Eminence in Shadow: Season 1 [Game Over]

[PenguinPower]

[SirCakez]

I hate this part of the game I don't trust anybody except Sakura

[SirCakez]

I feel like I should throw out my reads and look at people again in a vacuum

[PenguinPower]

I’m going to be very clear here….if anyone continues to suspect me at this point, after everything that has happened and all of the flips that we have had - I’m am only going to respond to you via gif.

Because you deserve nothing more.

[Bingle]

I hate this part of the game I don't trust anybody except Sakura

I’m like three times as town as Sakura. You’re just jealous of my eyepatch.

[Bingle]

I’m going to be very clear here….if anyone continues to suspect me at this point, after everything that has happened and all of the flips that we have had - I’m am only going to respond to you via gif.

Because you deserve nothing more.

I think it’s pretty obvious that penguin power is secretly a bird who lied about being old enough to join the site because birds have short lifespans. After years of research, I think the specific type of bird is probably native to an arctic region. I’m thinking he’s one of these

Spoiler:

[tired person]

alright time to bring out teh big gunz :)

i don't think it's penguinpower anymore. i felt his reaction to being voted was genuine. but more importantly i just think it doesn't make a lot of sense for the last 2 scum to just crossvote without even making a whole show out of if in such a disadvantaged position. because doing so just secures a scum elimination without making them look more towny. it could still be penguin and that he and t3 just gave up, but i think he's the least likely out of my elimination pool to be mafia.

jjh was my initial planned vote for today. i didn't like his defense of t3 at all, and especially didn't like his effort to counterwagon t3 by casing me. his case is inattentive and weak at best, and maliciously misrepresentative at worst. also his reads this game were trash tier (100% of his votes are either on my slot or on flipped town), which could be a scum tell.

however i felt i had left out sircakes and during the night i tried to figure out if there were any good reasons to townread him, and i am not really sure there are. i initially thought that his push on pooky day 1 was towny, but in retrospect it could have been tmi. additionally i agree that his push on alisae and reactions to the votes on him are not towny, as explained in posts 1408, 1423 by alisae and posts 1379, 1441 by kyouko. additionally he also had pretty trash votes this game outside of pooky, was voting t3's counterwagon, and had an awkward reaction to town's trajectory on whemestar last day phase (2727).

additionally, post 2075 by t3 feels like something scum would say about their partner and a town, so this is additional evidence for both sircakes and jjh.

so i am pretty sure it's sircakes, and if it's not sircakes it's jjh.

VOTE: sircakes

[tired person]

i do think jjh's entrance to this day phase is really scummy tho

[tired person]

VOTE: jjh

[tired person]

wait i misread wheme's softclaim. jjh entrance still scummy but not enough to prioritize over sircakes.

VOTE: sircakes

[Sakura Hana]

wait i misread wheme's softclaim.

which one?

[SirCakez]

I think I'm starting today with tired person and JJH main suspects
I agree with TP's assertion that Penguin and T3's interactions don't make sense as S/S

It's probably just JJH
VOTE: jjh

[PenguinPower]

jjh and t3 claiming to be neighbors when both are scum makes me smile

[tired person]

wait i misread wheme's softclaim.

which one?

i was referring to this:

How about I say chungus targeting t3 n1 makes sense to me

i misremembered it as wheme saying he made t3 target jjh which would make jjh's assertion that t3 tried to pocket him really scummy.

[Sakura Hana]

jjh and t3 claiming to be neighbors when both are scum makes me smile

me too

[Sakura Hana]

Wheme's soft seems to imply he redirected BCG to T3, so T3 did get a neighborizer.
Now the question is whether he used it on JJH or they are both just scum, since scum knew where the neighborizer was, there's no danger of counterclaim.

[tired person]

jjh how is reading the neighborhood for clues going

[jjh927]

It's not, really

The whole T3/penguin thing still feels a bit weird because of the amount of time T3 spent trying to convince me that PP was town only to instantly drop that but I don't feel I can really conclude anything there

[jjh927]

The other thing being that T3 neighbourised me after I said T3/penguin were the likely other 2 scum

[jjh927]

I think T3's biggest objective was to try and get me to drive an actual push on Wheme, which tells us nothing at this stage

[jjh927]

As an aside, I am conscious that my reads have been total shite this game

[SirCakez]

I think T3 had to 180 on Penguin because of him being the viable CW
This is more evidence for PP town imo

[tired person]

does any1 have any reason why sircakes isn't the last scum?

jjh in particular, whats ur read on him?

[jjh927]

I don't really know at this point
I think I've generally overlooked cakez for being somewhat towny in more recent days

That being said there is a notable absence of any discussion on cakez whatsoever in PT with T3

[jjh927]

Cakez makes the most sense to me from a PoE perspective but at this point I've got a lot of doubt on my pool and no particular reason to scumread anyone