Cheese Thief | Game 1 Over

[Skygazer]

but it inherently reads manipulative when done by stating stuff that isn't fully true

to be fair initially i didn't realize i wasn't actually mech cleared

after that i was kind of memeing

[Silverclaw]

The more people we include in the tie, the easier it is for thief and follower to get their way with it. 2 is fine, 3 is really pushing it because thief or follower can vote late.

nope

So your plan to split 6 votes among four people is? Having 2 people not vote is silly imo

[camelCasedSnivy]

The more people we include in the tie, the easier it is for thief and follower to get their way with it. 2 is fine, 3 is really pushing it because thief or follower can vote late.

nope

So your plan to split 6 votes among four people is? Having 2 people not vote is silly imo

we could do all 6 but people are voicing concerns about it. I'm fine with doing all 6

[Silverclaw]

... I just stated issues with all 6. This four plan is the same concept as the six plan.

[Skygazer]

Can confirm I woke up at 3am

have you stated if the cheese was missing at 3am?
sorry if i missed it

[Skygazer]

Maybe we can solve it using logic rather than cheese

Spoiler: info

I woke up at 2 AM.

i woke up at 4am

I woke up at 1am

I woke up at 3 AM

6am

Also 6am

also no one claimed seeing cheese thief

But yeah, I did wake up with somebody else (Mallow, as I don't see a point hiding it now).

Additionally, because I woke up at 2 so I knew cheese thief woke up at 1

whatever i woke alone and tracked mallow to 3 am im done

cheese disappeared at 1
mallow and silverclaw both have two vouches they weren't there at 1
dragoneater and skygazer both correctly claimed a paired time without partner help

cheese was stolen at 1
you saw mallow at not 1
it cannot be mallow thief

Can confirm I woke up at 3am

[Skygazer]

^ missed one:

Also, I peaked at Silverclaw and saw the 6

[Skygazer]

uhhh NDMath feels kinda townie to me
i think for me it's between NDMath and camelCasedSnivy

[Skygazer]

outside chance of DE70, but the odds for that are as low as the odds of me being the cheese thief

[Skygazer]

PARTNER POSSIBILITIES (fmpov)

thief	follower
NDMath	mallowgeno
NDMath	DragonEater70
NDMath	camelCasedSnivy
NDMath	Silverclaw
---	---
DragonEater70	mallowgeno
---	---
camelCasedSnivy	NDMath
camelCasedSnivy	mallowgeno
camelCasedSnivy	DragonEater70
camelCasedSnivy	Silverclaw

[Skygazer]

so that's like a 1/9 chance of DE70 being thief, compounded by the fact that if he were the thief, he claimed his time without knowing the time his follower had, or knowing that his follower was tracked (1/6 chance as he essentially guessed randomly). that's like uhhh 1 / 54 odds, or 1.85%. i think i can just rule him out. maybe you all could do the same for me? :-)

tomorrow i'll think about how the various possibilities have interacted and if they make sense as partners.

[DragonEater70]

Sky, the only thing making me suspicious of you is the fact that you are begging us to ignore the 1 / 54 chance you are the thief.

I literally wouldn't pay attention to it but when you insist that we ignore it, it's kinda suspicious ngl.

[Skygazer]

like i said earlier i hate being scumread

and i have plenty of games where i've insisted i'm obvtown for no reason

[DragonEater70]

Link pls

[Skygazer]

cant believe ur trying to make me do work

my role pm is default text color other than my rolename. which is green and not red because i'm definitely town haha

again i don't think it'll help us solve much at all tbh and it seems like a time sink. the same listmod could use different formattings. scum could lie about their formatting. etc etc

i think scum should shoot me tonight because uhhhhh im conf town

bc im obvtown

i think the fact that im playing so poorly points towards me being town

im town here tho!!!

[camelCasedSnivy]

... I just stated issues with all 6. This four plan is the same concept as the six plan.

whats the problem with it? (other than the whole cheating thing)

[DragonEater70]

Cheating.

[camelCasedSnivy]

ok, how many people would we vote before its considered cheating

4 does seem on the line

[DragonEater70]

Subject: large normal 243: lindOVER

and i conflated inflated with conflated

Amazing quote ngl

[Skygazer]

if we want fun and suspense we could go for one person

honestly going between ND and cCS seems like an easy win tho

[DragonEater70]

mallow do you have opinions of your own?

[DragonEater70]

if we want fun and suspense we could go for one person

honestly going between ND and cCS seems like an easy win tho

My preference would be to have each person just vote whomever they think is maf, and most probably either 1 or 2 people will be voted but I won't be upset if 3 people will be voted as long as it's not motivated by an attempt to gamebreak but simply because opinions are split.

[DragonEater70]

Okay you know what, screw this

I think my original gut vibe was probably correct

It's probably math+mallow as sidekick

VOTE: Math

[DragonEater70]

Gut vibe = gut read

[DragonEater70]

But it's not even a gut read

It was a very well thought out read

Whatever