Mini 1406: Sherlock Mafia (Game Over)

[Kthxbye]

[BBmolla]

This game is straight up Dance with Dragons all over again.

[DeasVail]

Rob, I would not be that against a sotty lynch. I just don't find them as scummy as D3x.

[Rob14]

If I follow onto d3x, can we all agree that sotty is next? If I can get some decent agreement on this (i.e. 3-4 of my town reads agreeing), then I'll give intent to hammer. Either way, we need a lynch soon because this day seems like it's been going on forever.

[Kthxbye]

I'm down

[sottyrulez]

If I follow onto d3x, can we all agree that sotty is next? If I can get some decent agreement on this (i.e. 3-4 of my town reads agreeing), then I'll give intent to hammer. Either way, we need a lynch soon because this day seems like it's been going on forever.

I'm actually not that thrilled with d3x's lack of reaction to the wagon on him coupled with his substantial lack of contribution in the thread, so I'd just say let's get on with it.

Proposing chain lynching is really crappy play, but it's really clear that we don't have any say in what's going on in the game at this point... so yeah.

[Rob14]

It's fine play when we consider the setup. If we have some agreement that you and d3x are both likely scum, then we should cut the discussion due to the probable setup.

[sottyrulez]

Is that a serious thought right now? Because we're on day two and we don't know the setup, making assumptions is just plain dangerous.

Do you have an actual suspicion of us outside the fact we don't agree with you? I wouldn't mind hearing about it.

~Sotty

[Rob14]

Is that a serious thought right now? Because we're on day two and we don't know the setup, making assumptions is just plain dangerous.

Do you have an actual suspicion of us outside the fact we don't agree with you? I wouldn't mind hearing about it.

~Sotty

I do, but you won't be hearing it. Based on my win-con and the public win-con released in the game-specific section of the rules, we're in a setup where I want the scum to know as little about the setup as possible.

[sottyrulez]

...*Sigh*

[Kthxbye]

Ok, I'm more then down with Sotty dying tomorrow

[DeasVail]

Rob, I'm fine with that if I don't strongly believe that someone else is scum and don't strongly believe that sotty is town.

I don't know if that's good enough though.

[Rob14]

Rob, I'm fine with that if I don't strongly believe that someone else is scum and don't strongly believe that sotty is town.

I don't know if that's good enough though.

I wouldn't expect anything else. Intent to hammer. Claim and final thoughts in d3x's next post, please.

[d3x]

post

[Kthxbye]

post

What's this d3x? Guilty post much?

[DeasVail]

It's quite an interesting post actually.

[Kthxbye]

interesting how?

[Kthxbye]

Hey d3x, wanna tell is who your bro's are? Is Sotty one of them?

[Herodotus]

It's quite an interesting post actually.

This. It's making me feel curious.

Although I am suspicious of sottyrulez, I'm categorically uncomfortable with chain-lynching. Maybe if the scum didn't have a NK things would be different but with it they can perform more manipulations, and planning the next day's lynch gives them more information.

[Rob14]

The reason I suggested it is because both sotty and d3x are in my null-scum category. I think we've gotten as much information from discussion as we need to say that scum is probably within like 3-4 people. At this point, I think lengthy discussion of who to lynch in future days will give the scum more info than it will give the town.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Vote Count 2.5

d3x (5)

– DeasVail, Jabberwock, BBmolla, Gummybear, kthxbye

Herodotus (2)

– d3x, Sottyrulez

Sottyrulez (2)

- Herodotus, Rob13

Gummybear (1)

- Feysal

Not Voting (0)

Deadline: Saturday January 26 @ 11:00 PM Eastern
Countdown: (expired on 2013-01-26 23:00:00)

[Rob14]

Vote: d3x

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Vote Count 2.6

d3x (LYNCHED)

– DeasVail, Jabberwock, BBmolla, Gummybear, kthxbye, Rob13

Herodotus (2)

– d3x, Sottyrulez

Sottyrulez (1)

- Herodotus

Gummybear (1)

- Feysal

Not Voting (0)

Deadline: Saturday January 26 @ 11:00 PM Eastern
Countdown: (expired on 2013-01-26 23:00:00)

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Another day, another suicide vest. A majority of you begin to chase d3x through the streets. He pulls out his cell phone as he runs yelling into it and you catch only the words John and shoot. Eventually you corral d3x and knock him out and throw the suicide vest on him. You walk away knowing that...

d3x

–

Sherlock Holmes blown up Day 2

When suddenly from a nearby window you hear a shot and as you glance over there you see John Watson and a smoking pistol before he ducks away. You look around and find DeasVail on the ground a bullet in his brain.

DeasVail

–

Miss Wenceslas shot Day 2

~~

A win condition has been achieved; congratulations to the

town

on their victory.

[Debonair Danny DiPietro]

Role PMs (thought they may have been revised slightly in terms of flavor) - From the setup it should be pretty obvious what the night actions were other than d3x targeted GummyBear with his Mycroft power on N1

You are

Sherlock Holmes

the world's only "Consulting Detective" and a damn good one at that. However, the actions of the world’s only “Consulting Criminal” Jim Moriarty is ruining your life and only his death or permanent imprisonment can make things right.

Abilities:

(A)

Mycroft Holmes

: Each night you may consult with your brother Mycroft on the identity of a player in the game. If that player is Irene Adler she will be put in contact with you and she will attempt to aid you in your goal.
(A)

Dr. John Watson

:

Once during the game (including immediately after your own lynch)

you may direct Watson to shoot someone. If you are no longer in the game Watson will listen to Irene Adler
(A)

Detective Inspector “Greg” Lestrade

:

Once during the game, during a night phase

, you may have Detective Inspector Lestrade arrest a player and remove them from the game. However, if you send Lestrade after a non-criminal that player will be mod-confirmed as town in the game. Additionally while Lestrade will act upon your hunches he will not act solely on the word of Irene Adler.
(P)

The Science of Deduction

: You have correctly deduced that

the Golem

is not involved in this fiasco but if he were involved his involvement would look like the below.
(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when Jim Moriarty (alias: Richard Brook) is dead or safely ensconced behind bars.

~

You are

The Golem

the contract killer and since Jim Moriarty is one of your biggest clients it makes sense to do all you can to keep him alive.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (ZZZ) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Irene Adler

aka “The Woman” and you use your position as a Dominatrix to hold compromising information and pictures as protection against the nefarious forces in the world.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty are eliminated.

~~

You are

Jim Moriarty

aka “Rich Brook” the world’s only “Consulting Criminal” and you are bored. Bored with the games and bored with ordinary Sherlock Holmes and frankly you don’t care if people die in the process of eliminating him because that’s what people DO!

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when Sherlock Holmes is dead or disgraced and imprisoned.

~~

You are

Jeff Hope

the serial killing cabbie. Since Jim Moriarity is sponsoring your crime spree it makes sense to keep him alive and well.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Edward Van Coon

the international banker and smuggler for the Black Lotus. Since you work for the Black Lotus and they work for Jim Moriarity it makes sense to keep him around.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Brian Lukis

the journalist and smuggler for the Black Lotus. Since you work for the Black Lotus and they work for Jim Moriarity it makes sense to keep him around.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Zhi Zhu

aka the Spider, an assassin for the Black Lotus. Since you work for the Black Lotus and they work for Jim Moriarity it makes sense to keep him around.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

General Shan

the leader of the Black Lotus. You either work with or more likely for Jim Moriarity it makes sense to make sure he’s safe from harm.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Miss Wenceslas

the owner of the Hickman Gallery. James Moriarty enabled you to come into a significant chunk of change and he would be most put out if you didn’t help protect him.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Jim Moriarty (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

Kitty Riley

a journalist digging deep into the mystery of Sherlock Holmes. Richard Brook is the key piece to your expose and if anything were to happen to him it would all fall apart.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Richard Brook (XXX) are eliminated.

~~

You are

DS Sally Donovan

the detective reporting to Greg Lestrade at Scotland Yard and you have always been suspicious of Sherlock Holmes but now you understand there’s proof that he’s nothing but a fraud. A man named Richard Brook is the key to Sherlock’s guilt and it’s incumbent upon you to keep him safe.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Richard Brook are eliminated.

~~

You are

Anderson

a member of the forensics team reporting to Greg Lestrade at Scotland Yard. For too long you have been bullied by and humiliated by Sherlock Holmes but now you understand there’s proof that he’s a fake. An actor by the name of Richard Brook is the key to Sherlock’s guilt and it’s vital that you help keep him safe.

Abilities:

(V)

Voter

: Each day you may submit your vote for who should be lynched. You may change your vote as often as you like until a majority has reached a decision.

Ability key:

(A) = active, (P) = passive, (R) = restriction, (T) = triggered, (O) = other, (V) = vote

Current Win Condition

: You win when all threats to Richard Brook are eliminated.