im arguing "i think there's at least 1 scum in {ranger, tbone} here is why individually i think they are scum"
You said a fair amount about T-Bone's early-ish play. Any thoughts on how he approached the last few pages with JV?
i don't really see anything here that piques me one way or another. maybe i'm just being silly but the argument just looks like "look at how reasonable i'm being, look at me having thoughts" when for most of the game T-Bone was like "here's a zinger, okay time to disappear for a day"
At risk of pocketing STD this is the truest thing he's ever said lol
In post 2041, T-Bone wrote:
First you quote that reads list there. But I clarified what it meant in a later post...but don't let that bother your analysis I guess.
i don't think just because you were asked to explain a garbage readslist and you succeeded at that should give you points when you tried putting this out there in the first place but okay
In post 2041, T-Bone wrote:
Your second quote of mine when I asked if you would settle on Enchant I was taunting you because I thought it was a ridiculous thing for you to ask someone given your positioning. You're only bothered by this now like a week later?
my point is you have lots of posts that seemingly have no point, these posts aren't driving the game forward or showing you have reads or anything like that, you're just posting to taunt or fluff or try to expose masons or whatever the hell you were doing yesterday.
In post 2041, T-Bone wrote:Finally I Drew what I felt was a legitimate question given the way Drew asked it. Did you agree with Drew and disagree with me? What does you quoting this post and saying "this is weird too" really mean?
my point is again you're not actually doing anything to drive the game forward, you're just sitting here taking potshots.
I don't think there's anything productive to respond to the first two quotes so you can have the win.
But I'd like to know what about the premise and the question I posed to Drew, in which I thought he was saying to ignore Python, that you disagree with?
Keeps the game fun for me. I'd hate the game if I just posted serious content all the time.
With that said I feel like I've given you a lot of grace on this read (to pocket you I guess) and I feel like I am asking some reasonable game advancing questions and you're choosing to respond to them with "but t-bone just posts zingers" so what exactly are you advocating for here?
(besides my elimination, which, ya know, go off my lord)
Let me back up. My goal is just to try and understand you STD. I don't care if you change your read or not. Sincerely eliminate me if you think I'm scum, it's whatever.
But I can't work with "t-bone does fluff" because that's just not true and not worth debating anymore. If all your read is based on that and vibes just say so instead of quoting me asking another player a question and going "see? T-bone is scum!". You don't need to make busy work to confirm your read to yourself.
i think that the push on JV has reached its maximum utility for the day, and we can go back to it before deadline
but like
it's day 3 and we have no alignment indicative stuff from davesaz and naerys
i am also unsure why I'm townreading naerys for their snappy attitude, but it seems like a player style that will be very hard to read and deal with towards the end of the game
my argument is not tbone does fluff
it is more that tbone has done a lot of fluff in an attempt to look busy without driving the game forward.
it is a vibe read when i look at your iso, i feel like you're lurking in the shadows and just kind of there
in regards to your question to drew, let me ask you this:
if you disagree with drew stating to "ignore python," where is any post where you personally take python into consideration?
i think it's because i strongly believed JV was scum, and so the "never voting Naerys" is a scum signal for me because it seemed like an easy pocket to just townread Naerys. but std has done it, and now t-bone has done it, so maybe it isn't as reliable as i want it to be.
maybe a scrutiny of why people that townread naerys would townread naerys, and an assessment of how believable their townread would be?
so the logic there for me was: JV and STD is scum, because they're obviously pocketing Naerys, so maybe Naerys is town.
but that could also be wrong, and maybe people who are scumreading Naerys IS the town signal (because scum would be shooting their foot making an enemy out of Naerys)
but i have no idea if i should even be townreading Naerys
gob-naerys-dannflor-monkey is nice town block on python right there,
if bussing happened we need to look into Black-StD-Dave and out of those i feel dave is the most likely to be scum
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile")