Micro 1061: If Trees Could Scream [Game Over]

[furtiveglance]

@Ircher, who do you sr other than Titus and who are your townreads?

~Nancy

From town to scum:

Ircher
Vanderscamp
SCRRRDBEAR
Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
furtiveglance
Enchant
Porkens
Herta
Titus

If ircher scum I'd look at furtivegalance draper or enchant as partner so I don't think ircher as scummy now since I townread those three.

This is the post in question. Are you guys saying Porkens knows Ircher is scum and setting us up while finding a justification to not scumread Ircher without directly townreading Ircher?

Herta, not Porkens.

[Vanderscamp]

I will vote ircher Titus or porkens.

This is my list except swapping you for Titus.

Nothing is really happening to make me change my mind on the general consensus being a good one, recent posts make me like porkens less

[Vanderscamp]

@Ircher, who do you sr other than Titus and who are your townreads?

~Nancy

From town to scum:

Ircher
Vanderscamp
SCRRRDBEAR
Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
furtiveglance
Enchant
Porkens
Herta
Titus

If ircher scum I'd look at furtivegalance draper or enchant as partner so I don't think ircher as scummy now since I townread those three.

This is the post in question. Are you guys saying Porkens knows Ircher is scum and setting us up while finding a justification to not scumread Ircher without directly townreading Ircher?

Herta, not Porkens.

I don't think Ircher has to be scum, it just sounded like a fake reason to read Ircher as town this early in the game.

[Vanderscamp]

Like, mid to late game I don't mind looking for specific partners on someone and then townreading them when they don't have any valid partners, because there are pretty obvious connections, but this is D1.

[furtiveglance]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

[furtiveglance]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Usually with TMI arguments the player accused has something to gain from townreading town e.g. towncred

But Ircher isn't really close to being voted out or anything.

Is it just that it's a bad reason to townread someone and that's sus?

[Ircher]

Why am I your top town?

I think you were asking townie-motivated questions in posts 43, 44, 47, and 49.

If not Draper, how about Porkens?

Well Draper is making this big fuss and all, so.......

It's not, but it's also early. There is merit in looking elsewhere.

Why are you still voting us then?

I didn't want to kill wagon momentum. It was more of a "if you rather" kind of thing. I could move now, but I don't really have a place to go with it, so....

I thought both reactions looked scummy to me: Titus voting me for not doing enough by page freaking 2 and Ircher for apparently no reason whatsoever, advocating wagoning us and I still think this. I no longer think they look aligned like I’ve said recently.

Look, it was early game. I advocated for wagoning you all because I was already voting there. If I started the game voting Titus instead for instance, I would've advocated there instead.

Didn't read too much today as I had a long work day; I just searched for my username to see if anything pressing came up.

Posts 64 and 111. While I don't necessarily disagree with the argument, I do believe that Titus's conviction is too strong especially given how often Titus has played with you.

These don't seem congruent with each other.

Look, can someone explain how the timeline works or doesn't work here?

You want me to move on? Talk to me.

I asked you directly to elaborate on what you find incongruent between these posts. I see no contradiction here. I had an RVS vote on Draper that I decided not to move to see where things go, and then after it concluded, I moved my vote to a real vote.

PORKENS CAN YOU POST A LIST OF YOUR READS

I would like this from Porkens as well.

I have to be able to call a spade a spade. That's reality.

Anyway, Herta's last post looks rather tmi.

VOTE: Herta

What looked tmi about it? It's making pre-flip associatives, sure, but I see people do that all the time (even when they are very wrong).

Tmi = too much information.

I don't buy Herta actually TRs Ircher because he can't find a partner for Ircher. He doesn't even consider me as a partner for Ircher, which also suggests a lack of analysis.

Now, I'll figure out some other way to comment on what I see with Nancy that's less bothersome but I'm not going to let Nancy object to my FoS and then do nothing productive and then paint me as the bad girl.

It's not tmi to believe X and Y are not aligned...

[Titus]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Usually with TMI arguments the player accused has something to gain from townreading town e.g. towncred

But Ircher isn't really close to being voted out or anything.

Is it just that it's a bad reason to townread someone and that's sus?

Don't really care to argue semantics. You got my point.

[furtiveglance]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Usually with TMI arguments the player accused has something to gain from townreading town e.g. towncred

But Ircher isn't really close to being voted out or anything.

Is it just that it's a bad reason to townread someone and that's sus?

Don't really care to argue semantics. You got my point.

Yeah it is a bit sus. Herta and Porkens are the Arsonists then.

[Porkens]

Scum theatre?

For serious?

No trust.

[Titus]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Usually with TMI arguments the player accused has something to gain from townreading town e.g. towncred

But Ircher isn't really close to being voted out or anything.

Is it just that it's a bad reason to townread someone and that's sus?

Don't really care to argue semantics. You got my point.

Yeah it is a bit sus. Herta and Porkens are the Arsonists then.

I have zero interest in a Porkens lim. Care to join on Herta?

[Vanderscamp]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Could be either!
The TMI might be that Ircher isn't with any of the remaining players for TMI reasons, but Ircher is still scum with Herta.

[Vanderscamp]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Could be either!
The TMI might be that Ircher isn't with any of the remaining players for TMI reasons, but Ircher is still scum with Herta.

The biggest conclusion is probably that the three people that could have been with Ircher but were too towny are all town.

[Vanderscamp]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Usually with TMI arguments the player accused has something to gain from townreading town e.g. towncred

But Ircher isn't really close to being voted out or anything.

Is it just that it's a bad reason to townread someone and that's sus?

I don't agree with your first paragraph

[Don Draper x Mistress]

@Ircher, who do you sr other than Titus and who are your townreads?

~Nancy

From town to scum:

Ircher
Vanderscamp
SCRRRDBEAR
Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
furtiveglance
Enchant
Porkens
Herta
Titus

If ircher scum I'd look at furtivegalance draper or enchant as partner so I don't think ircher as scummy now since I townread those three.

I don’t see the connections.

[Don Draper x Mistress]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Could be either!
The TMI might be that Ircher isn't with any of the remaining players for TMI reasons, but Ircher is still scum with Herta.

Why does scum!Herta make that post though? At any rate my initial sr on Ircher has pretty much taken a nosedive, have no idea what Auro thinks about it.

[Don Draper x Mistress]

@Ircher, who do you sr other than Titus and who are your townreads?

~Nancy

From town to scum:

Ircher
Vanderscamp
SCRRRDBEAR
Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
furtiveglance
Enchant
Porkens
Herta
Titus

If ircher scum I'd look at furtivegalance draper or enchant as partner so I don't think ircher as scummy now since I townread those three.

This is the post in question. Are you guys saying Porkens knows Ircher is scum and setting us up while finding a justification to not scumread Ircher without directly townreading Ircher?

If Ircher’s scum here, I’m poweryeeting Herta.

[Vanderscamp]

Ok so Herta's TMI is that Ircher is town

Could be either!
The TMI might be that Ircher isn't with any of the remaining players for TMI reasons, but Ircher is still scum with Herta.

Why does scum!Herta make that post though? At any rate my initial sr on Ircher has pretty much taken a nosedive, have no idea what Auro thinks about it.

The same reason any scum gives reads.

[furtiveglance]

I get the feeling that several of us agree on Porkens/Herta, yet we're kind of stuck on which one to vote first. Maybe it's better to just vote one of them and move on

[Aisa]

Prodding Enchant.

[Enchant]

Prodding Aisa

So anyway, there's something telling that Ircher can be somehow town.

[furtiveglance]

Prodding Aisa

So anyway, there's something telling that Ircher can be somehow town.

What thing?

[Enchant]

I would be reluctant vote one of non-voters as mafia atleast. It's like death sentence (depends).

[Herta]

@Ircher, who do you sr other than Titus and who are your townreads?

~Nancy

From town to scum:

Ircher
Vanderscamp
SCRRRDBEAR
Don Draper x Mistress (hydra of Nancy Drew 39 and Auro)
furtiveglance
Enchant
Porkens
Herta
Titus

If ircher scum I'd look at furtivegalance draper or enchant as partner so I don't think ircher as scummy now since I townread those three.

I don’t see the connections.

If you read my ISO you should be able to see how I concluded that a scum!Ircher isn't partnered with Porkens or Titus.

[Titus]

@Those who scumread Ircher, can I get a reply to 332?