Mini Normal 2119 [game over]

[Menalque]

I think bob is significantly above average to flip scum tho and I think that may mean we don’t have a wagon on scum atm

UNVOTE:

[Looker]

Counterwagon is Wilky, though, Chem, so you might be fucked.

[Menalque]

Ugh wait no we have like less than 24 hrs

Can we get more votes here please?

VOTE: bob

I think bob is consistently pushing slots that look scummy rather than that necessarily are scummy and I’m reminded quite a lot from ISO skimming him of his ISO in tris’ mini normal

[Menalque]

Counterwagon is Wilky, though, Chem, so you might be fucked.

Interesting attempt to frame yourself as not being the counterwagon when you are

[Menalque]

Okay I’m not letting myself get sucked in here or I’ll be here forever

Pls vote bob while I sleep and I’ll make the deal that you’ll retroactively appreciate why your vote was good after I explain more tomorrow?

[Looker]

A French bull just ran through my china shop

[Chemist1422]

quick question what just happened on page 8

[bob3141]

menal i think you have never read me rigth once so far day one

i was scum and you town read me

i was town and you pushed me while i was trying to push garmr.

And now again im town and your pushing me as scum day one

[Datisi]

bob can you actually answer my question thank you

[Chemist1422]

page 17 thoughts say GL/Datisi/maybe UP town, still not liking looker

[bob3141]

And menal do you real think we should not be asking chem to produce content. Bug did next to none so we need chem to make up for it.

we have less than 24 hours to choose a lynch. And so far 4 players are sitting on bug. A player that got pushed to l-1. Making him a likely lynch

And do we really want to go blind to teh deadlien on that slot. If he is town he might show something that could dissuade them votign him. And if he is scum he migth end up creatign associations and proof that he is scum.

[bob3141]

bob can you actually answer my question thank you

what question.

[Chemist1422]

oh boy page 18 was a GREAT one to read

[Datisi]

give us your top three scum reads.

And your town three town reads.

yo, when i asked you for your reads the only thing you said was "early days, early days"

can you do this?

[Chemist1422]

okay that happened

think my brain needs a quick break after that I'll get back to reading soon

[Chemist1422]

that was in reference to page 21 btw

[bob3141]

give us your top three scum reads.

And your town three town reads.

yo, when i asked you for your reads the only thing you said was "early days, early days"

can you do this?

That was stupid question. Pretty much a none question. And even you repeating it in effect is very suspect.

You even deliberately misquote me. Where i ask him for 3 scum leans and 3 town leans or a series of questiosn he wants to ask players.

In other words im asking him if he has solid reads and why. If he hasnt got a solid read then what does he ant to ask. Implied to be atlrast 6 players he wants to ask somethign off.


It should be clear were some of my town reads are

[bob3141]

Notice how ive already said i think ico is town.


Look how ive not asked anythign of aareon thus i think he is town.

And i normaly never check more than 2-3 players off day one as town.

and you see all the signs that im actively trying to sort the remainign players. Bug is blind slot that so far lots pushed to l-1 over nothing thus. bug must be sorted to sort his wagon.

And to do taht his slot must talk.

[Datisi]

you only said ico is gut town because posting rate. How the hell am i supposed to conclude that because you didn't ask Aaron anything you hink he's town?

and i'm not seeing any signs. I'm seeing questions that you don't follow up on?

[bob3141]

datsi explain why your first reaction to me trying to sort wilky by askign him series of questions. Was to shade me.

A series of question although clearly based on sligh scum lean were hardly anything compared to tunnel. For instance you have menal as town even though his attack on plank took a good 8 pages plus 8 pages were it wasnt just those 2.

Yet you town read him and that was one major tunnel if he is town. By your logic on that front he shouldnt be a strong town read of yours.

Yet when i simply ask a third round questions to get those essential hints of alignment you say oh that tunnel went further than normal.

Now that a level of inconsistency

[bob3141]

you only said ico is gut town because posting rate. How the hell am i supposed to conclude that because you didn't ask Aaron anything you hink he's town?

and i'm not seeing any signs. I'm seeing questions that you don't follow up on?

now this misrep if ive even seen it.

Your reads were based on post rate.

My read on ico is based off his answers to my questions. I test was set and he passed. If he was town i was expecting him to say he tried using menals own arguement against him. If he was likely scum he woudl answered differntly. I also pointed out i have scuma nd town meta on him. and it should be clear my read on him had large elements of meta to it.

[Chemist1422]

page 22 reads:
{Chem, Datisi, GL}
{Mena, Tchill/UP}
{rest}
{wilky, Aaron?}
{Looker}

aaron seemed kinda disengaged in a weird way though I don't remember what exactly gave me that vibe

wilky's scumread on UP felt bad

[Chemist1422]

back to catching up

[Datisi]

you only said ico is gut town because posting rate. How the hell am i supposed to conclude that because you didn't ask Aaron anything you hink he's town?

and i'm not seeing any signs. I'm seeing questions that you don't follow up on?

now this misrep if ive even seen it.

Your reads were based on post rate.

My read on ico is based off his answers to my questions. I test was set and he passed. If he was town i was expecting him to say he tried using menals own arguement against him. If he was likely scum he woudl answered differntly. I also pointed out i have scuma nd town meta on him. and it should be clear my read on him had large elements of meta to it.

Ok first can you pls spell my name right it's 6 letters

second my reads were *not* based on post rate - i've explained them whenever someone asked

third, i've ctrl+F "ico" in your iso, the only time you actually directly talk about icon before post 1067 is this:

ico posts allot in his scum games too but my gut feeling on him is town.


i think for ico he posts between 130% and 150% more than his town games


i was his scum partner in a game a while back so have feeling for him as scum

this post was mostly talking about postcount, and even then it was talking about "gut", which again, you did not explain any further

[Datisi]

datsi explain why your first reaction to me trying to sort wilky by askign him series of questions. Was to shade me.

A series of question although clearly based on sligh scum lean were hardly anything compared to tunnel. For instance you have menal as town even though his attack on plank took a good 8 pages plus 8 pages were it wasnt just those 2.

Yet you town read him and that was one major tunnel if he is town. By your logic on that front he shouldnt be a strong town read of yours.

Yet when i simply ask a third round questions to get those essential hints of alignment you say oh that tunnel went further than normal.

Now that a level of inconsistency

okay where the fuck do i start with this post

it was not my *first* reaction. It was a rection after seeing you shoot out question after question without ever drawing a conclusion.

yes i have menal as town? where did i say that those two tunnels were one and the same? like it's quite obvious the difference between menal losing his shit and getting into a shitfight (which i know is p town!indicative for him) vs you just shooting question after question with no conclusion, some of which looked a ~bit~ leading

like i'm not saying menal's tunnel didn't go futher than normal. it VERY MUCH did. but things going "further than normal" doesn't necessarily correlate to alignment and why are you trying to make it as if i said they do?