like the approach to fire/delta is just. his win condition is to achieve their lims, I dont believe he ever sorted anyone outside of them, me/datisi basically we were never evaluated.
it's like if mafia didnt really try to hide anything lol and just went for what they needed as directly and egregiously as possible. which I guess is kinda unfair to accuse someone of being but like I never reach this slot not needing to be resolved
basically my gut alone views datisi/delta/nurse with like 66/66/66 of being scum but I think from an objective point: if merlyn-nurse is town it's like welp I dont think it was findable and if nurse is scum and we dont beat him I very much need to be blaming myself
I think the other two slots have simply both looked vaguely villagery enough to support this
why am I town? is it only because delta and fire are scum to you?
Basically. You COULD be Scum, but my gut is telling me it's one or both of those two. So I see you as little more than an obstinate obstacle who makes no attempt to try to see Scum among either of those two.
There’s a weird difference where you say “my gut is telling me it’s one or both of these two” and then you behave as though you’re insanely confident in your two scumreads. I think a lot of aspects of your play don’t make sense if you’re not literally 99.99% sure fire and delta are scum. so then it’s a wolfy difference when you talk about them as weakly as “it’s my gut saying there’s either only one or both are scum”
For example, I don’t believe u genuinely considered the possibility that Datisi or i is scum. Like maybe for a moment you acknowledged it’s a possibility but if you’re not really really confident it’s definitely just fire/delta like win the game, then the amount of thinking about whether datisi or me is mafia just doesn’t meet what I expect to see in village play
yeah I read the nurse iso again more deeply and focusedly than I ever have (2 minutes)
I think it is just a really egregious wolf
first the confident delta stance happens at the start of today. I will only vote fire or delta. THEN the decent reasons start to pile on. fire is a similar story, it's almost always been basically just the page 60 tsq interaction thing; it is just not really buyable progression for me
sorry for inactivity - yesterday was Weird and now i'm sick in bed with a (what is probably) stomach flu
skimming a bit so i don't get booted, i would probably vote for delta rather than nurse. like the quickhammer yesterday almost feels too risky and as i said i don't think delta is genuinely evaluating me here. i don't think his thoughts are fake bc scum wants to vote out other scum but
idk how the fact he's now voting nurse fits into this
yes i am aware this means the look for scum is even more difficult since they can honestly scumhunt, or like more honestly than in a basic setup, and nurse kinda isn't doing that
i don't think i should be clearing fire/sheep but i am not in the position to actually reevsl them rn
I will straight up disregard all reason if you have a PR dream again. You can come back and be like, “I dreamt that Locke is a N2 Bulletproof Multitasking Cop and Self-Targeting Doctor,” and I will go, “Okay, Locke kill it is then.”
In post 949, Random Nurse wrote:
I really ought to self-hammer to punish this Town, for refusing to listen and work with me, but then that would be going against my win condition.
This particular Town *does* deserve to lose, though.
basically my gut alone views datisi/delta/nurse with like 66/66/66 of being scum but I think from an objective point: if merlyn-nurse is town it's like welp I dont think it was findable and if nurse is scum and we dont beat him I very much need to be blaming myself
I think the other two slots have simply both looked vaguely villagery enough to support this
i guess this is right but aaaahhh
it's leaning too far into "i wouldn't feel bad about this flipping town" territory and i think in my past experience whenever it gets to that point it ends up being the wrong move
but also literally every time i can't bring myself to do anything else bc like you say. what if he really is just obvscum who decided he didn't want to try