In post 796, Yume wrote:It confirms yo of being scum because you are defending your partner/buying him time by stalling on questioning him.
Lucky is not confirmed scum...?
You cannot confirm me as scum when Lucky isn’t even confirmed of scum. Even if Lucky was confirmed scum, I could still be a townie ‘defending’ scum. (But I refute the accusation that I am defending him).
If you are town, your inability to reason either argument stops you from talking to me like a townie.
That's how mafia is played here. I don't know how you play it on your home site, but that's the way it's played here, and you gotta accept that eventually if you wanna continue playing here.
Whatever the chains placed upon me
Whatever the prison, my soul has the key
No money can buy, no power can still
No burden can break the unshakeable strength of my will
In post 801, Yume wrote:That's how mafia is played here. I don't know how you play it on your home site, but that's the way it's played here, and you gotta accept that eventually if you wanna continue playing here.
That’s how
you
play on mafiascum. Don’t confuse the two. The 7 other players even in this game possessed the ability to talk without resorting to AtE/miss-reps/narrow-minded confirmation bias.
ProHawk. You’ve been very quiet today (D3). You are slowly fitting into the stereotype of ‘scum-letting-town-destroy-eachother-without-pointing-the-lynch-in-any-other-direction’.
Probably you yeah. The most intense scum reads today are Yume’s s/read of you and your scum read of Yume. Neither of you are strong town reads/leans of anyone. Pro/Me/Luca are second tier probably.
In post 807, Agent Dale Cooper wrote:ProHawk. You’ve been very quiet today (D3). You are slowly fitting into the stereotype of ‘scum-letting-town-destroy-eachother-without-pointing-the-lynch-in-any-other-direction’.
I don't actually get this, who is the town destroying eachother in your hypothetical?
In post 760, Luca Blight wrote:Please explain why you believe the NK's have been to set you up for the lynch? Surely the fact no-one has really pushed you today (you're the only one associating the NK's with yourself) in itself disproves that theory?
Also Hawk, where do you stand on the Lucky v Yume battle?
I actually have been suspicious of this and thought Cooper was trying to frame me for it. Don't see any reason for the 4nxiety kill except for that purpose.
In post 543, Agent Dale Cooper wrote:I am not opposing it. I am saying, "yes, ah Occam's razor. That is a good point. However, what other reasons are there to scum read Lucky?"
Why are you using your last game as the golden rule for all other games, that's a logical fallacy. You can use it to help you make a decision this game, but to make it a black and white rule is naive.
Can you answer my question about ProHawk:
does Occam's razor point to ProHawk being scum?
In theory, yes, but that would mean too much scum in this game, and my scumread on Lucky is stronger.
In post 547, Yume wrote:Luca as scum is largely based on PoE.
This makes no sense - how can I be scum by POE when you heavily scumread Lucky and admit that Occam's razor also points to Pro being scum?
And I don't believe you have ever really explained your strong Pro Townread, so if you could do so then that would be appreciated.
In post 776, Yume wrote:And this is your scum strategy, btw. You plan to have me lynched and then mislynch Pro as he'd be vulnerable to your dual attack without me to defend him. I solved the game.
In post 798, Yume wrote:Also, the reason I don't think the game will end today is because I am Bartleby Pischore, that's why.
So if you're town BP and are lynched today the game won't end? This simply isn't correct.
And can you confirm your role-claim and give the exact wording of it, just so we're clear.
Incidentally, no-one has even been attacking Pro today (or yesterday for that matter); you've just been overly town-reading him for no apparent reason. Don't try and act as though you've been defending Pro against being lynched when that's never even been a consideration since you entered the game.
In post 807, Agent Dale Cooper wrote:ProHawk. You’ve been very quiet today (D3). You are slowly fitting into the stereotype of ‘scum-letting-town-destroy-eachother-without-pointing-the-lynch-in-any-other-direction’.
I don't actually get this, who is the town destroying eachother in your hypothetical?
It's a simple hypothetical - any potential combination of players tearing their hair out and pressing eachother (excluding you, who's still in
Whatever the chains placed upon me
Whatever the prison, my soul has the key
No money can buy, no power can still
No burden can break the unshakeable strength of my will
Btw, if you think only I have confbias, then you are in for a nasty suprise, because 90% of players here are confbiased. You are just playing this game with the remaining 10%.
Whatever the chains placed upon me
Whatever the prison, my soul has the key
No money can buy, no power can still
No burden can break the unshakeable strength of my will
Whatever the chains placed upon me
Whatever the prison, my soul has the key
No money can buy, no power can still
No burden can break the unshakeable strength of my will
Well, Pro didn't quickhammer for one. Lucky is my stronger scumread, and due to Pro scumreading Lucky, Pro/Lucky scumteam is unlikely at this point. That's why I townread Pro.
Whatever the chains placed upon me
Whatever the prison, my soul has the key
No money can buy, no power can still
No burden can break the unshakeable strength of my will
