A warlock, a werewolf, and a vampire... [Game Over]

[Gentleman 4]

This is ridiculous.

[Lady 7]

G7 seemed to be an elitist jerk. He got eliminated early, so I wouldn't be surprised if he spoke as if his partners were incompetent and bragged about town.

Do you agree?

Not really, I think it's more likely he was using AtE and Lamist to try to get to the next dance phase

That's a false dichotomy. He could do both. Being mean and AtE are not mutually exclusive. How do you think G7 treated his partners?

[Gentleman 1]

Can both of you talk about Rosalina 2 because that's my strongest SR rn

Lady 4 has this constant style of asking other people to bring up things she's adversarial to
specifically so she can gnaw at them
over and over again
planning from the getgo to oppose them, never giving any appearance of genuine curiosity of the other players' point of view
i don't think I've seen a cycle like this run so consistently before
but it seems to make more sense for someone who has everybody's rolecards than someone who doesn't
it's certainly considerably less town indicative than being able to just run out with a hot take, the way L6dewgong recently did on nagito and the way l3sherlock entered the game
I don't get why my townread on this slot is so lonesome
i mean I guess it isn't people are voting there
but like L7blue says people don't mean it, I think it is actually a bad slot
the most favorable interpretation is a quirk of her particular adapation to a large
but directly contradicts the exact style of play she said was ideal in like her 3rd post so maybe it's just a sequal to 7bandana

I think I can see this. I think it's a good scum play to ask questions with the predetermined intent of dismantling them, it appears to be solving but also contributes to an agenda

anyway since I'm probably going to have to at least take a break soon, I'll try to do ISOs on L4 and G2 now, and depending on my conclusion I'll vote them or some other pair

[Lady 7]

probably doing an ISO of gentleman 7 without context isn't that helpful for relational tells

though that reminds me of how weird gentleman 7's proposal to lady 4 was

hmm

It's a great starting point. I'll never have the exact context y'all did. It's why I am checking my work.

My mind is drawn to L4 and L6. Both of those are weird. G7 is melodramatic towards L6 and random towards L4.

[Gentleman 5]

How do you think G7 treated his partners?

I don't know

[Gentleman 9]

I know the objective thing is to ask G2 and L4 to leave because it increases our lynches but I don't SR either.

I'm not sure that is correct and I encourage you to reread the rules.

[Lady 1]

Look it's very simple

We have 4 days to lynch 2 pairs

neither of the 2-4 pairs are in anyone end game and haven't been. If they're town we should flip them sooner rather then later to focus on the wolves. If they're wolves? Great!

[Gentleman 5]

Most players aren't going to enter an anonymous dance game and be hostile with their scum partners, though

[Gentleman 5]

This is ridiculous.

Why is it ridiculous?

[Lady 1]

I do agree that 1 of the pairs should leave though

[Lady 7]

This is ridiculous.

What is ridiculous?

Pedit - G5, You don't have a clue based on his play but you felt compelled to shoot down my theory about how G7 treated his partners?

[Lady 3]

proof town can misread this setup I guess (not revisiting that read based on the rep's play)

[Gentleman 5]

Neither pair is going to leave, we're going to have to use our votes.

[Lady 7]

Most players aren't going to enter an anonymous dance game and be hostile with their scum partners, though

Agreed but G7 reads like the type that would.

[Gentleman 5]

This is ridiculous.

What is ridiculous?

Pedit - G5, You don't have a clue based on his play but you felt compelled to shoot down my theory about how G7 treated his partners?

I don't get what your theory is getting at. I think the proposed theory is unlikely.

[Gentleman 9]

unrelated, but I think G8's characterization that gorilla boy has a seal fetish and is just sitting in the corner writing seal erotica after being asked to leave is so funny to me. i crack up every time his name gets mentioned.

[Lady 3]

It's not actually detrimental to town to fail to meet deadline for the record. Slightly beneficial. Gamestate health in a general sense is its own topic but mechanically town is rewarded the fewer hammers that have been thrown by the end of the 8 days.
---------------
I can conceive of versions of G7bandana that were cocky asshats in the PT, well meaning oafs in the PT, and even timid in the PT and comparatively bold here to play to his wincon (least likely option). I'm not sure how much ground can be covered speculating about it but it's not impossible you figure out some kind of likely scumteam dynamic I

guess

[Lady 7]

This is ridiculous.

What is ridiculous?

Pedit - G5, You don't have a clue based on his play but you felt compelled to shoot down my theory about how G7 treated his partners?

I don't get what your theory is getting at. I think the proposed theory is unlikely.

Then why didn't you ask? Why did you feel compelled to interject and say no when the question wasn't even to you?

[Lady 1]

I disagree with L3 but given what happened last time I said that I'll hold my tongue and just say there's more pros than cons.

[Gentleman 5]

I'm simply giving my opinion on your speculation

[Gentleman 6]

It's not actually detrimental to town to fail to meet deadline for the record. Slightly beneficial. Gamestate health in a general sense is its own topic but mechanically town is rewarded the fewer hammers that have been thrown by the end of the 8 days.
---------------
I can conceive of versions of G7bandana that were cocky asshats in the PT, well meaning oafs in the PT, and even timid in the PT and comparatively bold here to play to his wincon (least likely option). I'm not sure how much ground can be covered speculating about it but it's not impossible you figure out some kind of likely scumteam dynamic I

guess

Eh fwiw I think he just got apathetic and gave the fuck up.

I've been there.

[Lady 6]

VOTE: Lady 2

[Gentleman 4]

If you can't read me, just no hang and figure stuff out after intermission(no deadline). Saying "they never endgame" is lazy IMO and I'm sorta townreading both G2/L4, so things change.

[Gentleman 4]

Are you guys scumreading me or L2?

[Gentleman 1]

I would be very satisfied with a G2/Rosalina 2 pairing that dies first

I would be very satisfied with you engaging me about your read on me, but it seems like neither of us are going to get what we want.

I don't really feel like I have anything to add beyond what I've said. This game isn't that long.

And L4, why G2? He's barely done anything.

Exactly. Other gentlemen have been better.

Including G7?

No I put him in same basket as G2

Why do my posts look scum motivated? Can you give an example of posts I made that were surface level?

I will do some quoting

No, but I do get scumread a lot for my playstyle by people who don't know me very well.

I'm kinda surprised to hear my reads being called surface level, though. That's not something I get often given that I usually try to look one level deeper than most people (beyond "who does this appear to benefit" to "who does the player THINK this would appear to benefit").

I'm not calling your reads surface level I'm calling your general play
I don't see you really trying to dig into anything

this is VERY interesting with how the last pairing worked out

I'll see how thing shake out but I'm definitely leaning voting this pair rn