Team Mafia 2018: Mafiosi Revolution (Over)

[Aristophanes]

So that catch up lol

Gah!

[Ether]

Day 4, Votecount 23

---

I wanna join it, but I need to cut back (cut back)
I wanna play it, but I know I'd probably crack
I'd wanna try it, but for panic attacks (attacks)
I wanna risk it, but this game is venomous poison
It's poison, running through my veins
It's poison
But this site's all that's kept me sane

-[

Poison,

Alice Cooper

]

3 Aristophanes (Firebringer, Cheetory6, Chara)
2 Ginngie (Patrick, UnaBombaH)
1 Chara (Kmd4390)
1 UnaBombaH (Ginngie)

3 Unvote (Aristophanes, implosion, Spiffeh)

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.
The deadline is in (expired on 2018-02-23 01:00:00), on Friday, February 23 at 1:00 am EST.

---

[Aristophanes]

Spiffeh Iso done (well, the latter half mostly skimmed, but the parts when his scumteam was alive were actually read.)

I'm pretty sure this is the last scum guys.

[Ginngie]

and?

[Kmd4390]

Cheet, Mathdino gave me a reads list with like one-line reasons. I'll paraphrase it but it might be after my v/la ends. After I post it you can let me know what you want more details. I'm already noting his read on you as one thing

Here's that paraphrased one-liner list:

Chara: He's convinced this is scum based on trajectory on Mulch and Cabd

Spiffeh: Says he should have been more helpful so far and there is no reason to town read Spiff but later glances at past vote counts and says this is town

Una: Doesn't like the trajectory on Mulch at all. Feels like this lynch has to happen at some point to get the conversation out of the way.

Cheetory: Noted that Cheet went after Cabd on Day 1 until Assemble came in. Knows Cheet wants a town read, but asks that anyone who has Cheet as obvtown do a town case.

implosion: The case has already been made by other people

Don't lynch:
Ginngie: Bad choice

Patrick: We all know he's obvtown

Aristophanes: At the risk of using a "he wouldn't pick scum" argument, he wouldn't pick scum. If he hasn't done anything by LYLO go ahead and lynch him.

Firebringer: Basically confirmed town but can't say why in the game thread. I asked for the reason for this and it makes sense to me.

[Spiffeh]

(well, the latter half mostly skimmed, but the parts when his scumteam was alive were actually read.)

lol

[Aristophanes]

and?

So VOTE: Spiffeh I guess?

Pending further reading but it feels right.

[Ginngie]

No like

why

[Firebringer]

Aristophanes: At the risk of using a "he wouldn't pick scum" argument, he wouldn't pick scum. If he hasn't done anything by LYLO go ahead and lynch him.

I hate u right now

[Kmd4390]

To be fair, he said that before you said you'd have issues with it. Also I know you'd never pick scum so I'm townreading you.

[Ginngie]

Lmao KMD really

[Kmd4390]

Lol no not really. He's town for other reasons.

[UnaBombaH]

Una: Doesn't like the trajectory on Mulch at all. Feels like this lynch has to happen at some point to get the conversation out of the way.

Ah, thanks for making this simple for me.

Kmd is scum guys.

VOTE: kmd

[UnaBombaH]

I mean like, wanting to save the wine from Ginngie and Ari to Lylo is absolutely a good thing.
For a scum to do that is

The contrast of Mathdino saying that I'm a lynch that needs to happen vs saving a slot like Ari/Ginngie to LyLo doesn't make sense.

[Cheetory6]

Cheetory: Noted that Cheet went after Cabd on Day 1 until Assemble came in. Knows Cheet wants a town read, but asks that anyone who has Cheet as obvtown do a town case.

Ah yes this completely explains everything.

[Cheetory6]

Spiffeh: Says he should have been more helpful so far and there is no reason to town read Spiff but later glances at past vote counts and says this is town

Holy.

[Cheetory6]

I'm actually thinking about resorting KMD for how absolutely shit the Math readlist is tbh.

[Kmd4390]

I mean like, wanting to save the wine from Ginngie and Ari to Lylo is absolutely a good thing.
For a scum to do that is

The contrast of Mathdino saying that I'm a lynch that needs to happen vs saving a slot like Ari/Ginngie to LyLo doesn't make sense.

I understand thinking that on Aris, but Ginngie is just obvtown. Aris is probably town too though. Did you even look at my link? The point that he always does things as town is wrong and that game proved it.

[Kmd4390]

He wants the following clarified:
-the fact that he made that list at daystart
-says not to Lynch unabomb after the claim
-He never had cheet as a scum read.
-I misunderstood him on spiff. VCA only made unabomb his #2 scum pick over spiff but after unabomb's claim he's back to Chara or spiff being scum
-the only issue he had with cheet is that he'd expect scum to avoid voting mulch until assemble replaced in and was obvscum.
-He's at the following list for scum picks in order: Chara, spiff, implosion, cheet, Ginngie, unabomb

[Chara]

i just really can't get past being his top scumread.
it's just so convenient. "Chara was defending Mulch day 1 and had Cabd as tentative town based on his claim until the claim proved false."
like, the claim was always going to be false. scum Chara should have known that. it's a defensible position, but shallow.

[Chara]

i mean, has he seriously

still

not cased me? have you?
it feels like your reads have stagnated and you're just repeating Math's. i know you were on v/la but it was like that before, too.

[Chara]

also Ari, you really must explain why Spiffeh feels right for scum. :<
or i can't

not

lynch you.

[Kmd4390]

Wouldn't it be more "convenient" to have Aris and Ginngie as top scum reads?

i mean, has he seriously still not cased me? have you?

Wasn't it at your request that I posted it?

it feels like your reads have stagnated and you're just repeating Math's. i know you were on v/la but it was like that before, too.

I used his as a starting point today but I posted my reads. They're close to his, sure, but i had next to nothing at daystart and now I like my list I posted like 5 RL days ago.

[Chara]

in that case, i very definitely forgot about whatever case you posted.

i think it's most convenient to have a scumread that won't get lynched that you can keep pushing for the entire game. if i were Math i would be a lot more frustrated about the fact the last scum is pretty much unlynchable, i suppose..?
i don't even though. there are a few reasons it seems fake.

[Chara]

*i don't even know. god, i'm getting so sloppy.