Guns & Roses VI [Game Over]

[Taly]

i didnt expect either of you to return to the thread to townread the other, and now im having to rethink everything about the way ive approached this

[WhemeStar]

Wtf

[WhemeStar]

How’d you guys elim so fast

[pisskop]

Fastest Rose in the West

[pisskop]

[Taly]

How’d you guys elim so fast

Because everyone made me town leader

[Taly]

I chose violence

[Taly]

pisskop

where are you at with reads?

[Taly]

I'm genuinely stumped

[Titus]

It may not be kosher but I'm ruling out Wheme because of how short night was.

[Malakittens]

I'm not thrilled about the fact that you have 1 townread

I might be warming up to a pisskop town tho
So it’s 1 and a half lol

[Malakittens]

It may not be kosher but I'm ruling out Wheme because of how short night was.

It’s not kosher and I don’t think the mod would go fast night without everyone doing a PM

[Titus]

It may not be kosher but I'm ruling out Wheme because of how short night was.

It’s not kosher and I don’t think the mod would go fast night without everyone doing a PM

He wasn't around to do the kill. I bet he approved fast night previously.

[Titus]

I mean he could have set up a kill in case we limmed without him posting. But that's a bit feched.

[Taly]

I agree with

Titus'

take, it's unlikely and plus, I don't scumread him.

[Titus]

I want to push everyone to spew reads on Enchant/Wheme/Alisae.

I'm not convinced that any specific shot is a town-controlled one unless there is more input from the playerlist.

I think all three could be town,

I don't think Wheme's play makes much sense as any kind of gun.

If he's a mafia gun, openly claiming is very ??? like what's he expecting to get out of that? draw out town gun CC ? like town gun can just shoot him at night.

if he's a town gun, him responding to enchant's claim by saying yea i townread enchant is very ?? - like if he thinks he's 1v1ing enchant why would he say that?

so like if wheme is some kind of rose who's trolling and trying to draw a nightkill it kind of makes sense if he's a town rose doing it? like why would a mafia rose put themselves out there?

2ndly

I think enchant is town because the way he responded to being pushed felt like he was very much exasperated to think that I could possibly think he would do this song and dance as a mafia gun, which kind of bleeds into his posting like he's asking me if I think he's trolling and when I say yes his eyes kind of roll into the back of his head in annoyance and he vows to not talk to me - that's a p town reaction to being called a troll lol

thirdly

I think alisae's enthusiasm for mass claim / resolving the gun issue just feels very town - there's little reason for ali to insert into the wheme/enchant situation and force the issue as a mafia gun, ali can just let enchant shoot wheme and let the cards fall where they might. there's nothing for ali to actually disrupt in place - it feels a lot like a townie jumping the gun.


I would find it much more likely there are no mafia in ali/enchant/wheme than something like two mafia? if there's one mafia in the grouping I struggle to see who fits with a scum mindset.

Also this game does feel kind of stalled being that there's 3 days to deadline and some people have decided to ghost it.

for example Bulge/Mala & Dunnstral.

Bulge hasn't posted in 2 days
Mala hasn't posted in 2 days.

Dunnstral posted once on wednesday and once on thursday and niether post really bothers to push anything in the game state - just a very one liner comment focussing on talking about someone's comment about himself.

The thing is in a game state where Enchant/Ali/Wheme are town and town is focussed on the wrong area - then it makes sense to me that mafia would find it difficult to post and actively participate because they know the town is on the wrong path and they're fine just sitting on their hands waiting for the town to just off itself.

I find this more concerning for Dunnstral than the other two in relative terms because I've seen Mala/Bulge both flake out of games as town so I know they often sign up for games and just do not play them but for Dunnstral I think he tends to be more focussed on mech related issues and also scumhunt less when he's mafia.

[WhemeStar]

Wdym approved fast night

[WhemeStar]

It may not be kosher but I'm ruling out Wheme because of how short night was.

It’s not kosher and I don’t think the mod would go fast night without everyone doing a PM

Mala just slipped??

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Mala

[Titus]

You didn't approve fast night? I asked on a prior night so I figured he went with that.

I have it down to Taly or Mala anyway.

[WhemeStar]

No and the mod said in a previous message he only asked the people with nignt actions for fast night

[WhemeStar]

Mala prob missed that

[Malakittens]

I agree with

Titus'

take, it's unlikely and plus, I don't scumread him.

I mean we are practically in eol setting if we miselim today so no offense but I rather not mechanically clear someone from being scum bc they didn’t post in the thread between a day and a night.

[Taly]

You didn't approve fast night? I asked on a prior night so I figured he went with that.

I have it down to Taly or Mala anyway.

Are you basing this only off the timing? What is your read with

pisskop

?

[Taly]

I don't have any action so I never had to "approve" of a fast night if that's what y'all are talking about