Team Mafia 2018: Mafiosi Revolution (Over)

[Spiffeh]

I think it is

[Kmd4390]

i don't think one game of meta should be considered evidence of anything, personally. in both instances.

It's evidence that the idea that he only plays this way as scum is false.

[Cheetory6]

I think it is

stop being wrong about everything.

[Chara]

it's not evidence he's town.
he plays like this more often as scum + nothing so far to show a town process should not equal a townread. at best you could argue he's null.
your example was also from day 1. it's now day 4 and he still hasn't shown what he's promised.

[Ginngie]

Cheet

wat if

you voted Ari

for like a second

[Cheetory6]

haha
ur a funny 1

[Ginngie]

feck

[Ginngie]

I try

am sorr

[Chara]

what is it we're arguing about?

[Ginngie]

CHEET WONT LOVE ME ANYMORE

[Ginngie]

and...

I doin' a missin

[Kmd4390]

it's not evidence he's town.
he plays like this more often as scum + nothing so far to show a town process should not equal a townread. at best you could argue he's null.
your example was also from day 1. it's now day 4 and he still hasn't shown what he's promised.

Based on meta, I agree with a null read. Factor in that my team and I don't believe he'd be likely to pick scum and he's a town read. Is there a non-meta reason that says otherwise? Because I don't have one and don't recall seeing one from everyone else.

[Firebringer]

Cheetory I think ur vote is broken.
Try voting ari to see if it works

[Ginngie]

We've asked him to explain reads and he doesn't.

So.

[Kmd4390]

Is there scum motivation to do that when he's about to be lynched for it? Or do you think scum would be more likely to try to fake it when they have to survive multiple lynches?

[Chara]

there's no town motivation either.
it just means he can't.

[Ginngie]

there's no town motivation either.
it just means he can't.

[Ginngie]

WE LITERALLY HAD CABD?

HOW IS THIS AN ARGUMENT

[Kmd4390]

So are we lynching a null read then or am I missing something?

[Chara]

i'm not arguing it's a scum strategy.
the absence of town evidence is scum. Ari can't explain his reads. if he's town it means he was really unable to get into the game and i feel for him but there isn't really one good argument for town Ari.

[Cheetory6]

Ari has an hour to make a post explaining his spiff thoughts.

[Chara]

So are we lynching a null read then or am I missing something?

that's how townhunting works.
you're

voting

a null read. your argument for scum me recently was

literally

that you had reasons to townread everyone else.

[Cheetory6]

So are we lynching a null read then or am I missing something?

His Mulch interactions really suck.

[Firebringer]

Ari has an hour to make a post explaining his spiff thoughts.

U keep buying him time for no reason

[Chara]

and he isn't a null read. being unable to explain oneself is scummy. it's why Assemble was obvscum, in a more extreme case.