Mafia 54: Lagootany - ABANDONED

[genku]

Genku: is that JTHM I see in your avatar?

It's Squee who was on Johnny, yes.

Anyway, do you really want to just end the day and have me join the bandwagon? I guess I'll do that.. maybe learn some information.. though I won't unless you want me to.

[Riven]

I think we should wait for the

mod to prod jinx

I prefer replacement to undefended lynch/mod kill

[genku]

Yeah, I do too.. nobody is stupid enough to not post even when they are about to get voted out.. as I have pointed out in every single one of my games.. It would be much better to find a replacement.. and perhaps a bad lying replacement, wouldn't that be lucky?

[Talitha]

Look, It's only a week since Jinx posted... I dunno if he/she's a good candidate for a replacement. *shrug*
Probably as good as anybody for a lynch though.

Anyway, do you really want to just end the day and have me join the bandwagon? I guess I'll do that.. maybe learn some information.. though I won't unless you want me to.

This sounds like you kinda want to lynch Jinx, but you don't want to be held responsible if he's innocent.... I think you should just bite the bullet and vote if you think the lynch is a good idea, or not vote if you think it's a bad idea.

My vote was initially just a bandwagon vote for a roleclaim or something, but if that's not going to happen I'm willing to lynch.

[genku]

Hmm, hmm, well, I wasn't quite sure if I wanted to vote or not.. blah, I guess I'll just not join this bandwagon. I'm not a big fan of lynching people due to inactivity.

I was thinking that perhaps it would help get us information.. but there isn't really that big of a chance that Jinx is scum.. so I will just hold off.

[rOver]

My vote was initially just a bandwagon vote for a roleclaim or something, but if that's not going to happen I'm willing to lynch.

Problem is that some of us are just getting tired of day on. Mini 55 was on day 4 last time I checked and we are still on day one. Obviously lynching Jinx is not the right strategy. Question is are we willing to go on for another week (or more) until we reach a majority or would we rather end this day with a worse than random vote.
I admit I was thinking about voting Jinx just to end this miserable day but that would just help the scum. Worse still some of these scum helped create this situation and now use it as an excuse to kill off someone who is not suspicious at all.
I'm thinking about Macros who completely refused to say anything constructive, posted just enough not to be replaced* and now says he'd rather see this day end. Well, Macros if you had participated this day could have ended a long time ago.

So:

unvote:Wacky
vote:Macros

If we are to lynch someone for non-participation MAros is just a way better candidate than Jinx. Then we can have Jinx mod-killed or replaced if he doesn't show up.
*Actually when I posted that Macros shoul be replaced I thought if he shows up now he is probably scum. I think Macros has been following the game all along and didn't post becouse he thought it was the best way to stay alive.

[Someone]

Question is are we willing to go on for another week (or more) until we reach a majority or would we rather end this day with a worse than random vote.

How is the bandwaggon worse then random?

Anyways, I agree with what r0ver has to say. Macros is a better person to lynch. The only reason we are voting for Jinx is lurking. However, it seems that she is not lurking because she is mafia, but because she has forgot about the game. Anyways,

Unvote:Jinx Vote:macros

[genku]

Okay, this bandwagon makes more sense.. and maybe we can get information from him without a lynch.

vote: Macros

[Macros]

uh, lets see, im not here, people suggest i should be prodded, the mod prods me, i post. possible correlation?
no, he must be scum.
im a useless townie, i have no information, the game has been random votes for the msot so far, we have nothing to go on, bandwagoninbg seems (for once) the best option.

[Riven]

Thats an easy claim to make as a mafia Macros.. and I dont really believe you.

Vote: Macros

[rOver]

Question is are we willing to go on for another week (or more) until we reach a majority or would we rather end this day with a worse than random vote.

How is the bandwaggon worse then random?

I don't think a mafia would keep silent when he needs only one vote to be lynched. I also dn't think a mafia would forget about the game. But then who knows. Make it not better than random if you like.

[Wacky]

Actually, I believe that macros has been prodded. Check the dates for confirming in Shrek Mafia for instance.

On the other hand, macros is a very useless townie and hasn't really said ANY new ideas at all. So macros - talk. Who's suspicious? Who isn't? I'm sure you get the drift...

But at the moment I find that while macros is utterly useless he probably isn't scum whereas jinx has simply disappeared off the face of the earth so is a little more of an unknown. Only a little though.

But that's just my opinion and I don't really care because its like Groundhog Day here. Every time I wake up its still Day 1.

[Jinx]

Hey guys I know I haven't been playing very well and all, and I am really sorry about that. But if you want to lynch a a townie on the first day, go ahead. Why don't we try to find somebody who might really be mafia instead of giving them an easy lynch for the first day?

[rite]

confirm vote: jinx

At least Macros seems to talk once in a while. I still don't think that we're going to have any firm evidence of anyone being scum or town, so we might as well lynch a player who isn't adding anything to the game. Jinx ain't cop or doc, she would have claimed by now. This day just needs to end, and I really wish that mikehart would set a deadline.

[Green Crayons]

Vote: Jinx

. He just reeks of scum to me. And if not, he's just a plain townie, so there's no real blow to the town in killing him.

[Wacky]

Confirm Vote: Jinx

Rie's explanation seems eloquent enough.

BTW, I think the cop's dead. There might be a backup though.

[mikehart]

Vote Count:

Someone

(1)- Jinx

Macros

(4)- rOver, Someone, genku, Riven

Jinx

(5)- Wacky, Green Crayons, Talitha, rite, Macros


Still

6

to lynch

[rOver]

It seems we have reached a stalemate with noone changing their votes for a few days. How about everyone explaining why they felt their choice was justified? I partly did that when I voted Macros. Though Jinx's reappearance was not convincing at all I still believe Macros has been acting suspicios.
Macros, let me ask you something. When was the last time the mod asked you to post more? Was your post on oct 5th a result of proding or was it an exception?
Rite made his case too though from his previous posts I expected something like: "Jinx has more votes so I'll stick with him".
I also find repeating Macros' and Rite's arguments somewhat suspicious but maybe that's becouse I think Wacky is scum anyway.
BTW it looks like both Macros and Jinx has claimed townie so at least we are not killing someone important either way.

[rOver]

I also find repeating Macros' and Rite's arguments somewhat suspicious but maybe that's becouse I think Wacky is scum anyway.

I meant: I also find Wacky's repeating of Macros' and Rite's arguments...

[Talitha]

I'm actually happy to go either way.

Macros was one of my 3 main suspects, mainly due to lurking. However I still think rite is more suspicious than Macros.

Jinx is not a bad lynch, lurker, and the Night 1 kills look like newbie kills.

Flimsy reasons I know, but there you have it.

[Wacky]

I'm also willing to go either way as I've implied earlier- so 4 + 2 is 6. Yay - we have a lynch!

Unvote: Jinx, Vote: Macros

[Talitha]

OK then, here goes nothing

unvote: Jinx, vote: Macros

I would've hated to lynch a newbie on the first day of their first game

[Macros]

pah, so instead you lynch an innocnet townie?
you'll all regret it etc, muwahahahahahahaha

[genku]

So, Macros..are you pro or anti town? We wanna know!

[Macros]

can't you read scum boy?