Toriel's Patience (end)

[Lazy Shirou]

even without any votes on me i feel slightly offended.

[Lazy Shirou]

maybe i'm just not used to being suspected as town though

maybe i'll get more used to it this game

i'm trying my best to be a pleasant player to be around here

[Bingle]

912 looks like town Dann. At that point in the game that's probably enough for me to townbin for D1, but I will presevere.


923 and 929 also seem kinda partner-y. Note to self, read Dunnflor joint iso after Ali Iso to check into this.


Overall, I kind of like Dann for town here. All of his pushback seems completely reasonable and I find myself nodding along while reading his posts even I don't have context to go along with what he's actually saying. I will say that I particularly like that he's poking at things off to the side while making his bigger posts on the same few topics, which makes me think he's reading for content and not to know where he needs to position himself.

Is there a section of posts/pages that can give context to why you think he is the scumz, Ali?

[Lazy Shirou]

@mod V/LA until sunday

[beeboy]

Hello everyone I’m back, what did I miss barring the obvious new player list

[Bingle]

Hello everyone I’m back, what did I miss barring the obvious new player list

You got replaced, sorry.

[Taly]

Hello everyone I’m back, what did I miss barring the obvious new player list

I think

Dann

and

Implo

are worth townbinning and

Alisae

is a scumread.

[implosion]

Was occupied yesterday, will be catching up probably in a few hours

[Taly]

I feel like this game has a lot of life for one that just had 4 replacements.

[Freedom]

i don't mind never being spared that could be fun in its own way

i do dislike people putting me in the PoE for D1/D2 alongside Meuh/Ali when i think i've been significantly townier than either of them

Isn't it a bit too early to decide that we're going down the

Mercy

route?
Unless there's a consensus that we all think Dunn is town, I feel like it's too early to decide.

[Taly]

i think

dunn

is town and

mercy

is preferable to me regardless of what his alignment is

[Freedom]

i think

dunn

is town and

mercy

is preferable to me regardless of what his alignment is

I'd say that while I agree with the first part, I feel like we need to have some flips before deciding which route to go for.
If we can eliminate two scum in the first two Days, then we're almost guaranteed to win by going down

Mercy

.
Otherwise, it's more complicated, especially since scum only needs 2 of them to be spared while we need 4.
And that is not counting the fact that the first spare/elimination will be on Dunn.
Which means that if there isn't a majority either TRing him or otherwise feeling comfortable with sparing him, we might not even be able to get to go down the

Mercy

route.

[Freedom]

But then, maybe I'm overthinking things.

[Taly]

I see what you're saying but I'm operating off the assumption that we will eliminate scum

[implosion]

implosion it kind of feels like you want to hop away from meuh but won't let yourself

what are you seeing in 1870

I wouldn't say that I'm not letting myself, I think if Ali had a bigger wagon than Meuh I'd jump.

Regarding Freedom: I asked if he was an alt because I thought his posting sounded exactly like RH's but he mentioned that he'd read some of the coalition game which I thought might mean it wasn't him (since he repped in to that game) but yeah. I think I err on agreeing that RH is not easy to read, I remember having trouble in the guardians game I played with him where i was town a long time ago and in the coalition game he was pretty easy to mislim but that was mostly because I'd been pushing his predecessor really hard. But yeah I don't have a sense of what looks different about his town and scum game so if Ydrasse thinks he's easy to read, i.e. if she has a good idea of that, i'd love to hear it.

I'm trying to reevaluate implo I'm just kind of frustrated with their approach toward my slot.

I really don't see why you should be frustrated. I do still think you're town, the last comment I made was like, a thing that pinged me. You have pinged me this game and I think it's important to note those things for later but right now I'm not really interested in thinking about you that much today because you're pretty clearly not getting limmed today and I think you're more likely than not town anyway. Hence me calling you town with reservations, or whatever I did. You're a skilled scum player (from what I can tell) who I've never played with; it'd be pretty hard for me to ever call you town without reservations.

[Taly]

shhhh, you're town

*puts implosion in a box and wraps it*

[implosion]

dann/implo

how do you feel about

shirou

?

This is a hard question. The short answer is that I'm not sure if I'm ever really going to feel confident on Shirou this game. The long answer is that my eyes have stopped glazing over at his posting but I don't really think he's done things especially out of his scumrange but he says that he has but I don't really remember what the things he said he's done that are out of his scumrange were, and I'm not sure how to evaluate them either, and I feel like he is probably the kind of player who would be like "it's unreasonable to not townread me here i'm way out of my scumrange" as scum or as town, and yeah, I'm just kind of ignoring him :X

[Taly]

tonally i feel akin townread them but i just have a different perception on the game than some of their recent posts suggest

but atp, binning them would mean a PoE of

bingle, aliase, meuh

and idk if that sounds right.

but i dont want to reevaluate my PoE without any flips either

[implosion]

Unvote

VOTE: Alisae

2051 seems a bit unlikely to come from scum, the admission to a shallow read, telling someone else they're probably correct on poijnts they don't seem to have examined, and looking at ydra again based off recent votes doesn't seem like a progression an informed thought would make.

This is a decent point, I do like him saying his read on me is shallow because it'd make sense for him to feel inclined to rest on the laurels of something like that but also understand it's not solid as town.

my poe is lazy shirou, meuh, freedom, alisae

hooray

[implosion]

Isn't it a bit too early to decide that we're going down the Mercy route?

see here for an argument that we should probably just do mercy anyway unless we specifically suspect Dunn, or at least bias ourselves in that direction.

[implosion]

I will say I still never reached the point of particularly thinking Aristeia was town, so Random Nurse is also in the PoE for me.

[Taly]

ari

knows how to activate

Taly!tryhard

and thats holistically protown

and

ari

did that

but i do wish to see more from

random nurse

[Sakura Hana]

@Taly

What are your reads looking like right now?

[Sakura Hana]

This site drives me crazy sometimes with it's downtimes.

[Taly]

tonally i feel akin townread them but i just have a different perception on the game than some of their recent posts suggest

but atp, binning them would mean a PoE of

bingle, aliase, meuh

and idk if that sounds right.

but i dont want to reevaluate my PoE without any flips either

just about everyone i dont have in my PoE i have at least a solid-ish townread

here are the tiers

Dunn-Sakura-Random Nurse-Ydrasse-Beeboy
Dannflor-Implosion-Keyleth
Freedom-Shirou
-
Bingle
Meuh-Alisae