Mini 1907: Oddrole Mafia IV (Game over)

[TheBrie]

Well Desp and I have already claimed. I'm guessing Guilty killed Joe and Joe killed Guilty. Which means Desp killed Chick and is Goo now.
Question is whether Chick became Goo when she stole the vote from Massive N1 or someone else N2.
I'm not sure of the dynamics, but since no one lost a vote tonight but Chick was killed, I'm guessing it was N1 which puts Massive as Goo also and Snarky or Creature as the remaining scum.

[TheBrie]

Alternatively, Desp is scum and this whole thing is an elaborate ruse. He and A40 were working together along with Guilty.
Which means there's one Goo who may or may not be Massive. I think that's a bit crazy though. All that points to it is the fact that Desp scumread Chick and said nothing about A50. It's a bad theory.

[TheBrie]

Further debunking that crazy second theory is the fact it would place all three scum on Chickadee's wagon. So Desp is Goo.

[Creature]

Okay, I think it's Snarky or massive.

[Creature]

idk about black goo.

[Desperado]

cults suck lmao

[TheBrie]

Yeah, they do. I think for town to have any chance at winning we'll need to lynch you today. And you were the one person I was most confident about. So sorry.

I've looked at more about Goo mechanics, and I think I got it wrong. Chick only just becoming Goo seems more likely now. Which does clear Massive as not Goo.

[TheBrie]

Okay, I think it's Snarky or massive.

You think what is Snarky or Massive?

[massive]

I'm thinking. It's gonna take a bit. Only one mafia left is nice though.

[massive]

And we probably need to know:

Mod: In a hypothetical situation where a vote thief would steal a vote and then die, would the person stolen from still have no vote?

[eagerSnake]

Actions resolve in such a way that as many roles (and/or actions) will take effect as possible. If there are any conflicts, it follows the list order of standard action resolution. If there are still conflicts, it goes by which action was submitted first.

Given this, the stealvote action usually resolves before the person dies.

[TheBrie]

The really important question is whether becoming Goo nullifies non kill actions. The Wiki seems to indicate it does, but it's vague.

[TheBrie]

So if Chick steal a vote from Goo, she just becomes Goo and as she isn't a vote thief anymore nothing happens.
Other possibility is that Chick was more than a vote thief. She didn't claim, so she could have had another action.

[SnarkySnowman]

can we get a mass goo-claim?

I am not goo

[massive]

Scum did a good job of obscuring votes but this still needs a scum:

Rautherdir

(7) [LYNCHED]: Desperado, SnarkySnowman,

GinghamDog

,

Chickadee

,

Javajoe24

,

podoboq

,

boring

Guess what Snarks it's you.

[Creature]

I am not goo

nor am I.

[Creature]

massive?

[Creature]

I guess we'll have to lynch Desperado if only no one else claims goo.

[massive]

Probably a scumclaim from Snarky since he knows as well as anyone moving onto A50 that Chickadee would have come on and hammered him.

given how he's played this game I'm not convinced Snarky is even reading the thread

Oh GL you had me pocketed good.

[Creature]

massive, are you goo or not?

[massive]

I'm not. But I also don't think all three of those can be true.

[eagerSnake]

VC 3.01

Not Voting (5): Desperado, TheBrie, SnarkySnowman, Creature, massive

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch.

Day 3 deadline in (expired on 2017-06-16 19:53:11).

Prodding Desperado.

[Creature]

Yeah, Desperado likely got goo.

[Desperado]

lmao i'm confirmed goo, bud

vote: snarkysnowman

[TheBrie]

Reasoning for scum!Snarky seems solid.
We've got to lynch Goo though, or we'll be 2-2 tomorrow and they win. They might still win, but I'm going for the narrow chance of escape. Sorry Desp.
VOTE: Desperado