Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[Bingle]

I got prodded, I have no reason to reevaluate my solve, I’m vaguely waiting for people to be done arguing.

[PenguinPower]

Well then. Let’s just move on.

VOTE: jjh

[Bingle]

VOTE: jjh

[Bingle]

Good game, it was me and Sakura the whole time and she still has a vig shot.

[SirCakez]

ok all this "waiting for someone else to do something first" stuff is not giving me town vibes from any of you, it seems like TP is the only one actually trying to solve here

[SirCakez]

oh there was hammer that works too!

[jjh927]

That doesn't work at all, no, because that gives me fucking nothing and I'm now entirely reliant on you guys just solving the game

[jjh927]

Up until now I could at least input into the process but yeah

Okay, gut reaction is Bingle has been being disingenuous since he replaced in

[jjh927]

But yeah I was hoping to have some interaction that wasn't just being immediately hammered, although this is scum indicative in itself

Other than that, best of luck. You all did have a lot of reasons for me being town that you managed to ignore so the circumstance is heavily of your own making

Also my last will is out of date

[jjh927]

I was heavily wrong on T3 and you limmed there in spite of me, so who knows- maybe you'll get the last scum

Acting like the game is "autowin" in a situation like this is dangerous though because I have no clue who the last scum is and I wanted to be able to more conclusively say if it was Bingle or not before moving forwards

You guys honestly looked at interactions between me and T3 and came to the conclusion they were faked? That shit's on you. I played this game atrociously, don't get me wrong- but I should probably have been one of the easiest reads in the game right now

[PenguinPower]

Acting like the game is "autowin" in a situation like this is dangerous

I do agree with this. I don't really agree with anything else you said.

Oh, except this.

I was heavily wrong on T3 and you limmed there in spite of me, so who knows- maybe you'll get the last scum

[tired person]

jjh, as someone who didn't even vote you, could you please stop blaming everyone for the fact that you were a consensus scumread? this is not a sportsmanlike behavior at all.

if you want to help town win, then instead of being toxic, why don't you post your thoughts as to what makes bingle likelier scum than sircakes?

[jjh927]

It's more that I'm annoyed at being quicklimmed than anything when I was holding stuff back specifically to help generate content

[jjh927]

If anything I'm most annoyed at the offchance that Bingle is town here because out of everyone, I think he should know better but has been able to get away with voting me. His approach to my slot since shortly after he replaced in was primarily focused on picking faults rather than making deductions

[jjh927]

so basically there is a chance that he is town and has just quickhammered me

That's the frustrating part

I can't just take the objective evidence that he's been taking a disingenuous approach to my slot that is the quickhammer and say "Yep, he's scum".

I needed a drawn out conversation where I could get a reevaluation out of him if he was town

[jjh927]

I don't know

That's basically the problem


Jingle isn't gonna show before Firebringer locks the thread anyway, even though he cast the hammer vote and would have every reason to be refreshing this thread frequently as town


Maybe ask him in what way my play this game was similar to vengeful ghosts because I can assure you my dayplay in that game was nothing special and bringing it up as a good scumgame only serves as a means to increase paranoia about me

[jjh927]

To elaborate on earlier, I also don't think Jingle misses the human aspect of my PT with T3 and if he was town he'd have gone looking for evidence of that in my posting and actually weighed it up. Essentially, if I was scum, T3 would have neighbourised me on a purely mechanical level and then every aspect of that interaction would have been faked. That seems like something that can be lost on most of the people voting me but I am certain that with this kind of mechanical aspect to it that Jingle would specifically look into this in a way he did not. He just came out of being prodded and immediately voted me while I had indicated I wanted to interact with him here

[Firebringer]

After being able to ditch his companion Rose, Cid spent his time investigating the city at night.

Day 6 - Lindwurm
Vote Count 6.02 Final

jjh927 [4][ELIMINATION] Sircakez, Sakura Hana, Penguinpower, Bingle

Sircakez [1][E-3] tired person,


Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 1) : jjh927

With 6 Alive, It Takes 4 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-02-10 11:44:00)

Mod Note: No mod notes

[Firebringer]

jjh927 was eliminated.

He was a member of Shadow Garden

Spoiler: Role PM

Flavor Name:

Chi

Alignment:

Shadow Garden

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win Condition:

You win when the Cult of Diablos has been eliminated.

[Firebringer]

jjh927 left a last will:

I've been in a PT with T3 which he apparently made with the invented neighbouriser and he seems pretty towny.

Interesting that I've ended up dead though. Best reason scum could have to kill me is that they might think I am Cid

[Firebringer]

Night 6 Deadline is (expired on 2024-02-04 10:00:00). Please submit all actions and last wills prior to this.

[Firebringer]

Sakura Hana was killed last night.

She was a member of Shadow Garden.

Spoiler: Role PM

Flavor Name:

Alpha

Alignment:

Shadow Garden

Abilities:

You have no special abilities.

Win Condition:

You win when the Cult of Diablos has been eliminated.

Welcome First Chair of Shadow Garden,
You have been granted the following power from Shadow:

Watcher

Abilities:

Each night you can target a player and be notified of any player who visited them.

[Firebringer]

Sakura Hana left a last will:

t's nice to know that my gut that was saying that T3 was scum trying to increase the suspect pool was correct, so i'm inclined to believe the cleared people are indeed cleared.

Based off my previous post in the thread:
"Cakez and TP are cleared based on associations with flipped scum, TP doubly so due to STD's meta assesment of Ceph.
Bingle is cleared via Kawaii's meta."

Last scum is within jjh/PP/Wheme.

The neighborhood thing still sounds like whack to me, i think the safest bet for an elimination is jjh while we still got 1 miselim remaining, make sure Wheme claims tho.

These are all my night results:
N1 - Kyouko was visited by Pooky.
N2 - STD was visited by Pooky.
N3 - Bingle wasnt visited by anyone.

[Firebringer]

After being able to ditch his companion Rose, Cid spent his time investigating the city at night.

Day 7 - Sanctuary
Vote Count 7.00

Lurking in Shadows (Not Voting - 4) : SirCakez, tired person, Penguinpower, Bingle

With 4 Alive, It Takes 3 to Eliminate.
Deadline is (expired on 2024-02-18 11:44:00)

Mod Note: No mod notes

[tired person]

so there are two options:

we can no-lim, and if we choose to do that then we should not post anything this day phase aside from votes to no-lim and definitely not discuss reads as this will give scum an advantage in approaching the final 3. this will give ev of 1/3.

or, you guys can decide to sheep std and sakura and treat me as confirmed town which will basically result in an ev of 1/3 anyway. i don't really care which option you choose but i do think i'm most likely to die if we choose first option. or i guess we can also sheep klick and have bingle as a confirmed town.

i'm going let you answer this and then probably vote no lim.