In post 43, zMuffinMan wrote:Serene's argument is very convincing and is making me want to bus SB.
ok
VOTE: SB
In post 43, zMuffinMan wrote:Serene's argument is very convincing and is making me want to bus SB.
In post 295, pieguyn wrote:also Sakura is probably scum and Serene is like 95% town
@Sakura:answer my question in [post]186[/pos]?
In post 308, pieguyn wrote:
also interested in the reasoning behind this, even though I agree with the conclusion
In post 321, zMuffinMan wrote:
In post 301, Kagami wrote:Does sakura scum make sense given your negative utility aspect? (Yes/No/Irrelevant)
Why are you asking pieguy this? (Or rather, how would pieguy's thoughts on this matter compared to your own?)
In post 409, Rylai Crestfall wrote:
Actiondan: Cool with since he's actually posting (I also like what he's posting so)
In post 672, zMuffinMan wrote:general question for anyone that actually reads 655, what do you think of it? both in terms of its content and what it says about drezi's alignment?
In post 778, zMuffinMan wrote:In post 774, Kagami wrote:feigned belief that he had been vigged
mm... i have mixed opinions about this
just to be clear, are you referring solely to the reads list post or his whole reaction?
In post 786, zMuffinMan wrote:In post 784, Kagami wrote:Posting a reads list is a stereotypical thing you do when you believe you've been killed, which is well known
this is the main thing i'm internally debating at the moment
whether it is likely he is scum who thought "oh, in case it's a fake day vig, i'll do this because that's what's expected"
or whether he's town who thought it was productive (or expected)
and i'm trying to figure out whether i think it's likely he really thought he may have been vig killed
to be honest, the rest of his reactions to what he may have thought was a day vig don't look that bad to me
In post 789, Kagami wrote:
I think it's also a little weird to believe the SB-serious bananas thing might be a legit slip while also thinking AD is scum, but scum reads can mean independently scummy so meh. My neighborhood didn't get pre-game chat, though I think scum did in corpse bride.
In post 853, SXTLHGaiden wrote:
fun fact, he copied the alive people list and not the VC list.
Also i got my first pick, futo.
In post 932, zMuffinMan wrote:i'm not gonna use the gladiate today, mainly because i left it too late (my fault) and i'm waffling on who i actually want to see lynched plus there's a lack of claims on the table to ease this decision. if i'm still alive tomorrow, i can do it then
In post 1105, zMuffinMan wrote:In post 1099, Sky_Paladin wrote:That is not a full claim.
You have three spell cards and an ability.
I'm actually thinking this post was an unintentional town slip, given FakeGod posts role PMs in the scum PT and I find it highly unlikely he's scum who hasn't read his team's role PMs (or that scum all have exactly three spell cards and an ability).
The alternative here is he forgot or overlooked this.
In post 1107, ActionDan wrote:In post 1025, pieguyn wrote:I think Dan might actually be scum. I'm looking through his posts again and I don't see the town in them; he has a few scum reads, but I don't get the impression he's actually putting any effort into pushing any of his targets, as opposed to sitting around and looking like he's doing stuff.
Besides the fact that this comment applies to basically everyone who isn't you/Muffin this game, it's not my style to be in my scumreads' faces all the time. Unless I'm tunneling on one particular person since I've done that before. That isn't going to happen with kagami anyway since she hasn't answered the one question I asked her nor shown any response to the case I presented in one of my posts.
There are a lot of Sky P walls in the last few pages holy shit.
In post 1111, ActionDan wrote:In post 458, ActionDan wrote:VOTE: Kagami
I just don't like the all of a sudden Sakura vote on the heels of Pieguyn's budding suspicion. It's a vote whose reasons lie in the past and thus could have been acted upon much more immediately (even in the post where Kagami says Sakura is suspicious). Besides the timing of it, I find the reasons themselves for it weak, especially the muffin investigation thing. Since I believe that played out in the Pieguyn and her back and forth I'll mention I found that looked pretty legit there. And even were the suspicion solid it's abnormal that it's isolated in a sea of content that Kagami has really yet to touch.
This one
In post 1127, ActionDan wrote:In post 1116, Kagami wrote:You haven't thought about your own case
Apparently neither have you!
In post 1130, ActionDan wrote:In post 1110, Kagami wrote:What case?
Plus the fact you don't have an appreciable comment on it
In post 1147, ActionDan wrote:Kagami you can tell what's blatantly wrong with that paragraph that i would have noticed had i been town. Don't be afraid to speak your mind.
In post 1170, zMuffinMan wrote:it really would have been nice to have more time to think about the claims than a few hours before the deadline when there aren't more viable wagons
In post 1243, Kilgamayan wrote:Whoops I completely missed that Dan targeted Kagami >_> It still doesn't change my opinion of the two of them, unless Dan decides it's worthwhile to share anything for whatever reason.