Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[EchoVision]

page top drop top

[EchoVision]

what will your vote do being on the inactive slots

ico was just for fun
my last post covered why i voted this one

[shellyc]

Nooooo not the townpoint

Herta was pressed earlier and blew it off. I wanted to add to the pressure by helping build the wagon. I wasn’t satisfied with the answer and would be okay with the elim /willing to hammer.

I voted echo because he did the thing twice. I only have one vote smdh

okay?

I feel like this comes from town, tone etc. "not the townpoint" is genuine so maybe i'll give it back
echo wagon is good but I want herta today, im the reverse titus

[shellyc]

because assembler has posted; i don't want assembler to be coasting and lurking
i know assembler's been there in the past, might be here now
a vote on them has a higher chance of getting attention than a vote on ico right now

lurkers get replaced, pressure votes are pointless when you say they're pressure votes

[EchoVision]

because assembler has posted; i don't want assembler to be coasting and lurking
i know assembler's been there in the past, might be here now
a vote on them has a higher chance of getting attention than a vote on ico right now

lurkers get replaced, pressure votes are pointless when you say they're pressure votes

yeah but i don't know if he's actually lurking or just gone
if he's gone you're right
if he's lurking now he's like "oh damn i'm lurking i should go post cause there's a vote on me aw shucks!"

[EchoVision]

and i have to say they're pressure votes cause yall like to whine and not let me have fun with my vote on someone with 0 or 1 votes on them zzzzzzzzzzzzz

[NoPowerOverMe]

I'm seeing a lot of overreactions so far.

[shellyc]

npom what do you think about herta wagon and the echo one?

[NoPowerOverMe]

I see good things about both, you and red seem pretty town on Herta, and I like Titus and Echo on Iconeum. I'm currently on Herta because all else being equal I believe pressure is a good thing.

[Primate]

Sorry, I was busy all yesterday so I need to reengage.

Redcardinal reading Shelly and Noraa as scum in #222 together feels a little contrarian.

Noraa #248. Very eh on this vote. I think red's being weird but not sure about scummy.

I don't buy Noraa as scum generally. Would a scum spend the early bit of the day hard pushing a niche meta case? I'd say a hard no in singleball when they know it to be incorrect, maybe in multiball it's more likely?

Reasonable post from Titus in #275.

I want a counter to this wagon.

I don't see how this is helpful at all. Not a counterwagon generally, Ico specifically.

Herta giving off major "you caught me for the wrong reasons" vibes here.

Yeah. There's little talk about how the wagon is wrong, just that it's undeserved.

Echo's behaviour with the wagon switch is odd but I'm not sure it's scummy. He was on a safe wagon that he could have just sat on, people were starting to join, what's the scum motivation for switching at that point? Just towncred signalling? IDK, why couldn't he do that from the ICO wagon? I would very much like Echo to stop lurkerchasing though. The whole behaviour is a little scummy because it's a shield for nonengagement.

Rannygazoo is still scummy.

[Iconeum]

Rawr!

Catching up later today but consider me vla for thé next week

Irl stuff

[shellyc]

primate's 334 is pretty good only i think rannys response to me pressuring them was well-reasoned. can anyone give me the tl;dr on ranny so I can evaluate the SR there

Noraa can do wacky things as either alignment although I'm pretty null on them atm as they often look LHF as town

[shellyc]

im going to add primate to the townlean pile for that post and the efforts to make a push against ranny.

Town
iamausername
NPOM
redcardinal

Townlean
Titus
Primate

TBD
everyone else

Scumlean/question mark
Echovision
Assemble

Scum
Herta

[EchoVision]

Rawr!

Catching up later today but consider me vla for thé next week

Irl stuff

VOTE: ico

[shellyc]

VOTE: ico

echo they're going vla what the fuck will your vote do at all???

+2 scumpoints, are you excited for the Authetic Shelly Tunnelling Experience

[EchoVision]

arachnids, ico, assembler all disappeared
i'd like to rock herta's shit
i don't want to rock herta's shit yet because there's three people that just don't exist anymore

nobody else is doing anything that crazy to me
i have nowhere i really

want

to vote aorn aside from herta

maybe i'll do a re-read later, but i'm in class right now so give me a bit so i can not pay attention

[shellyc]

arachnids, ico, assembler all disappeared
i'd like to rock herta's shit
i don't want to rock herta's shit yet because there's three people that just don't exist anymore

nobody else is doing anything that crazy to me
i have nowhere i really want to vote aorn aside from herta

maybe i'll do a re-read later, but i'm in class right now so give me a bit so i can not pay attention

then vote herta
not your job to make sure everyone's playing, its the mods job

herta wagon is the best and echo staying off it is pretty indicative of echo/herta being groupscum?

[shellyc]

Idk I think thats quite blatantly partner-y and i think that's too easy of a solve tbh, but if anyone wants my vote on an echo wagon I'm persuaded

but herta is the elim and herta is obvscum.

[shellyc]

Tell me, tell me, how is the herta slot town

Herta goes "who's scum" is

weird

, not scummy; it's a common newbscum tell to point out something is weird instead of scummy because they know who town are and will need to miselim town. but newbscum often think if they suspect town they'll go down as well

154 is just IIoA without any reads or takes
192 discredits my attempt to push them instead of attacking me. this is pretty much omgus. instead of pointing out why they are town, herta basically says "people never scumclaim", that isnt a defense.
281 asks for VC to "scumhunt" but still hasn't posted any reads at all, no effort to solve, lamist
296 has spectacularly failed in defending themselves it isnt even a defense. the point isnt that you scumclaimed; it's that you made No Effort to defend yourself or engage with me after i (admittedly) overreacted

Herta's reaction is basically "you got me for the wrong reasons" which isn't a town mindset, it's a survivalist one. Instead of providing content when the spotlight was on them they flailed. And that is why we should all get herta NOW.

[SirCakez]

wiyvern replaces arachnidsGrip!

[redcardinal]

herta is pretty obv scum to me at this one, and will provide a lot of good info on a flip whoch is something I'm always looking for d1. I like noraa's response to my proposal for a townblock, I think the scumclaim thing is pointless though, I scumread herta for totally different reasons including this omgussy defensiveness. I also don't like the people who are throwing shade on herta but not joining in, but I buy username's reasoning. going after lurkers is nai for me

[Noraa]

Nah Shelly's backtracking is scum indicative too. Trying to pocket me by handing me a town pass then immediately backing off when I say this is what she does in all her scum games. Lel I found one scum day 1. It'll be proven post game where I can go make fun of shelly welly :3

But I think this Herta wagon, thought it has somewhat good reasons backing it up, will not go thru. The reason is that Herta was joking and honestly, not being that engaged and willing to defend isn't necessarily a scumtell. Im interested in hearing from the replacement. Echo is prolly town here bc of his paranoia when evaluating shelly since that's exactly how I felt. So far, I really like Primate's analysis and reads on the game. They seem to have a pretty solid town mindset.

My town block rn: Noraa, Echo, Primate, NPOM

Scum: Shelly

[Herta]

Nooooo not the townpoint

Herta was pressed earlier and blew it off. I wanted to add to the pressure by helping build the wagon. I wasn’t satisfied with the answer and would be okay with the elim /willing to hammer.

I voted echo because he did the thing twice. I only have one vote smdh

You may not be happy with the answer, but "sarcasm" is what it is. Deal with it.

[Herta]

Nooooo not the townpoint

Herta was pressed earlier and blew it off. I wanted to add to the pressure by helping build the wagon. I wasn’t satisfied with the answer and would be okay with the elim /willing to hammer.

I voted echo because he did the thing twice. I only have one vote smdh

Echo bouncing around on inactives is NAI. Why is it scummy to you?

[Herta]

Herta's reaction is basically "you got me for the wrong reasons" which isn't a town mindset, it's a survivalist one. Instead of providing content when the spotlight was on them they flailed. And that is why we should all get herta NOW.

You're essentially co-opting username's reasoning as your own after admitting that you overreacted in the first place. That's not a villagery mindset. That's a wolf who got caught without cover.

VOTE: Shelly