Open 779: Pick Your Power X/Y Game Over!

[skitter30]

and melody just feels kinda gutscummy to me but idk why yet

[Melody]

Our vote switched to Cats because of some hydra dissonance lul

Melody, what made you want to vote me rather than waiting for me to post more?

I questioned you because I disliked that post, and a vote on you for pressure was better than anywhere else. Cats/the other slot we mentioned were pretty small scum impressions.

~Dawn

[Datisi]

wow such inconsistency skitter did you roll scum again

i think i gotta give this game a reread or something because i'm still in the early shitpost whatever mode

pedit: lul huh

[Alduskkel]

Our vote switched to Cats because of some hydra dissonance lul

Ok so why is cats a bigger scum impression than me now?

pedit: this is all @melody

[Melody]

Aldu, so you think Dunny is openwolfing in a sense by trying to get the 1-shot vig to claim? He doesn't read that way to me, and I think the positives associated with trying to force an anti-town claim are outweighed by the negatives of the hit your appearance takes.

~Dawn

[skitter30]

what was the hydra dissonance?

[Melody]

what was the hydra dissonance?

I (Dawn) voted for Aldu. Evening voted for Cats. As much as I'd love to have perfect aligning reads on a telepathic level, we're not quite there yet.

~Dawn

[skitter30]

what do each of you feel about the person you didn't vote

(i.e. dawn on cats and evening on aldu)?

[Melody]

Ok so why is cats a bigger scum impression than me now?pedit: this is all @melody

I don't really have you both on a scale so to speak, you're both unsures. I don't get your Dunny suspicions but I can see the logic behind your push so I don't think that's bad faith. Probably.

~Dawn

[Melody]

what do each of you feel about the person you didn't vote

(i.e. dawn on cats and evening on aldu)?

We agreed on Cats. I'll ask Evening what she thinks of Aldu.

~Dawn

[Alduskkel]

Aldu, so you think Dunny is openwolfing in a sense by trying to get the 1-shot vig to claim? He doesn't read that way to me, and I think the positives associated with trying to force an anti-town claim are outweighed by the negatives of the hit your appearance takes.

~Dawn

I wouldn't call it an openwolf. Also, judging by the lack of votes on him, Dunnstral hasn't taken much of a hit.

pedit: ugh hydra dissonance
ppedit: can i post please

[Melody]

but I can see the logic behind your push so I don't think that's bad faith. Probably.

*push on us

[Alduskkel]

I mean look at Dunnstral's iso. He tried to get a PR to claim and then got flak for it and has been laying low ever since. The only "scumhunting" he's done is casting aspersions on me for voting him.

what's not to get

[Melody]

-FarkranWell this feels weird. Melody just said I was "pending further evaluation" but then votes me, and then I don't know what to make of Farkset's vote. I doubt Farkset-Melody scumbuddies do this tho, unless that's exactly what they want me to think (but probably not).

Melody, what made you want to vote me rather than waiting for me to post more?

What do you find so strange about this, Aldu? By "pending further evaluation" it means I saw something I disliked and questioned you about it. How else would you expect me to use my vote rather than to pressure slots I'm unsure about? Especially since I was voting Drew who I started changing my mind on.

~Dawn

[Melody]

I mean look at Dunnstral's iso. He tried to get a PR to claim and then got flak for it and has been laying low ever since. The only "scumhunting" he's done is casting aspersions on me for voting him.

what's not to get

The law low point is fair. I just disagree with the basis of the push; I read Dunny's intentions for the vig to claim as more genuine.

~Dawn

[Melody]

thats my bad

what do each of you feel about the person you didn't vote

(i.e. dawn on cats and evening on aldu)?

I think early on i didn't like the scumreads that Dunn was receiving (Aldus being one). i'm not really sure disagreeing with him on Dunn is valid reason to scumread him yet. also for some reason i thought i heard someone make a meta case for Aldus being town, unsure if I got that confused with someone else but I had Aldus as closer to town in my mind earlier

i saw the mounting wagon on cat w/ skitts n datisi on it and went "ooh i like everything about that" and joined it for pressure. but i let up on Aldus in doing so. oops

i really should have read the thread more carefully, sorry again abt that

~Evening

[skitter30]

why are you guys townleaning me again?

[Alduskkel]

What do you find so strange about this, Aldu? By "pending further evaluation" it means I saw something I disliked and questioned you about it. How else would you expect me to use my vote rather than to pressure slots I'm unsure about? Especially since I was voting Drew who I started changing my mind on.

~Dawn

I thought you'd wait for me to respond/post more so you could do the further evaluation and then decide whether or not to vote me.

Like, I'd expect town to either wait to vote me and/or after voting me not move the vote elsewhere so soon.

[alimdia]

Kinda wanted to say Alimdia's 338 felt forced like the skitts argument at the beginning. But I think i can see the argument. "You listed two scumreads, didn't vote either, then later voted a completely different person after Dunn voted them".

Small scum impressions:
Cats and Alim for reasons stated in 136 and 232.

@alimdia re 338, wasn't the "need to find another vote" saying they want to vote someone besides Drew?
VOTE: clemency

ye but they said me and cats are scummy.
Why not vote one of us?

what scum motivation do you think there was behind not voting one or the other in the same post? Especially considering Cat, Alim, and Aldus were probably all at 0 votes at the time

~Evening

Have you not voted people with 0 votes before? How do you think a wagon starts. I just feel like your actions and words are not consistent.

so far i have gut-towns on:

melody

, don, dunn, and maybe datisi

nice catch

and melody just feels kinda gutscummy to me but idk why yet

nice safe

Aldu, so you think Dunny is openwolfing in a sense by trying to get the 1-shot vig to claim? He doesn't read that way to me, and I think the positives associated with trying to force an anti-town claim are outweighed by the negatives of the hit your appearance takes.

~Dawn

how is the 1 shot vig anti town?

I am gonna iso cats

[alimdia]

CSF does seem to have a quite fluff, but I don't see her 'case' against farkset to be AI

[Elmo TeH AzN]

Prodding Clemency and Cat Scratch Fever

[JacksonVirgo]

Going V/LA for the next two days. Probs

Noted

[Farkset]

Half of the playerlist disappeared over the weekend.

As for the last couple pages, i think:

- Skitter is more town than before
- Datisi is more town than before
- Almidia is a lot more town than before
- I like melody less than before
- I'm... inclined to think that aldu/melody are not a team

I don't know what to make of Aldus because of that. Also i don't see the case against Cat Fever, i only see votes. Can someone enlighten me?

-Farkran

[Farkset]

Melody you voted drew and aldu before, i think that with intend to pressure. What kind of conclusions did you gather from your previous pushes?
~ker

Also don't ignore my other head please

-Farkran

[Dunnstral]

I still think the 1-shot vig should claim; I think worrying about scum hitting a town pgo is a weak point (I don't think town is mor elikely to pick pgo than vig, anyway)

Whereas allowing Don to half claim cop while he can potentially be a role such as mafia pgo or mafia vengeful and be baiting town is unwise. I'm not sure why everyone is townreading him thinking scum would never fakeclaim cop - especially when they're not considering the potential power roles in play

Melody looks like town to me