Open 453 - SCIENCE! ( Game Over! )

[Venmar]

Votecount 3.0

[L-2] Rainbowdash:

[L-2] Equinox:

[L-2] Robocopter87:

Not Voting

• Rainbowdash, Equinox, Robocopter87

Deadline

• November 8, 2012

Mod Notes

• No one is V/LA
  
• No other notable mod votes atm.
  
• If i make a mistake in my vote count at any point, please let me know so i can correct my error(s).

[Rainbowdash]

This is stupid. Its now strong town reads vs town read and I still seriously have a hard time even trying to force a case on somepony. I dont think I can really use any VM-CES tells too much because that was obviously the mason pair since D1 and was a major factor in having Tierce be the PoE type lynch day one.

@Equinox - What was your reasoning to vote Tierce day one?

I seriously almost want to just vote Equinox here because I just cannot for the life of me see Robo being scum here. Problem is I feel like I have to first assume Equinox is scum to make any sort of point that im not laughing at myself for bringing up. Day one from Robo though is just so ungodly town I cant get over it, even remove the town tell he hit - Tierce and him as scum after D1? I just do NOT see it.

[Equinox]

Let's dance.

Vote: Rainbowdash

Robocopter87, I'm town, so please vote Rainbowdash. Admittedly, I've got nothing on Rainbowdash except that I'm fairly certain that you aren't Tierce's partner, so that's something you get to sort out yourself.

Preview edit: Well, now, since we agree that Robocopter87 can't possibly be scum, how about we skip the formalities and get right down to voting each other?

[Rainbowdash]

Vote Equinox

Yeah I think doing anything else is just delaying for no good reason.

My question to Equinox still stands though regarding the Tierce vote. I saw the VM-CES pairing and having Robo town left it at Equinox-Tierce-Riss as possible scum. With Riss getting wagoned and obviously having no clue who the masons were hurting their position quite a bit, it ment that other scum probably did not know who the masons were either. Equinox however like me knew the mason team, so why would Equinox not help her partner out by just feeding them information that would stop them getting wagoned hard? This ment that no matter which of Riss and Equinox were scum, it should be with Tierce. Its also why I had to be vauge because it relied on the fact that VM-CES were masons.

Thats what the "bizzare bus" would have been, Equinox not helping their partner through daytalk when she didnt stand to gain enough town credit to win if Riss was lynched to win the game, and Riss suddenly getting or something like that the mason team helped her. It would have been a bus where the bussing scum gained little to nothing because town cant intentionally withhold info from scum.

Really I think thats my best case for the Equinox lynch is I am town in that I saw the lack of Equinox-Riss as a possible scumteam and got Tierce lynched because of that, when doing basically anything else led to the Riss lynch. Its backwards from the normal cases, but I feel anything I actually make as a case isnt that good.

[Equinox]

Might as well answer this.

@Equinox - What was your reasoning to vote Tierce day one?

Timeline time!

While I was looking into Tierce's case on Cogito Ergo Sum, I noticed that Cogito Ergo Sum had a strong read of Voidedmafia, and Voidedmafia was behaving similarly towards Cogito Ergo Sum. That was confirmed when Voidedmafia responded to Rainbowdash's question about Voidedmafia's strongest town read. That left me to sort out the other 4 players.

It took me about a day and a half to eliminate Robocopter87 and, subsequently, Rainbowdash, which left me with Riss_ and Tierce. Cogito Ergo Sum wanted to lynch me and Riss_, so I asked him to compromise with me and lynch Riss_ on the condition that, if Riss_ flipped town, he was free to push my lynch.

Between that and Rainbowdash voting Tierce, there's some hullabaloo between me and Tierce. When Rainbowdash votes Tierce, I decide to switch over because I figured Tierce would be a harder lynch than Riss_ on account of Tierce's play style, so I should take any opportunity to lynch the harder to kill of the two.

Preview edit: You should've been like me and just not posted a case at all, then maybe Robocopter87 would have to do actual work~

[Robocopter87]

I laugh at this three man LyLo.

[Robocopter87]

So here is the point where I ask myself, "Who is scum?"

The answer is Equinox.

VOTE: Equinox

[Robocopter87]

Reasons:

1. Tierce voted Equinox in her first post.
2. CES never made a single accusation towards RBD. He did however vote Equinox.

I feel very strongly that I just won us the game.

[Equinox]

Town lost.

[Robocopter87]

I don't believe you.

DONT LIE TO ME

[Equinox]

Why the fuck would I lie to you? The game is over.

[Robocopter87]

Because scum often do that to screw with people's minds.

Anywho, I was going to pick you anyway. It was better for me to just up and vote than sit around and mumble

[Rainbowdash]

Seriously why cant I ever be on same team as Equinox it seems

[Robocopter87]

Well played, RBD.

Well played.

[Robocopter87]

Ugh now I feel bad about this game.

[Robocopter87]

Shoutout to venmar though, you did epically. Usually I got a few things I say to first timers. But heck man, you did it beautifully.

[Venmar]

Votecount 3.1

[L-1]

Rainbowdash:

Equinox

[LYNCHED]

Equinox:

RainbowDash, Robocopter87

[L-2] Robocopter87:

Not Voting

• Nobody

Deadline

• November 8, 2012

Mod Notes

• Game Over

[Venmar]

Flavor

The group looked at each other closely, now all standing in the center of lab. The remaining students were RainbowDash, Robcopter, and Equinox. The trio seemed to have a "face-off". They all knew that this was going to end right now, either they catch the killer, or watch as the killer kills the other two are clean. Insults were hurled at each other, cruses and accusations, and before they knew it, Robocopter and Rainbowdash turned on Equinox, looming over her with dominance and anger. Robocopter brandished the long, sharp knife that they found sticking out of Voided's deceased body, approaching Equinox with a threatening stare.

Equinox started to yell and shout, demanding that she wasn't the last killer. She started to back up, knocking over stools, chairs, and lab equipment as she did. Robocopter kept chanting reasons for why she was the killer, he kept advancing, and he didn't waver. When Equinox was finally pressed against the back of a wall, she stared at Robocopter in total fear. As Robocopter raised the knife to strike her down, Robocopter stopped himself when Equinox murmured Rainbowdashe's name. Stopping himself midway, Robocopter lifted an eyebrow, curious as to what she meant. When asking for Equinox to clarify, she said that Rainbowdash was nowhere she could see.

Behind Robocopter, he could hear the faint singing of a man. As the singing grew louder, he lowered his arm and as he began to turn around to see what where Rainbowdash went, he could feel a long, cold barrel press against the back of his head. The coldness seemed to as if sting Robocopter, sending a million chills down his spine. He froze in place, staring at Equinox with dread, realizing how much of a fool he was. Standing there, he quickly deciphered that Rainbowdash was standing behind him with a pistol pressed against the back of his head. Not just any gun, Tierce's gun. The gun that "disappeared" from Cogito's body a few nights back.

Rainbowdash was mumbling and singing to himself, somekind of a tune was stuck in his head and he was repeating it out loud. When Robocopter tried to raise his voice to ask the meaning of his betrayal, Rainbowdash frowned and pressed the pistol harder into Robo's head, causing him to shut up instantly. Rainbowdash leaned his head to the side for a second, taking a look of Equinox, seeing her fear and vulnerability standing there. She kept glancing into Robocopters hand, who was still firmly holding the knife. Shaking his head and making that irritating tsk tsk sound, Rainbowdash prodded Robocopter once more, who received the message and dropped the knife.

Satisfied, Rainbowdash smiled wickedly and started to sing loudly, enough to make the lyrics audible enough for the other two to hear.

" My Little Pony... "

BANG

The sound of the loud crack echoed throughout the entire lab as Rainbowdash pulled the trigger from behind Robocopters head. Equinox shrieked as millions of small brone fragments splashed over her head, being only able to glance the large spray of blood that burst from Robocopters forehead after the shot. She screamed in fear as she heard the loud thud as Robocopter collapsed like a large sack of potatoes, landing right in front of her. Looming over his dead body was Rainbowdash, smilling, the pistol already raised and aimed at her head as well.

" Friendship Is Redemption... "


....




....




....




....

BANG

Equinox

, a

Vanilla Townie

, was Lynched & Executed Day 3

Robocopter87

, a

Vanilla Townie

, was Executed in Endgame

RainbowDash

, the

Mafia Encryptor

, Surived and Won Day 3

[Malakittens]

Well played Dashie.
Also awesome modding for your first game Venmar. Keep it up.

[Venmar]

The Game is over, and has been won by the Scumteam! Below are the roles, night actions, and some flavor.

The ScumTeam

Rainbowdash

- Mafia Encryptor

Tierce

- Mafia Goon

The DayMasons

-

Cogito Ergo Sum

-

Voidedmafia

The Vanilla Townies

-

Robocopter87

-

Equinox

-

DoomYoshi ( Originally Riss_ )

Night Actions

Pregame

- Tierce murders Dr.Venmar by shooting him three times.
- Tierce takes the keys, RainbowDash takes the

Encryption

Key.

Day 1

- Robocopter ( The hammer ) kills Tierce with a pool of acid

Night 1

- Rainbowdash drowns Cogito Ergo Sum in a toilet, reclaims Tierce's pistol.

Day 2

- DoomYoshi is "lynched" but poisoned soon after by Rainbowdash.

Night 2

- RainbowDash sneaks up on Voidedmafia and stabs him to death. An Assassination.

Day 3

- Equinox is executed by Rainbowdash after being lynched.

Endgame

- Robocopter is shot in the back and executed by RainbowDash.
- Rainbowdash wins the the game for the scum as the last man standing.

Quick Topics

- Graveyard QuickTopic = http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/88St3HkTjKJ
- DayMason QuickTopic = ??? ( The Masons can reveal is they wish )
- Mafia QuickTopic = ??? ( The Scumteam can reveal if they wish )

[Robocopter87]

Nice manipulation, RBD. You really had me.

Sorry town & Equi, I did what I thought was best.

I don't think i've ever properly lynched in a LyLo situation before.

[Tierce]

Well done, Rainbow. ^_^ Excellent resolution on that know/not know the mason pair.

If you want to reveal our QT, it's fine by me.

[Rainbowdash]

Don Dashie is back.

You can post the QT if you want. I think most of the discussion was if I should pull the bus that I did because its absolutely something I would have done there as town given the masons were obvious and who noticed it. The Robo tell was my VT one where early on comments were such that he was going to be VT or scum and I knew he wasnt scum... it also gave a good faux mason partner for me that may get a reaction out of real masons and have any VT back off a bit.

[Tierce]

Scum QT: http://www.quicktopic.com/48/H/dyrqJ3tsrfFSr

Yes, that 'mason tell' from you was what I decided to push as something I had been convinced of, which would give a good "wait, what" reaction as to why I was convinced my partner was one of the masons.

[Venmar]

Thanks for the positive feedback guys

I enjoy writing in general, especially stories and novels so writing flavor just comes naturally to me and I feel like the game is nothing without it, so writing out flavor is like a mandatory task for me, as well as one that I feel should be good. I don't know if you guys enjoyed the little scenes I did in those flavors regarding how you guys died, but I enjoyed writing it even if it didn't have any impact on the game itself. I am also generally a neat freak, so putting a Votecount on every page is compulsory for me, as well as writing out the first few posts of the thread as neatly as possible. I tried my best to be consistent enough to make votecounts, watch for replacements, prods, and rule breakage.

As for the game itself, I wasn't keeping up with the argument as much as I would like to, but I was really expecting the town to win Day 1, not being because of Tierce's lynch but because of how frighteningly accurate Cogito's reads were and how town he just was in particular. If Cogito stuck to his initial scum reads:

Dash-Tierce, calling it now.

- Than I think town could have won. I think that how obvious Cogito and Voided made it that they were masons gave Dash and Tierce an advantage, as you would see in their quick topic where they explain it all, i wont even risk trying to explain it wrong. Overall though I think the games was fantastic, great job by Dash who solo'd the game throughout with great help from Tierce, and good effort by the town. Although I think they could have done with a bite more thinking and less quick lynching.

Thanks for letting me mod guys, and giving me such a beautiful playerlist for my first mod game on this site