Song Contest U-Pick - GAME OVER

[Agent Minnesota]

No escape from reality

VOTE: Garruk
For ruining it.

[Agent Minnesota]

This is for all you new people: I only have one rule. Everyone fights. No one quits. You don't do your job, I'll shoot you myself. You get me?

Vote: evilpacman18

Ninja-edit: Parama, your #2 doesn't make much sense to me. Why are you attributing not paying attention to the thread as a scummy action? It's obviously WIFOM either way, but scum do have inherently more motive to pay close attention to what they say in the thread, because they're trying not to look scummy. Town have the same motive in a way, but it's not as prominent.

I get you but your avatar seems to doubt me.

I really disagree that scum will want to pay attention more to the thread than town. Town needs to be constantly looking out for scummy posts to play to their win condition. I personally think the motivation is equal but if one is more likely than the other it would be town.

~Agent Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

3. Songs can be ANY ROLE and ANY ALIGNMENT.

VOTE: Pasch

Sup?

Serious vote for no reason, or just pissy OMGUS? Probably the latter. But then we get to a more interesting question. If the songs don't matter at all, why bother claiming them?

VOTE: Paschendale

[Agent Minnesota]

@Parama I get it I just don’t like his response to NS's vote if the flavor doesn't matter and NS knows it doesn't matter and it’s basically still RVS why he asked a pointless claim seems pretty obvious.

~Agent Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

@T-Bone

I am scum because I am what I am sincerely señor pie.

@Parama

I'm not defending per se, just questioning how you can open with scum finger pointing so early. Your jump to conclusions also includes assuming that I'm reading Garruk as town. I'm happy to conclude that you have no actual reasons for Garruk's scumminess.

Really? People always start with the scum finger pointing early; it's actually a really basic tactic. Why do you have such an issue with this?

[Agent Minnesota]

This is for all you new people: I only have one rule. Everyone fights. No one quits. You don't do your job, I'll shoot you myself. You get me?

"The only sensible way to live in this world is without rules, and tonight you're gonna break you're one rule."

~ Psi

[Agent Minnesota]

This is for all you new people: I only have one rule. Everyone fights. No one quits. You don't do your job, I'll shoot you myself. You get me?

"The only sensible way to live in this world is without rules, and tonight you're gonna break you're one rule."

~ Psi

I hate you I hate you so much!

^^^ Scumposting

How am I

not

responding townily?

--veil-cursed

Please explain how that post is scummy.
Also you have a lot of scummy reaction mostly in contradictions inconsistent play (yes I get you're a hydra but you seem to be inconsistent when claiming to post as the same person) and generally acting anti-town.

VOTE: Garruk

~Agent Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

So Generic, PecanPie, and T-Bone are town. T-bone and PecanPie for their response to Generic, more PecanPie than T-bone, and Generic is town for 188.

~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

So... I'm 100% up for voting any of the above three.

I also really don't like this.

[Agent Minnesota]

TBone & Nacho are also on the watchlist.

--Veil-Cursed

Why these two?

[Agent Minnesota]

I hoped to get support from others? Please show me where that happened.

It was a blatant attack on something you thought was an easy wagon to get started, there's no denying that.

This is just putting words in his mouth.

Also, I'm going to check through this thread over the weekend to see who has marked me as town. I'm going to say there's a 90% chance that one of them will be scum as well who are attempting to buddy me, ditto with those calling NS town. I also have another theory... but that will come into play a little later in the game (maybe a few days along, it's a tough one to do quite so early in the game, but come day 3 I'm sure plenty of information will be there).

This I do like it seems like good effortful scum hunting that could get some useful results. Just wondering why you’d check for scum in the people calling Not science (well actually I kind of get this one) and you town over other players getting called town?

So... I'm 100% up for voting any of the above three.

I also really don't like this.

And your reason for this would be....?

It feels like really blatant fence sitting, you named off three of the most popular scum candidates in this game and said you'd be happy lynching any of them, it feels like you're leaving it open for wagon jumping later.

~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

@Parana your argument feels really WIFOMy do you have anything else besides what YOU think he was thinking?

[Agent Minnesota]

@Parana your argument feels really WIFOMy do you have anything else besides what YOU think he was thinking?

Yes, what he did on those posts. Or are we going to take Mafia to it's basic level, in which case EVERY case is "what I think he was thinking", is it not?
[quote="In post 215Prana & Generic, answer this truthfully: Are you on the same team?

Not a clue, I believe we aren't, but I couldn't say for certain as I only know my role PM.[/quote]
Well not really. For example there is a big difference between him voting not science, and you saying he thought it would be a big wagon, opposed to him casting the vote and giving evidence he thought it would be a big wagon (like trying to get to people to vote with him).

~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

Whoops messed that up.

[Agent Minnesota]

Sorry I've been missing for a few days’ time to make a post about my general feelings in this game.
1. Can someone explain to me this M45tin guy to me? I think he is a parody of some player I don't know. This isn't really game relevant but I'm just curious.
2.

Generic will probably turn out town, I just don't like how he's been acting, the ate he's been displaying, and the open call to lynch him with a vt claim. I don't have much experience with him yet so I don't have much to go on other than feel with him.

Mast is just annoying.

Don't see the problem with this post if had called Generic scum then said this I would, but he had him as "scumish" and I think that makes a big difference. That seems like a normal town feeling to have. Thinking someone is more likely one alignment but to have this nagging gut feeling from their posts that causes you to hesitate.

3.

And ex-fucking-cuse me, but seriously? Five votes in two pages for this? Are you kidding me?

</rant>

Now, I'd like to grow to not suck at this game, which I evidently do 'cause I get five votes in two pages, but by the gods below, give me a chance.

I need to give Maenara a better look but for now this screams "noob town" though the "town" part of that is the more interchangeable word.

4.

Vigmeat my ass. If you actually read anything in the thread you would notice my point that I am basically regigigas in large games.

Don't try to push things on others. Step up to the plate.

I actually just meant the flavor. It's just... wow.

Hi guys, I start very slowly in big games so you won't see any posts from me for a while.

My role PM makes me want to kick babbies.

I see it

Who should I vote

If you don't mind I'd like you to explain this? If you're on to something the rest of town could find the info useful. I hope it's not so obvious that once I ask this all the players think I'm an idiot. Lastly why are you asking someone else who to vote?

V/LA

Until Saturday, I need to do work and read over this game again. Also I need to get my other head in here to actually make a second post.
I need to talk to my other head, but last time I check we both still weren’t too big on Garruk and were wondering where he went. Also unless I notice what everyone is talking about my second time through I much prefer a Pasch wagon to Maenara one.

[Agent Minnesota]

~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

If you don't mind I'd like you to explain this? If you're on to something the rest of town could find the info useful. I hope it's not so obvious that once I ask this all the players think I'm an idiot. Lastly why are you asking someone else who to vote?

Simple

They're my townread

And when I townread them

I like to sheep them because it tends to make good things happen

Thanks for answering that? Though it was the least important question I had for you. Would you mind actually explaining what those three specific quotes mean?

[Agent Minnesota]

VOTE: caled I like this as a wagon. We will make a better post later. I don't like Formerfish.
~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

Honest question, do you want me to replace out?

I'm good with you. If I were to ask someone to replace out it would be Caled.

[Agent Minnesota]

Annoyed Nacho's been on unstated VLA lately.

Wasn't his laptop stolen or something?

[Agent Minnesota]

He almost definitely will. If your goal is to get Caled replaced (in other words, if you're aware that he isn't here right now and can't respond to any pressure) then you shouldn't like his wagon (because you know it won't accomplish anything). Yet there you are, voting him and then promising content later.

Well anything to say after it worked immediately after you posted this?
I was promising content because my partner said he'd caught up and was about to make a post.

I am back in a blaze of glory (and later lurking because of a busy schedule) with Caled's ISO Infographic^TM:

Spoiler:

Prana and Spyrex are at around the same level as Parama and notscience respectively. Pie kid is pieceofpecanpie but obviously there was no space for that.

At the end of the day, Porkens is confusing, notscience sounds like a poor tsun-tsun who wants everyone else in the game-senpai to notice him, Pasch is now a martyr and this game is the biggest clusterfuck ever.

VOTE: 50 Shades

This is a bad post. Really bad. Are you really saying that you took the time out to instead of making cases on those you found scummy, you just made a slightly fancier list of the players?
And even when you were pushed to explain your reason for calling people scum it's completely under explained, and bad.

#554 You claim to not like me but don’t say anything else, last time you mentioned me you were defending me. Care to let the rest of the class in on this?

I read your ISO you have 12 posts 8 of which are nothing, just prod dodges and fluff and even some of the content ones were not that great. Of course if some of your future posts keep up to this one’s level (or at least near it) I have no issue with you.
~Minnesota

[Agent Minnesota]

Nachomollie and cabdffery who are we going to be voting

I could potentially vote Porkens, Pasch, Spyrex, PoPP, caled, TBone, Hiraki

Why did we drop of this?

[Agent Minnesota]

I went away for an hour rofl

And fuck if I know but I like them for town better than some of the people here

Who are you talking to?

[Agent Minnesota]

mollie

Want to answer my question?

[Agent Minnesota]

Nachomollie and cabdffery who are we going to be voting

I could potentially vote Porkens, Pasch, Spyrex, PoPP, caled, TBone, Hiraki

Why did we drop of this?

No, I mean this question.

[Agent Minnesota]

So do most of you even have any actual reason for voting Hiraki? Or is this all just sheeping?

Nachomollie and cabdffery who are we going to be voting

I could potentially vote Porkens, Pasch, Spyrex, PoPP, caled, TBone, Hiraki

Why did we drop of this?

No, I mean this question.

@NS answer this.

[Agent Minnesota]

You made a post of people you were willing to vote we were on it. Then later without us having done anything new you removed us. So what happened?

[Agent Minnesota]

9. Agent Minnesota- how do you miss NS directly answering your question in #903? Ok, I see that you were referencing another question, but again you don’t see that NS actually does respond to you, you just keep on him like he is side stepping you all the way.

But I do really want to know why we dropped of NS's group of potential votes, when we have done nothing in between the two posts. The only thing that did change is that the two major people NS is sheeping didn't have me as a scum read. So seeing that irked me and I wanted Ns's explanation for it.

[Agent Minnesota]

Also NS missed me a few times as well and that's because the thread was moving at a really fast rate the past few days.

[Agent Minnesota]

@50 Shades you left us out, but that's because we haven't done anything recently.