NY 215: HMS Erebus - Game Over!

[Performer]

Purr - not getting a good tr from this slot either
--------------
Io - tr. Posts 474 & 477 show her trying to sort the scion slot. Her posts look town in her ISO, but I'm curious where Garm is in the below readslist:

I’d prefer Mala, Ct, Lapsa
Also wouldn’t be opposed to a Hugo, popo, Dave, or Scion lynch as I don’t have any hard reads on them.
Absolutely not lynching Gamma, Tictac, akarin, saudade, nosfu, or purr though.

That being said I’ll go vote for Lapsa until I’m convinced lynching out of Mala, CT, Lapsa is a better option.

VOTE: Lapsa

[Purrcocet]

Will have to sort the rest as I review ISOs again.

@tictac & purr - why are you guys voting me?

u replaced scioness scum

[Performer]

@purr that's the only reason?

Awaiting a few more replies to questions but one more I have right now - Lapsa were you talking about scion in your 855?

[Lapsa]

quite a peculiar question

[Purrcocet]

@purr that's the only reason?

she was scum, might i add
and sort of like cozily coasting so if its paragraphs u want i am not ur cat

[Performer]

@purr that's the only reason?

she was scum, might i add
and sort of like cozily coasting so if its paragraphs u want i am not ur cat

That's unfortunate because I am a cat person.

[Lapsa]

and I'm drunk. so no more posts till tomorrow

[Gamma Emerald]

Ye I like performer rn

[popopopopopopo]

and I'm drunk. so no more posts till tomorrow

afraid of scum slipping while your inhibitions are lowered?

[Gamma Emerald]

and I'm drunk. so no more posts till tomorrow

afraid of scum slipping while your inhibitions are lowered?

This is pox7’s best post so far

[Malakittens]

i have to agree

[Io]

I am new to forum mafia, this is my third game in this format.

I'd still like other people to reply to my 875 though, I think the players in this game have been strangely silent when it concerns him.

Performer, why is Umlaut replacing out because he didn't have time towny? Any player could become busy enough that they can't post, regardless of allignment. Also, do you think that Scioness wasn't coasting since you put it in quotation marks? If you believe she was accused unfairly, then why is Nos voting her because of that towny?

You know, this is one of the reasons I still don't trust you.
Like, something about people constantly bringing up that they are new just comes off as suspicious as the only thing I end up thinking is "why would they say that?" and usually it comes down to the player trying to make an excuse for bad play. Yeah, not everyone is super experienced, but 3 games isn't nothing and you have experience with Mafia outside of this format (and this is probably the easiest format outside of browser-game Mafia's like Salem and EpicMafia) so it doesn't really make sense why you would constantly be bringing up that you are new to this when you don't really fit the category of new and the excuse in general is just kind of scummy.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Io, I was answering Performer's question in 915 and wasn't making an excuse for bad play. I think the only other time me being new came up was in 36 when I answered my own question about my experience at mafia.

[Io]

Oh sorry I didn't see it was a response post.

[Saudade]

It's okay I wouldnt trust someone called Completely Trustworthy either

[Garmr]

davesaz(4)

~ Akarin(27), popopopopopopo(21), Garmr(31),Io(84)

@Krazy
Did you make everyone that was in mini normal 2023 town this game. because I like Akarin so far and I can see their logic and I have the same gut feel from that game on popopopo

Anyway a quick read list not ordered.

Town lean

Akarin
IO

Gamma

Null town-

Popopo

CT

Scum lean-
Mala

I do have some other scum reads and not just mala but I want to keep them to myself for now and see how they react.

This wagon gets better and better

[Garmr]

Garm – thoughts on nos – since you say you’re familiar with him? Also, you caught him due to 1 of your reasons of him coasting in that game. How come you didn't vote my prior slot for coasting, despite nos saying scion was coasting?

Different circumstances. I didn't catch him with coasting alone.

Nos why did you sr garmr? Garm , I think nos is town - my read on him hasn't changed since I last posted about him.

The posts on pg 38 are alarming. Hmm.

Everything in my post and a couple more things might as well dot point them

1.scum reads seem to follow general consensus.

2.Spent most of day 1 costing

3.A lot of his posts are just filler, Look at post 222 it adds nothing to the game and makes him look like his doing something.

4.Post like 484 seem to lack drive he doesn't captalise on it. In fact if you read through his iso. He doesn't really push anything to get information out of it.

5. Put himself in a position where he could lynch invis if he wanted to but waited to see how people would react. Was online for role reveal didn't put his thoughts down on invisible wagon. Put in a fluffy statement anyone could of made. Nos also made it clear that invis was a scum read early so I would think he would at least have a reaction to invi being lynched.

Question to you name a time when he actually furthered the game state or got information out of a push we otherwise wouldn't of got.

It's more like a puzzle, point 1 and point 5 were like the corner puzzle pieces to work from. That's why I get better as days go on more peices.

[tictac]

tictac - on first impression, not liking his slot.

Something feels different in his play compared to the play in my hosted game

I bet. That game was over 2 years ago and my first one outside of newbcue. Using dissimilarity to that for anything is reachy af.

tictac what's your read on CT, who put up a case on you?

Why do ya wanna know?
did ya read the case and the post it was referring to? I don't see a possible motivation for 644 besides buddying CT, which would mean he's town.
Do tell me what is there to agree with in 475 if ya disagree.

I also agree that 875 was towny, but disagree with the reason.

Can someone comment on my case against Tictac and say whether they agree or disagree with my points?

He's asking for a singular volunteer, not singling out many people, so would be supremely ineffective in locking scum into any reads they didn't want to be locked into.
(I disagree with locking reads being a good thing btw, but that's a playstyle/game-theory discussion and not really relevant to this)
I think he is feeling insecure about his read because it's being ignored. He's seeking validation or someone to tell him what he should be scumreading instead.
Comes across as very newbtown to me.

Lapsa were you talking about scion in your 855?

Spoiler: context

the chicken guy replaced?? wonder why.

not my fault you are unable to follow thread

That a scum slip?
Just did an iso, he did not ever indicate replacing out ITT
viewtopic.php?p=10435252&user_select%5B ... #p10435252
His iso

Just did an iso, he did not ever indicate replacing out ITT

nevermind. I believe it now. defo scum slip. carry on, soldier!

peculiar indeed.
Lapsas post would only work as a slip if he's scum with you. Why is it something ya are interested in?

[Lapsa]

and I'm drunk. so no more posts till tomorrow

afraid of scum slipping while your inhibitions are lowered?

that's the easy part. cleaning up mess in your head is what I'm afraid of

[Lapsa]

Lapsa were you talking about scion in your 855?

no. I was talking about Hugo

i have to agree

this stinks. Mala and Gamma are

scum

VOTE: Malakittens

[Gamma Emerald]

So based off a snarky comment I made and mala’s agreement you see fit to conclude we’re scum together? You have no sense of reason apparently.

[Lapsa]

no, you have no sense of reason

[Garmr]

@performer

Vote davesav if you wanna live.

@Everyone else vote Dave

[Lapsa]

daev is still in my maybe lynchpool

[Lapsa]

I think he is feeling insecure about his read because it's being ignored. He's seeking validation or someone to tell him what he should be scumreading instead.
Comes across as very newbtown to me.

^ unlikely