Ok, smallpeoples is lurking in this game but being active elsewhere but that's not a fo' sho' scum tell is it? There's plenty not participating here (including Rikana, emp, mal, randomguy, myself and others) so why is smallpeoples the scummist lurker of them all? I'm not saying that you're 100% wrong but I really don't want to open the game with a round of 'lynch the lurker'.
Explain. Why would he lurk? Is he bored? Is he scared? Is he forgetting? Is he aware that he's lurking, or is he oblivious? Mafia's all random bullshit, so you just have to lynch scummy players and hope that they are in fact scum. My thought is that his blatant refusal to do anything worthwhile is indicative of scum.
Last time when I saw a player start with active lurking, it was a newbie game and she showed Town. So eh, it's not sure-fire. But there's nothing wrong with threatening to punish someone for doing diddly-squat. I haven't looked at all players thoroughly, nor can I really at this point.
Also I'm still fairly new here, is Rikana being an alt account mean that he's playing under a different name at the same time? Or is there a rule about using alts at the same time as regular accounts?
Rikana has a "main" account which is a username that most of us would probably stand a better chance of recognizing - and probably is at least a year older than the join date suggests. Hence the point of alts, you're trying to play under a less recognizable name so that you can play radically different. Which is probably why he's all lulzy and weird with his avatar and whatnot, he's trying to experiment with being a different person.
Unless perchance he is cheating, Rikana isn't another person in this game at the same time. And although he may have thought my next question was "tell me whose alt you are" (I might be wrong), my next question was "are you Town?" and he said "no". You might be onto something.