Mini 1991: Taking Justice Into Our Own Hands (Town Win)

[Beefster]

Official Vote Count 1-13

Guy_Named_Riggs

(4): Luca Blight, Havo, Eddie Cane, Awoo

Lexa

(3): Mumble, northsidegal, havingfitz

Cedrick

(1): Papa Zito

Mumble

(1): Lexa

northsidegal

(1): rb

havingfitz

(1): Cedrick

Not Voting

(2): Alexcellent, Guy_Named_Riggs

With 13 players alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2018-02-23 09:00:00)

Previous Vote Count | Next Vote Count

[Luca Blight]

He's also not the only one who would rather lynch one of the PR claims, so you can't say that is hugely AI.

This is a closed setup and there is a definite argument to lynching one of the PR claims at this point.

[Lexa]

I'll be around this evening to focus on game

[Luca Blight]

@Mod

- prod on NSG, if you don't mind?

[Beefster]

@Mod

- prod on NSG, if you don't mind?

Sure thing. She's overdue by 9 hours anyway. I spaced checking for prods last night.

[havingfitz]

He doesn’t even consider he could be wrong.

I'm not 100% sure of anyone's alignment in this game other than mine.

Just flying by the keys of my keyboard I'd say:
I'd call Lexa a >90% scumread.
I'd call Mumble a >70% townread.
I'd call Cedrick >70% scumread.

[Beefster]

northsidegal has been prodded

[Cedrick]

To be fair Cedrick, you haven't exactly wavered on your read of Lexa.

fair point but I have seen 2 people I scum read use very bad reasons to push for her lynch, those bad reasons are reasons I really don't see coming from a town mindset.

I know nobody is listening to me but fitz backing off when lexa made her post and then re-voting her for more bad reasons was very suspicious. His 180 on mumbles is also suspicious and then outright believing him and now basically saying he is town and he believing mumbles when doctor is probably the most commonly used fake claim just screams he is scum. It's possible they are both scum, but i'm fairly certain fitz is scum. Let's also consider that he wants lexa lynched no matter what, he won't push for my lynch until others push it OR after lexa flips. There is no way he can be that certain mumbles is town or that certain lexa is scum.

Nobody can have that kind of certainty.

[Cedrick]

so you can't say that is hugely AI.

it is to me. I already said anyone pushing a pr lynch today is suspicious to me.

[Papa Zito]

eff

VOTE: riggs

[Cedrick]

eff

VOTE: riggs

What would a lurker lynch do for us?

Also why didn’t you mention fitz in your write up? I’d love to hear detail thoughts on him. If you town read him I’d really love to hear how you spin his actions in a town light.

[Havo]

Is there anyone who still has any doubts as to how I came to my Day 1 Disclaimer play style?

Gotta love Day 1s. Lol.

[Papa Zito]

I’d really love to hear how you spin his actions in a town light.

my ironymeter just exploded

[rb]

northsidegal has been prodded

bad

[rb]

eff

VOTE: riggs

What would a lurker lynch do for us?

Also why didn’t you mention fitz in your write up? I’d love to hear detail thoughts on him. If you town read him I’d really love to hear how you spin his actions in a town light.

okay i need to know your real account now because i must figure out if being this dumbtown is a possibility i believe in

[rb]

only my lack of esteem for your ability keeps me from thinking you're scum at this point Cedrick.

[Eddie Cane]

Hey everyone, please stop insulting and discrediting the smartest player in the game.

[Alexcellent]

I think Eddie's town and I was probably wrong about numberQ. Really like his posts and reads.
Pretty decent town lean on fitz too.

The GNR wagon makes me uncomfortable, but 626 does suck, and his inability to produce any sort of reads to Awoo earlier doesn't help. But then I'd think scum could at least post a few bullshit reads on the spot if they had to, so I don't know. A lot of the votes on him could probably apply to me too. I can see him being scum? But I'm on the fence.

[Alexcellent]

Kind of want to lynch Lexa still, but I think I'm on team "don't lynch PRs" for today.

I could see value in a Cedrick lynch though

[Papa Zito]

don't do this to me

[Alexcellent]

I also challenge the people who town read mumble to explain what he’s done that’s protown. Cause I don’t see anything in his iso.

He hasn't done anything protown, he hasn't done anything that I view as scummy either. Town read on him is gut and I can see his aggression being town aggression. To be fair I can see his play coming from both alignments. Except for his claim. His claim makes no sense from any alignment.

[Alexcellent]

Mumble info for those who don't know him

I've played with Mumble twice. Once me S v him T; I, to quote Transcend, dominated him. Second, I subbed due to other reasons (lol hi Havo you were one of the other reasons xd), he S v me T. I don't know if this is a rule for his meta, but I do know he lurked the FUCK out of that scum game and not as much as the town game. He wasn't a beacon of activity, but he posted what I'd call "sparsely" as town and essentially prodged as scum. And, as town, I remember fighitng him as scum was the most annoying shit ever because kinda like Fitz he kept throwing completely garbage arguments and acting like he'd made some god catch off a false positive. The thing is, he got EXTREMELY emotional and angry, and it was believable. I firmly believe off of a p e r s o n a l i t y a n a l y s i s that activity and emotion will sort Mumble accurately later on, so he's off the table for now for me. This is also because I townread him so far; the comments about him I've seen ITG are best demonstrated by Zito's "a bunch of snark". IIRC, and havo or mumble (lol) can correct me if I'm remembering wrong, he did not have that same type of snark as scum at /all/. I think his dickishness and Lexa interactions are pretty likely town. At the very least, everyone voting him can fuck right off for now unless you explain why he's scum and not bad.

so ? ^

so what? your post means nothing to me. I am not really a fan of meta personally and I certainly can't trust meta reads of people who I think could be scum

I find this weird. "Not a fan of meta personally" but 62 - one of Cedrick's first posts in the game - is digging up another player's meta.
Just find this post to be a bit too dismissive.

[Cedrick]

That really isn’t meta though.

[rb]

don't do this to me

LOL

VOTE: Cedrick

im sry papa

[rb]

i can unvote and you can vote and be first on the wagon if you want