In post 339, Hu Tao wrote:
I think I still want not_mafia today. He is different from when he was town last time I played with him,. Definitely more reads. and then when I said it, he said 316
Reads? Where? What posts do you see as Not_Mafia making reads?
-Atalanta
You don't think NM has been posting reads?
I looked at his ISO before asking that and didn't see anything that I could take as a serious read. What do you take as serious? The only somewhat plausibly serious content I saw was a couple of advice-type comments about voting.
In post 339, Hu Tao wrote:
I think I still want not_mafia today. He is different from when he was town last time I played with him,. Definitely more reads. and then when I said it, he said 316
I think you linked the wrong post, that's actually 36, not 316
Though from my experience, NM is currently prod dodging and waiting until the game is fun for him again
How did it do the wrong post? but okay. I don't have much experience with him
In post 339, Hu Tao wrote:
I think I still want not_mafia today. He is different from when he was town last time I played with him,. Definitely more reads. and then when I said it, he said 316
Reads? Where? What posts do you see as Not_Mafia making reads?
-Atalanta
He's doing way more here than what he did as town when I was with him before. So that's why I assumed these were reads
In post 339, Hu Tao wrote:
I think I still want not_mafia today. He is different from when he was town last time I played with him,. Definitely more reads. and then when I said it, he said 316
Reads? Where? What posts do you see as Not_Mafia making reads?
-Atalanta
He's doing way more here than what he did as town when I was with him before. So that's why I assumed these were reads
That doesn't really answer the question - which posts? Yeah, he's posted more than he does some games, but it looks like all joking around to me.
What's the motivation for a townie who sees supposedly scummy activity, and isn't currently voting anyone, to NOT vote the scummy activity? OTOH, scum could want to point out the activity in hope that another townie picks up on it and starts a push.
Also, your point on my question is wrong. Even if she answers yes, that just means she's playing to her overall scum meta (town would want towniness to come through in RVS). It says nothing about this particular game. It's literally designed to say nothing about this game. So, how would I push her on it, even with an affirmative answer?
All the question does is help me understand her for future games. That's why I prefaced it with "Just curious."
Oh you're serious, lmfao alright.
Even if I was serious enough to think you were >rand wolf from this, I don't care about a vote, I consider it a useless thing to flop around unless I really wanna do something with it or I'm making a joke. If a vote is what's needed to make a point, there's no point in doing anything but just voting people. We can use words, so I'll use words.
My point on your question isn't wrong, it's framed in a way that appears to be trying to make them look bad OR to make you look like you're doing something both of which are bad but I didn't even remotely care outside of poking fun until you're taking this way further than I expected it to.
In post 338, Argonauts wrote:
Black, my dear, this doesn't seem like you, usually you sink your teeth in a bit more than this. More an observation rather than a read, but is making me say hmmmm
shrug
I would love to sink my teeth in but there hasn't been a lot happening this game
I agree that NM seems a little different than normal. Maybe more engaged and active early which I haven't seen from him much. I'm not really sure this is scum indicative though
In post 359, Black wrote:
I agree that NM seems a little different than normal. Maybe more engaged and active early which I haven't seen from him much. I'm not really sure this is scum indicative though
i haven't read anything between when i last posted and now but i think one of the last times i played with NM i killed town-him in elo because his towniness and activity levels were throwing me off
In post 338, Argonauts wrote:[...]
Jake, I love your sense of humor......I want to say you are posting just to post, but I also am not too familiar with your style(and I enjoy a good shit poster so who am I to judge).
[...]
-Asclepius
If you were trying to read me based off of previous performance, you would have had my head. This game is more atypical as I try playing Mafia again.
I am (mostly) posting just to post, as the group of people I want to talk with happen to be the same group of people who aren't here to talk. To ramble a bit; I'm waiting on some of the low-posters to pick up the slack and have some more thread presence. While I ~could~ try conversing with the high presence peeps, they already have a pretty firm grip on the game and have probably already answered any questions I would have in their posts.
I forgot just how
slooooooooow
this site's games can be.
You seem very restless
what does this mean reads-wise? or is it just a comment
I'm here and catching up. The fact that there's a wagon on me is crazy. We're less than half way through D1, and I've had basically nothing but RVS input because I'm V/LA on weekends (and had stuff on either side that made things exciting too).
I will be in and out since the kids are home and I have to shovel, but will answer questions and address things as I read through them.
but okay. I don't have much experience with him
