In post 160, mykonian wrote:
Not how this game works. You don't like how I play mine either.
And I think I'm not the only one who dislike you being slow. There's nothing to go off if mosts posts of you end in a question mark. We don't even have your vote to see where you stand. One day you might say Aureal seems disingenuous but you need more questions.
Or we could have someone seeming "disingenuous" sitting at E-1 while Herta, who's second post is a promise that he's going to participate, is going to have to navigate the situation where he ends up on the E-1 wagon. I'd like to see lurkerscum deal with that. Answers without there even being questions, because actions speak louder than words.
So I'd like to see some action from you as well.
That does sound like it would make Herta quite readable. Okay I like this more than your arguments for Aureal actually being a wolf. I read your arguments and I just think "Myko would probably be making this arguments if he was a wolf."
And look I empathize with you here. You want some content, ok, I'll throw you a bone. First let me complain about how if you just read into what alignment my playstyle comes from instead of what wolves actually do and determining if I am doing that, you are probably going to struggle. So much so that whatever read you have on me, it's likely that the opposite is likely to be what you're actually dealing with!
Yes yes the content
I think Aureal's posts are getting better.
115 I'm super happy with and in light of that I feel like their responses to me have been likely what a villager would do? I thinks the post is fine and I buy it.
I don't mind breaking down what I see w/
128
In post 128, Aureal wrote:
So on page three you repeatedly urge people to vote me without giving any reasoning, then finally you bring this out. This was actually in response to you being asked about Andante, so firstly it's ducking a question because it doesn't follow that my being scum would make Andante town.
I like them holding you accountable here. In fact a question I want to ask you is why are you giving Ari this response?
In post 73, mykonian wrote:
Not sure I'm helping anyone if I answer this. For one, it's 3 pages in and Andante is probably the person I feel most confident I can read anyway, so I might as well wait till I'm not leaning one way or another from a handful of posts. There's no pressing need to answer, Andante isn't even being voted so I imagine you all agree she's pretty town. I also don't have to tell the scum who's the obvious town.
That's a lot of words to say that I don't like you and Klick asking about a townread 3 pages in. Go find some baddies. May I suggest Aureal?
Why do you feel like your Andante read wouldn't be helpful? I get everything else but I imagine these processes also make it easier for others to work with you so why not post them?
I've never encountered someone saying "I don't want to tell wolves who obvtown is" why are you saying that?
anyway back to the post in question
In post 128, Aureal wrote:
Secondly, you're just making an assertion about my play based on your own opinion and making a fallacious appeal to authority. Are you really surprised people thought you were meta reading me after that post? That's exactly what that post looks like to me, except I know it isn't because I know we've never played together before.
This I don't care for, could come from any alignment. Could be a villager whom wants to hold you accountable for faking confidence or could be a wolf who is using it against you.
In post 128, Aureal wrote:
What is in my posts is a caution against blindly scumreading me because you don't like the way I dealt with something in early game. And the criticism here seems especially bad faith because you, so far as I can tell, are scumreading me for failing to draw a connection between a sequence of posts. In other words, for reading posts and playing based off what I saw. You're basically just saying "git gud or else scum" to me here.
I think this is fine because if they're a villager they see you and they are probably thinking that you don't care to understand them or see eye to eye. reading it more now it's probs likely to come from either alignment.
In post 128, Aureal wrote:
This seems a bit shallow. I thought town would obviously not quickhammer except possibly by accident when I first came back to playing. 1068 proved me wrong, not only was Enchant's hammer town but Menalque as the fourth vote egging Enchant on to hammer was also town. Do you feel you know enough about everyone here to know they wouldn't do that as town?
I like this line of questioning.
ya lmao except for like the first point this post seems null.
Let's see if my opinion changes with
151
In post 151, Aureal wrote:
I'm sorry, are you seriously trying to argue that town should not scumhunt among people who are voting for them??? I think that's often the most natural thing to do- who else is going to have a better perspective on what's accurate about arguments about me than me?
I agree I think it's easier to try to understand if the people who have fos' on your slot are coming in good faith or not.
In post 151, Aureal wrote:
You're trying to discredit my reasoning by waving omgus around. That's not a great sign. And thanks for confirming that you're appealing to your own authority on how I should play, that's exactly what I'm taking issue with. You don't have that authority.
I like the 2nd bit but the first bit can probs come from any alignment and honestly so does this.
In post 151, Aureal wrote:
This is kind of word salady but I'm trying to parse. You're right that a townread on Andante has nothing to do with my vote so I'm not sure why you're throwing that line out there like it's some shady thing you saw me doing.
I do see now that you explained earlier that you didn't want to explain yet, but the segue into that post is still weird because it's trying to draw a link between the read on Andante which you didn't want to discuss and your read on me. Is your read on Andante related to me?
Also, Andante has a wagon going now, so are you starting to feel more inclined to share your reasoning?
I want to say I see signs of villager thinking here. I like the line of questioning and bringing it back to Andante.
Anyway I want to say Aureal is a villager. Posts still aren't as good as I thought they were but like I see fine I wanna let em cook.
I think your push on them could easily be wolf!agenda, I like Aureal more than I like you but I like this concept of seeing what Herta does in this position, I think that is something that is likely to come from town.
Andante I would like to try to understand. I don't get why they're reacting the way they are, I don't get why they have the stances they have. I don't see how her current stances come from a wolf they seem fucking weird but I don't understand anything that's going on and I don't understand how we get from excitement to "SLOTS DOOMED VOTE ME OUT BEFORE I CARE"
Wavelength and Klick seem fine so far.
Myko I think if you address some of my concerns. I think if you can address some of the things I see with them as well as some of my concerns with you then I'll vote Aureal.
