Corv wrote:I just said why not. You haven't convinced me anything to the contrary and I said why I don't believe a Mirth-scum-Godfather claiming doc after being bussed/forced to claim by scum.
If she were the GF about to be lynched/bussed what would she have claimed to save her ass in a deadline lynch? Vanilla townie? Can you imagine how powerful a doc claim can be?
Tell me why are you ruling out a GF claiming doc when there was nothing to lose in case it didnt work (still be lynched) but so much to win if it worked.
Corv wrote:You say that there is a scummy link for Mirth that you see but no one else does, so why not tell us what this is?
Check my posts from D2. Specially check Mirth and farside relationship D1 that generated my suspicions. If you cant find it Ill try to quote them when I have time.
Corv wrote:I don't know what scum are thinking as they are killing millers and doing other weird (in my opinion not-optimal) plays but I guess it isn't that hard to imagine since everyone who "could" be investigated had been except farside so why not?
And why are you ruling out the scenario where farside wasnt killed and mysteriously left alive because she is scum?
Corv wrote:Mirth-Farside scumpair are facing 2 NK resistant cops (i dont know why you say vanilla but godfather since that implies that Mirth isn't the godfather?)
I meant that SC could be painted as a godfather if needed as was specualted yesterday.
Corv wrote:Even if Shadowgirl was 'confirmed' to them, would she have been confirmed to everyone else? It was PoE and Farside-Shadowgirl's position was interchangable-ish at some points so I just don't see it.
Not if farside is scum. Also how can you keep pointing that SG wasnt pretty much confirmed after all the things that happened? Dude, Corv, think a little.
Corv wrote:Yes, I think Farside-Tajo scumpair is possible. It has been said (repeatedly) since yesterday so it is still possible today.
I dont see it. Why not tell us what this is?
Corv wrote:Farside could be the last scum? I assumed we were all operating with the belief that there are 3 scum (2 now with Crazy dead) and I don't see how Farside being lynched today and flipping would have any affect on your imminent lynch as well.
It was an hypothesis. A reason why we should lynch her before losing the game with my lynch. At some point of the game I thought Crazy was third party, leaving Mirth and farside as a 2 group scum, GF and goon. But I dont think its likely. Really this game is that insane that I think speculating about it doesnt make sense.
...................
Corv wrote:Tajo, there is no real evidence for you and Farside as a scumpair. There is however evidence for you being scum with Crazy and for Farside being scum individually. Unlike the two of you, I'm not pushing an argument of "you're scum because you must be scum together," like you both have been about me.
What are you talking about? Im pushing both an argument of both of you being individually scum (since D1-D2) and both of you making sense as scumpartners. Farside is a different case and Id like you not to generalize for reasons you only know.
As I said, push the Tajo-farside link a little bit more.
Call me Tajo.
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=12894
Coming summer 2010: Tajo's Starcraft Mafia.
Tajo's MagictheGathering Mafia