In post 134, Cape90 wrote: In post 71, shiki wrote: In post 67, Cape90 wrote:I kinda thought they just looked like mafia trying to look busy, but a little later, I am warming up to them, especially with their latest post in 65 and I kinda vibe a bit with the vanderscamp read
hmm
Alright so about your suspicion on me, let us start here, what are you not following here in terms of logic?
I will admit that maybe my read on
65 was a bit shallow, I don't think I really have seen mafia make a post about finding 1 more town for a winning POE. I feel like that would just close off options if the supposed winning POE is wrong. i guess in other words I tend to see mafia try to keep their options more open
it's like,
jacket says 'this the scummiest rvs!'
you disagree with this, but as you've clarified when questioned, this is because you think any reads based on rvs are questionable and that you thought jacket maybe was just trying to look busy, right
but if all reads based on rvs are questionable, and you didn't find any of the other posts scummier than the one pointed out just that you found it scummy for any of them to be pointed out, it's like ... but then why would this be more likely mafia trying to look busy than town moving the game? and what would have been a towny thing for anyone to be doing? continuing to rvs indefinitely?
but sure your post also moving the game so it's like on that level i can see why maybe towny but not why scummy from jacket,
but then jacket is doing coalition thing, and saying, well i have no reason to move game as mafia
and! the awareness of this i would think would make your busy work hypothesis stronger
as jacket was certainly doing things and saying 'i want to have conversations/produce content' but not really taking actions towards this goal but rather the building coalition goal
which was both not encouraging me/bugspray to have a conversation/produce content right, jacket was not really reaching out to us to get a read on us, and was also townreading players for very little without engaging them further just issuing a townread right
so it seems weird to me that you viewed this and thought, ah, that's towny now
and timing of it felt in line with potential mafia reasoning to me as i explained to umlaut