To clarify something: I dislike fakeclaiming as town, but this particular game kmd is referencing, I CLAIMED SCUM IN TWILIGHT AS A TOWNIE, as a last ditch effort To try and give us a chance To win. (multiball, tried to make both scumteams shoot me)In post 3824, Kmd4390 wrote:I mean. I did see him claim scum once to try getting two scum teams to shoot him and it almost worked. He was so convincing that I could have sworn he was scum in that game before I looked back on in a couple of weeks ago.
I was just about to ask your opinion on this lolIn post 3830, Cheetory6 wrote:I kind of feel like Spiff would hate winning here as scum with how he's performed. Like, he felt annoyed when everyone called his performance in biochem a lurkerscum win. I suspect he'd be kind of embarrassed by winning Team Mafia by underplaying this hard?
My point was more that you are capable of being a good bullshitter. I believe you that of you fakeclaim in this game, it means you are probably scum. I dont think you'd do it as town considering that's already been done this game and led to a quickly check on town.In post 3826, UnaBombaH wrote:To clarify something: I dislike fakeclaiming as town, but this particular game kmd is referencing, I CLAIMED SCUM IN TWILIGHT AS A TOWNIE, as a last ditch effort To try and give us a chance To win. (multiball, tried to make both scumteams shoot me)In post 3824, Kmd4390 wrote:I mean. I did see him claim scum once to try getting two scum teams to shoot him and it almost worked. He was so convincing that I could have sworn he was scum in that game before I looked back on in a couple of weeks ago.
I do not otherwise fakeclaim as town, and if I ever leave crumbs, I mean it.
Thats where I am except that it's been discussed enough now that it should just happen.implosion wrote: Regardless of any of that my feelings on massclaim right now is that it's hard to tell if it's a good thing or a bad thing, but i personally just want more info to work with. And @Chara, I think you at least somewhat underestimate what setup speculation is capable of. It's very difficult to do well here,
you're going to need an amazing reason for asking investigatives to tell the last scum what kind of results they could have before the scum is forced to claim.In post 3827, UnaBombaH wrote:I'm also pleading that we don't force Ari to claim, but instead all ask for our investigative to step forward, and claim their role, but no results yet.
The fact that it has happened before doesn't exactly make me feel better about it.In post 3830, Cheetory6 wrote:Like, he felt annoyed when everyone called his performance in biochem a lurkerscum win.
yeah the one thing i'm really confident with atm about una is that his reason for wanting claims to go like this, whatever that reason may be, isn't as good as he thinks it is.In post 3834, Chara wrote:you're going to need an amazing reason for asking investigatives to tell the last scum what kind of results they could have before the scum is forced to claim.In post 3827, UnaBombaH wrote:I'm also pleading that we don't force Ari to claim, but instead all ask for our investigative to step forward, and claim their role, but no results yet.
I feel like it'd be a factor. Probably not enough to write him off as town.In post 3835, implosion wrote:Do you think that annoyance would be sufficient motivation for him to be more active in this game? I feel like efforting as scum isn't as simple as not wanting to have a win be called a lurker win.
like.. I just said that "no results".In post 3834, Chara wrote:you're going to need an amazing reason for asking investigatives to tell the last scum what kind of results they could have before the scum is forced to claim.
lol @ everyone who was salty about thatIn post 3830, Cheetory6 wrote:I kind of feel like Spiff would hate winning here as scum with how he's performed. Like, he felt annoyed when everyone called his performance in biochem a lurkerscum win. I suspect he'd be kind of embarrassed by winning Team Mafia by underplaying this hard?
Could be. But I also feel like I know what type of a role the remaining scum has (if not Vanilla).In post 3837, implosion wrote:yeah the one thing i'm really confident with atm about una is that his reason for wanting claims to go like this, whatever that reason may be, isn't as good as he thinks it is.
I am!!In post 3842, Spiffeh wrote:P.S. I have an hour or two to spare soon so I'm gonna maybe do things?!?!?!?
Who's excited?!?!?!
Yeah that's not what Chara is saying.In post 3839, UnaBombaH wrote:like.. I just said that "no results".In post 3834, Chara wrote:you're going to need an amazing reason for asking investigatives to tell the last scum what kind of results they could have before the scum is forced to claim.
I asked u.
Have you met my wagon ari?!In post 3829, implosion wrote:Firebringer is still my best guess for scum atm. But I really don't feel great about it.
What are the reasons we're writing off Spiffeh? He's done townish things but he's also just constantly substituted telling us that he's town and selfmetaing for actual content.
no, you're correct.In post 3845, implosion wrote:Yeah that's not what Chara is saying.In post 3839, UnaBombaH wrote:like.. I just said that "no results".In post 3834, Chara wrote:you're going to need an amazing reason for asking investigatives to tell the last scum what kind of results they could have before the scum is forced to claim.
It's saying that for instance if someone says "hey, i'm a rolecop" then even if they don't claim their results, suddenly it informs the last scum if they need to be truthful about their role or if they can safely fakeclaim.
Etc.
(correct me if I'm wrong, Chara)