NY 215: HMS Erebus - Game Over!

[Nosferatu]

By definition all reasons are bad given I'm town.

mood lmaoo

i never gave one, i was actually midway through typing it before you posted that

[Scioness Sajj]

My gut reads are not at all like that. Comments on this from others please?

i guess what gamma means is that the rvs vote itself isn't really that ai but he feels it's more likely coming from scum

no
the RVS vote felt AI and I had a reason for it, but I had a gut "this looks wrong" feeling, rather than actually feeling like it was logical.
Maybe I should just use illogical in place of gut from now on
...
Wait what. What the fuck am I, Spock? (fyi I think the idea is fine I just wanted to make that joke)

well
you are not making any sense then

[Gamma Emerald]

I said it was illogical, didn't I?

[Purrcocet]

I might be wrong on Nosferatu. People who scumread me for bad reasons turned up scum in 4/4 of the most recent games I was in, on this and an alt. Gambler's fallacy applies though so Nos might just be the odd one out who is simply bad.

..what were you townreading him for to begin with?



ok i really want gamma to be town here
nos am i bugging

[Krazy]

Votecount 1.11

Gamma Emerald(3)

~ Purrcocet(34), Lapsa(52), Nosferatu(83)

Lapsa(2)

~ Completly Trustworthy(40), Gamma Emerald(89)

davesaz(2)

~ Akarin(17), popopopopopopo(15)

tictac(1)

~ Scioness Sajj(19)

Scioness Sajj(1)

~ tictac(21)

Nosferatu(1)

~ Garmr(7)

Malakittens(1)

~ Io(62)

Completly Trustworthy(1)

~ Saudade(62)


Not Voting (3): Hugo Stiglitz(11), Malakittens(36), davesaz(61)

With 15 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2018-09-19 07:00:00)

FLAVOR

The Franklin expedition included two ships, the HMS Erebus and the HMS Terror. The HMS Terror had been retrofitted from its time during the War of 1812, where it had taken part in the bombardment of Fort McHenry--the basis for the "Star-Spangled Banner."

[davesaz]

I might be wrong on Nosferatu. People who scumread me for bad reasons turned up scum in 4/4 of the most recent games I was in, on this and an alt. Gambler's fallacy applies though so Nos might just be the odd one out who is simply bad.

..what were you townreading him for to begin with?

I dislike his posting style and disagree with some of his conclusions but on balance it looks like he's doing things to gamesolve. It isn't a specifics kind of thing where I can make post by post comments, it's more a running balance tone/gut thing.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think I'm at the levelest my head has been since this kerfuffle started so while I'm good I'll try to work on my other reads (fyi I already have tictac as town and saudade as townlean, plus maybe some subconscious reads)

[Lapsa]

mmmm... fancy subconscious reads. my favorite

[Malakittens]

Back here later maybe.

[Saudade]

only one vote on CT
this game sucks

[Saudade]

3 votes on Gamma
this game sucks

[Saudade]

No one voting Malakitty anymore
this game might be redeemed

[Akarin]

Oh lol I thought Akarin was going after me

I mean, I did think that section was quite scummy and I'm definitely considering you a good lynch, but my Dave read is stronger and more interesting to push I think. Plus some of the votes on you have been weird. *cough* tictac *cough*

[Akarin]

Serious question: what was Gamma's massive dramatic improvement?

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh lol I thought Akarin was going after me

I mean, I did think that section was quite scummy and I'm definitely considering you a good lynch, but my Dave read is stronger and more interesting to push I think. Plus some of the votes on you have been weird. *cough* tictac *cough*

Actually tictac’s push makes a lot of sense to me
As for my “dramatic improvement” that’s an overstatement firstly and secondly it was me not continuing to push something when I had been presented with a decent counter to my thinking.

[Akarin]

Buut, this read used to be "gut", and I really don't see what changed to give it reasoning.

It's a gut feeling
but there's a reason why I have that gut feeling
hopefully that makes sense

My gut reads are not at all like that. Comments on this from others please?

My gut reads that don't have reasons still have reasons, like meanie-pants=scum cat/anime avatar=town, "ur" instead of "your"=serial killer. I try to ignore these.

I feel like "gut" might be good cover for when it's a weak read and people will say your reasons are ridiculous, but there are always reasons.

vote:dave

i agree with akarin

Wow. Ya read the game in 3 minutes.
Wish I was that fast

popopo's reading the important parts

[Akarin]

As for my “dramatic improvement” that’s an overstatement firstly and secondly it was me not continuing to push something when I had been presented with a decent counter to my thinking.

That's it?

tictac please confirm

[Akarin]

Umlaut's vote was clearly a RVS joke based on how much I get wagoned/mislynched.

it's rather funny that anyone read anything into Umlaut's vote because it was clearly a RVS joke about how Umlaut (and almost everyone else) ends up voting mislynchbait me at some point.

Weird how Dave has brought this up twice since I started pushing him. One more time to really drill it in, marketing style.

[Akarin]

Yeah I don't like the waffling and fencesitting in post 601, good catch Dave.

[Scioness Sajj]

Reading 468 was quite discomforting to me. First Tictac started out by saying that Gamma might be scum due to having an informed POV, but that was because Gamma was acting differently than usual and breaking their meta read. Any player has a general knowledge of their own meta and can change it, so I don't see what the problem is. Then they went on say another post looked towny, but could have been made by scum, ending that section with no conclusion. Afterwards there were a few comments on posts, but several were completely irrelevant to the game and the only two that contained actual content involved agreeing with other's points. I feel like that post has little substance despite being relatively long.

you could really benefit from shortening your posts.

but i agree, tictac has been mostly talking around, there was only that early nonsense read on lapsa and a vote on me just now.

[Akarin]

By definition all reasons are bad given I'm town.

TBH I don't even know if you've given a reason. I'm going to work. You can do us all a favor by enlightening me and the thread, or you can be an ass and make me look it up when I'm not working.
Guess which one I'm betting on.

But this is the basis for a scumread on Nos?

[Scioness Sajj]

i will catch up but it won't happen today. it will also most likely not happen this weekend since i'm working, i will try

we will see

[Akarin]

Scioness:

@Scioness:

this akarin - tictac interaction is something

what is the something
i got the impression that you wanted to make it look like there was a something when really there was not a something

I want to know this too

[Scioness Sajj]

you are bad
mala is town

what makes you think mala is town?

what makes you think shes not?

she jumped off a wagon due to association with nulls with low content.
does it in need to be explained further?

she did the what now???

she decided to unvoted nos becasue pox7 and lapsa jonied the wagon. she doesn't have a read on them, they are null, and they give no reasons for their reads, she also asked them for elaboration and now is in the state of waiting for them to change their playstyle(?)

pretty premature reaction if you ask me followed by really passive approach to solving those two slots that scared her off so easily.

so why is she town?

[Scioness Sajj]

Akarin i'm 20 post away from this, i will get to it.