Mini Normal 2309 | Finished!

[Hu Tao]

I'm fine with starfire out. Any one else willing to vote?

[Civil Scum]

I think we still have plenty of time, and I really feel like RN is dodging the BP question. Even the wiki states that it is considered ideal for town roles not to reveal BP modifiers.

As for Greeting, there’s a lot of things I find scummy about him , but it just doesn’t add up because he is a much more capable scum player than this imo.

The still think Naerys is very scummy but my read on PC is too solid.

[Civil Scum]

*I still think Naerys is very scummy…

[bob3141]

Not too sure on Naerys as they have been scummy but with pressure i havnt really noticed the developments i would expect. If they are scum then their scummyness would be due to being new. In that situation i would expect either their partners to bus them or give them hints the pt. Ive not noticed any sign of this so on balance for im leaning null

UNVOTE:

[Naerys]

I'm fine with starfire out. Any one else willing to vote?

I thought you considered Greeting more scummy

[Yimmy]

i wish the line breaks weren't like that. bummer
ok here are my catchup notes in full

bob3141

148 is maybe a town post
194 why mention how you feel about iavh?
479 is an actual thought process

Hu Tao

208 casting shade on… his own slot?? This is a town post actually
346 this isn’t a good post but i believe it coming from hu tao
354 great post. Probably nai though

Random Nurse

82 isn’t good
413 bad again
425 isn’t very good. Rn is being weird and then giving people a hard time for not getting it
iamveryhappy ItalianoVD
114 is bad i think. Believable that iavh thinks it’s not though
197 you are liking bob and placing him in null? Probably just communication ig

Greeting

504 this is a scumpost actually
516 feels more like an excuse than an explanation, especially since it’s mostly a repeat of what kkfc has already said conceptually (the bad meta is new)

Civil Scum

Not a fan of 14 but i guess i have to admit that this could be town
Should keep 27 in mind i guess (don’t want to though)
39 is not true and also very cocky
104 Did cs believe that rn’s claim is nai? I think a vig should like that claim a lot more than anyone else
129 is not “policy lim lurkers and replacements” behavior i think
155 what even is giving someone a pass on poor language?? Do you think poor english is actually scummy??
162 me when a guy uses emoticons (i dont use emoticons)
163 lol
231 “the strangest (and therefore scummiest) logic” this isn’t how the game works at all. Not a scummy thing to say, just very wrong
242 is bad
248 me when someone thinks something that i wouldn’t think
282 don’t like this post i think. overexplained
307 i think characterizing kkfc as defending bazuf is a little weird but that’s nitpicky
330 bad
342 ridiculous post
347 bad response to 346
387 doesn’t make sense since you backed off immediately.
405 is weird
411 bro the day is hardly halfway over and there is definitely content out there bro

Bellaphant

270 like this post for some reason. Probably shouldn’t base a read on it though
321 is weird. Umm i think i’d like bella to elaborate. I’m not sure how though. Anyway
361 is good
362 why post this?

Political Clout

92 is incoherent and i don’t appreciate that
97 is very overconfident. Does pc think this is the way out of rvs?
100 no he doesn’t. This is a bad interaction then
158 feels town in my heart
250 pretty please use more punctuation
353 does not read sincere i think

Save The Dragons

141 is so real.
283 another banger post from std
297 this is a weird thing to pick it but i think i believe that town would

Naerys

Onto 80 and all her posts seem like super light reactions. Could be newb tho
87 is towny
214 seems super sincere
267 town post
379 is a real thought

Starfire

Don’t get the joke in 7 :(
222 is good but doesn’t strike me as immediately sincere. Light town ig
363 is kinda good

KatyKimFanClub

149 is a very good post
226 is a quality post
298 is good again
324 is super valid
327 is a little defensive i think. I guess it’s because bella said it was shade. That makes sense
338 i feel like kkfc maybe should’ve backed off after he sorted civil. I wouldn’t have either though
341 yeah this is town
383 is town
384 it does
386 is good
390-391 is funny

so reads are (not ordered in tiers):
town: std, kkfc
light town: iavh, hu tao, naerys
null: starfire, bellaphant
light scum: rn, greeting, pc
scum: cs (this might not actually be a good read. i do not like reading his posts)
i don't think i want to vote cs right now cause i'm worried it's just a personal thing (like he could be misguided town. that would not make me happy though). i will probably sheep std or kkfc when deadline approaches

[Yimmy]

oh nice the line breaks aren't like that!! preview post lied to me

[bob3141]

Hey PC, you mind explaining why you’re voting for Bob before you run off?

Lotta people with unexplained votes, like sure I could trust your read blindly but surely there’s a better way…

I'm worried I have a bias against bob. Just his play in general pings me. It doesn't feel like bob is trying to solve the game his spat with naerys does not feel natural it just feels like they were piling on. I can go into more detail but it might be a playstyle difference.

Look like back peddling. Do you think im scum or not.

Town doesnt think that they might be bias they either dont notice or they change there read. They dont make excusses

I could only find one scum game of PC so this is hardly conclusive, but he is so far off his town meta this game it’s simply insane.

Coupled with one scum-claim too many is why I’m voting for him currently.

Ive not liked how he is scum reading Naerys yet has only one direct interaction with them and even that was in response to naerys question. So there scum read there doesnt look genuine as i cant see any attempt from them to sort that slot.

[bob3141]

yimmy you've missed me in your read list

[Civil Scum]

Yimmy - I honestly think you just don’t like my style. There’s no way I could possibly defend myself against someone who thinks every post of mine is “bad”.

[Yimmy]

yimmy you've missed me in your read list :-P

whoops null

[Yimmy]

Yimmy - I honestly think you just don’t like my style. There’s no way I could possibly defend myself against someone who thinks every post of mine is “bad”.

ok

[Civil Scum]

However, I will reiterate that you are left to explain why a scum who was a town read on everyone’s list took the risk of painting a target on themself in a game where BP modifiers are being claimed.

[bob3141]

However, I will reiterate that you are left to explain why a scum who was a town read on everyone’s list took the risk of painting a target on themself in a game where BP modifiers are being claimed.

maybe you like to live life dangerously

[Civil Scum]

[Yimmy]

when you say "reiterate" do you mean "say for the first time"? cause i read your iso and that definitely hasn't been iterated before
anyway idk. cause you felt like it maybe. maybe you like wifom. these explanations are stronger gameplay than your explanation (you were just so confident you'd be nked tonight but not doctored tonight)

[Civil Scum]

I didn’t spell it out the same way but yes I’ve said this before.

I guess it’s WIFOM on some level, but lots of things are.

Me claiming Vig doesn’t decrease my odds of protection imo and made available other avenues of survival. I also have other motives which I don’t think you’ll guess.

I’m really only engaging with you on this point because I like a couple other names on your scum list so I wanted to try to discourage your scum read of me.

[Civil Scum]

I suppose I’ve been trying to bus PC and Greeting as well?

[Yimmy]

if you say so

[Hu Tao]

I'm fine with starfire out. Any one else willing to vote?

I thought you considered Greeting more scummy

I do. But I've asked everyone about greeting and no one is voting there. You seen new, so I'll explain. Toward the end of the day is when people should start consolidating. I think starfire has more of a chance to be voted out than Greeting so I'm voting there for now.

[Hu Tao]

I didn’t spell it out the same way but yes I’ve said this before.

I guess it’s WIFOM on some level, but lots of things are.

Me claiming Vig doesn’t decrease my odds of protection imo and made available other avenues of survival. I also have other motives which I don’t think you’ll guess.

I’m really only engaging with you on this point because I like a couple other names on your scum list so I wanted to try to discourage your scum read of me.

Thoughts on starfire?

[Political Clout]

VOTE: greeting

[Civil Scum]

Hell I’m BP too, what can it hurt to claim LOL

Your meant to claim your super powerful town pr that inst in the slightest way bullet proof and is macho too

This post was another reason I claimed.

Bob seemed to be implying I was intending to claim, which shocked me a bit tbh. It made me wonder if I had given off vibes or had been obvious in some other way.

[Civil Scum]

Hu Tao- I was leaning town early on Starfire, but with little to go off since I really have no clue about her.

[Civil Scum]

Bob sounds a bit role-fishy doesn’t he?