Guns & Roses VI [Game Over]

[Aristeia]

I'm actually geniunely confused what you find convincing about his push.

is "because its contrarian" your best reason for why you think he's town and right on pisskop?

[Redados]

Generally when a townie catches up on a thread and comes up with an epiphany about a player that the rest of the PL is ignoring they do it for a

reason

there is no reasoning contained in Redados push, I have no idea how Redados came up with Pisskop as the last mafia.

It's not like he is saying I read to post # and because of this Pisskop is mafia

his reasoning is:

So why are you voting me?

Well it was a gut feeling but now that I have ISOd you it looks like I’m a genius

That is not a reason. Please explain

ok I will explain I don't feel like you are playing like a town would I feel like you are playing like a scum would.

you're mafia because you're acting like mafia is a circular argument with absolutely no specifics attached. I find no way to read into his thinking.

but did you see my question about the scummy award? I noticed that you didn't quote that.

[Redados]

1. Why do you scumread Cakez?

Low info slot, low effort attempts to move the game, and simple POE

Why am I not in your POE?

[pisskop]

3. Why was it a bad idea for any N1 roses to claim when it was evident that a block had occurred?

It provides info to mafia for NK analysis and encourages people who feel they are 'clear' to not continue to post

Why does 4 people coming forward to claim night1 rose clear anyone or help town in any way

[Redados]

hello my name is redados and not radados. I am a red gyarados, not a rad gyarados. although red is rad I feel you for sure

I meant to quote taly here in this post but I did not.

[pisskop]

im not optimistic in

mala

becoming any denser with content

mala is perfect as a poe policy lim in a game where there is 1 maf left on day 2

No play = no endgame

[Taly]

I'm actually geniunely confused what you find convincing about his push.

is "because its contrarian" your best reason for why you think he's town and right on pisskop?

i dont find

rad's

take so far convincing, i made an ISO between

pisskop/cakez

and took issue with

pisskop's

posting.

[Redados]

I'm actually geniunely confused what you find convincing about his push.

is "because its contrarian" your best reason for why you think he's town and right on pisskop?

i dont find

rad's

take so far convincing, i made an ISO between

pisskop/cakez

and took issue with

pisskop's

posting.

ok are you doing it on purpose now

[Taly]

i originally wanted to just towncase

cakez

but figured

pisskop

was a slot i hadnt looked at critically in the game before and went there

I'm actually geniunely confused what you find convincing about his push.

is "because its contrarian" your best reason for why you think he's town and right on pisskop?

i dont find

rad's

take so far convincing, i made an ISO between

pisskop/cakez

and took issue with

pisskop's

posting.

ok are you doing it on purpose now

oh sorry lol didnt see that post

[Redados]

this is fun, I have really missed mafia. thanks guys

[pisskop]

took issue with pisskop's
posting.

my posting has been fine. My motivation to play may be suspect, but my posting has been consistent with everything I have said.

What issue do you have with me pushing cakez into posting more, and agreeing that theta wasnt posting enough

[Taly]

im going to take a bit to think over

pisskop's

answers

[Aristeia]

generally speaking I read a lot less into D2/D3 posting than D1 posting

D1 is the only day with multiple scum alive where scum are behaving in an agenda'd way.

at D2/D3 where its 1 scum left the win condition for the mafia becomes the same as the win condition for the town so its a lot harder to figure things out.

Reading someone on motivation is questionable because some people become demotivated as last scum and some people become more motivated, also town can become demotivated by being far ahead and feeling like its already over.

I reread d1 to figure out what is the scum team doing and how a strategy makes sense. I don't think it makes sense for pisskop scum rose to bus dunnstral scum gun because scum guns get to shoot and scum roses do not get to shoot. I feel like Dunnstral's thread trajectory was basically walk in and make small comments while doing his best not to rock the boat because things were going well for the scum team - he only really efforted when things moved towards looking bad for him, doing a desperation readlist to try to get people to unvote him. That simply does not fit in a world where his scum teammate is bussing him the whole way through imo and if the scum made the decision to bus dunn for credit I would've expected Bulge to be on the wagon as well, instead he hard committed to fighting me the whole way through while I was pushing him and while I was pushing dunnstral. This suggests to me that the scum strategy was not to bus dunn and hope for the best.

[Alisae]

Figure out who to kill and tell me plz ty

[pisskop]

The amount of content produced on subsequent days is going to be more TvT by nature of we dont have new content to work through.

Neither maf seems overly keen to associate with their mystery partner.

[Redados]

also town can become demotivated by being far ahead and feeling like its already over.

Figure out who to kill and tell me plz ty

[Redados]

The amount of content produced on subsequent days is going to be more TvT by nature of we dont have new content to work through.

Neither maf seems overly keen to associate with their mystery partner.

when the action is TvT is when it's wise for scum to just stop talking/participating.

[Redados]

The amount of content produced on subsequent days is going to be more TvT by nature of we dont have new content to work through.

Neither maf seems overly keen to associate with their mystery partner.

when the action is TvT is when it's wise for scum to just stop talking/participating.

I would like to clarify that this was NOT an invitation for everyone to stop talking/participating.

[Taly]

i mainly need a short break from mafia for the day but i appreciate your interest in continuing discussion

[Redados]

thanks for the response

taly

see what I did there

[Taly]

Lmao

The amount of content produced on subsequent days is going to be more TvT by nature of we dont have new content to work through.

Neither maf seems overly keen to associate with their mystery partner.

when the action is TvT is when it's wise for scum to just stop talking/participating.

I would like to clarify that this was NOT an invitation for everyone to stop talking/participating.

Also this post hits really close to home, I really don't know that

rad

( ) is scum

[Redados]

Figure out who to kill and tell me plz ty

[Redados]

Whemestar, Malakittens, Titus, and SirCakez all owe me a read on me.

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 3.3

SirCakez [1] - Titus
Redados [2] - Aristeia, Alisae
pisskop [3] - SirCakez, Redados, Taly

Not Voting [3]

- Malakittens, WhemeStar, pisskop

With 9 alive it takes 5 votes to be executed.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2023-11-10 22:00:00)

[Redados]

pisskop why haven't you voted today