Open 422: Polygamist Mafia (Game Over)

[Malee]

why is you being at one vote convenient for my explanation? do you seriously think putting a second vote on someone is a scumtell? what is there to explain exactly?

Of course it's a scumtell. Who would dare to vote me if they are town? No, seriously, I don't need any explanations from you, Slandaar. My point being is : Aru's vote is a little bit extreme, bad excuse to park his vote on TAM. Or was it a "joke vote"? Doesn't seem to be one, and if it is, it is not needed at all. It's just fluff ...

VOTE: Charter

For not posting yet.

[yellowbounder]

Exactly what grand ulterior motive would Arugula be hoping to achieve here, Malee?

Maybe none? Or like I said, trying to make TAM's comment less important, even futile. But I'd like Arugula to answer. That vote seems a little bit extreme to me.

Extreme? You're at two votes, we need to get out of the random stage as quickly as possible. A vote's a great tool to spark people to say something, to expose scum who may make a slip or sommat.

UNVOTE: charter
VOTE: Malee

[Malee]

Extreme? You're at two votes

, we need to get out of the random stage as quickly as possible. A vote's a great tool to spark people to say something, to expose scum who may make a slip or sommat.

You shouldn't skim. Arugula voted TAM. So I had only one vote on me until yours. I agree we have to get out of the RVS, but you don't try to do that by voting for someone who's just a little bit impatient.

[Slandaar]

Yellow you can still answer my question

Why was/is it too early for massclaim?

[yellowbounder]

Yellow you can still answer my question

Why was/is it too early for massclaim?

I wanted to see who would parrot the wiki and who actually had thought about it.

Maybe more towards late D1 would be a better idea.

Explain this

Emphasis mine. Your original proposal was apparently not about actually asking for mass claim, but just provoking reactions?
People have already made good points; mass claim now would frustrate our ability to do individual reads, which is counter productive, all we need to do is catch ONE scum, and we win.

[Slandaar]

Seemed like a good way to start discussion and see who had been thinking about if mass claim is good or not and who had been thinking 'Well wiki says mass claim better late so guess better massclaim late' Looking for reactions you could call it yes.

I like the Malee vote fwiw

[Malee]

I like the Malee vote fwiw

I'd have been surprised if not ! :p

And I didn't check all the games we have played together, but it seems that in some of them, when you are "after me", you are scum.

[Slandaar]

lol I did try mislynching you in one game before you site flaked but sure, I was scum, what do you expect? you were lollurking and I thought easymislynch lets go!

[Slandaar]

OK

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Snake

Everyone votes him in their next post or explains why they think the guy who wanted an exact start time is lurking through the game hardcore.

[Arugula]

Surprisingly, Aru's vote puts me at 1 vote again. Now, that could be convenient for Slandaar's explanation, making TAM's comment look futile. Trying to help your buddy there, Aru?

What? How would unvoting you "help my buddy"? Putting someone at two votes is scummy?

Exactly what grand ulterior motive would Arugula be hoping to achieve here, Malee?

Maybe none? Or like I said, trying to make TAM's comment less important, even futile. But I'd like Arugula to answer. That vote seems a little bit extreme to me.

It wasn't a joke, but it wasn't a permanent vote either. I'm not shouting OMG TAM IS SCUM LYNCH HIM LYNCH HIM. Your reaction to it is terrible though. How the hell is trying to get out of RVS extreme?

Extreme? You're at two votes

, we need to get out of the random stage as quickly as possible. A vote's a great tool to spark people to say something, to expose scum who may make a slip or sommat.

You shouldn't skim. Arugula voted TAM. So I had only one vote on me until yours. I agree we have to get out of the RVS, but you don't try to do that by voting for someone who's just a little bit impatient.

Well it worked, didn't it? We are now out of RVS.
UNVOTE: TAM
VOTE: Malee

OK

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Snake

Everyone votes him in their next post or explains why they think the guy who wanted an exact start time is lurking through the game hardcore.

I don't really see this as scummy. Maybe he was bored and wanted the game to start, and now it's 4th of July and he can't get on. I don't know, but I'll wait for Snake's explanation. +Town for Slandaar for noticing though.

[yellowbounder]

OK

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Snake

Everyone votes him in their next post or explains why they think the guy who wanted an exact start time is lurking through the game hardcore.

Cute. There are people who haven't posted yet, and the game's only been going for three days.

Let's not be so twitchy, eh? I admit, people could be posting a bit more, not naming any names, but now is not the time for a lurker wagon.

[Slandaar]

Cant wait for game to start
Game starts
Posts once in 3 days

The important bit is; nothing in the three days has really happened. So he as scum came in got the vote down early then decides to lurk till something happens... its safe scumplay.
If you don't punish this type of play all that happens is the town post early get into a war and beat each other up then the scum enter a little later and join the party.

The fact he was getting an exact start time shows he was interested in playing, but he actually isnt playing which backs up this hencewhy hes the vote over all the other lurkers.

Voting Snake is good.

[DeltaWave]

VOTE COUNT 1.3

charter (1): Malee (L-6)
Jal (1): SnakePlissken (L-6)
Brundibar (1): Jal (L-6)
Fennin (1): BridgesAndBaloons (L-6)
Yellowbounder (1): Fennin (L-6)
Malee (1): Arugula (L-6)
SnakePlissken (1): Slandaar (L-6)

With 12 alive, it's 7 to lynch.

Fun fact: It's impossible to lick your own elbow.

[charter]

Hey, power was knocked out last week, just got it back.

[The Acting Method]

VOTE: Argula

Why place your vote back on Malee now we are out of RVS stage as you put it?

Brundibar, and Fennin (especially the latter) need to get posts in.

[BridgesAndBaloons]

Let's not be so twitchy, eh? I admit, people could be posting a bit more, not naming any names, but now is not the time for a lurker wagon.

Hey

yellowbounder:

without getting so thorough into theory, when

is

the time for lurker wagons? I'm looking for a short answer.


Also, did anyone else think that this was weird? (underline and italicized emphasis is mine, not in the original post)

VOTE: Argula

Why place your vote back on Malee now we are out of RVS stage as you put it?

Brundibar, and Fennin

(especially the latter)

need to get posts in.

UNVOTE

[Arugula]

VOTE: Argula

Why place your vote back on Malee now we are out of RVS stage as you put it?

Brundibar, and Fennin (especially the latter) need to get posts in.

Her horrible reaction to my vote on you.

[The Acting Method]

How was it horrible?

[Arugula]

She was saying how extreme it was for me to vote you for being impatient. She also thought I was catering to your post when I unvoted her, because she thinks putting someone at L-2 is scummy.

Then she says that we shouldn't get out of RVS by voting a player because they are impatient, when exactly that happened. AND IT WORKED.

[The Acting Method]

Actually Arg... Technically, it didn't.

That would be when I switched my vote.

So that means she's scum if she gave in your opinion a horrible reaction?

That makes sense to you how?

[Arugula]

No. It would be when Slandaar switched his vote, which was caused by MY vote on you.

Yes. How doesn't it make sense? Her reaction was scummy and bad.

[The Acting Method]

Argula... How is it scummy, because I don't see it.

[Arugula]

She is overreacting on a simple vote. NOT EVEN ON HER. And she thinks putting someone at L-2 is scummy.

[The Acting Method]

. . .

I'm trying to decide if you are a hypocrite or stupid...

I could argue that your vote on me was overreacting to a simple vote, and you thought my vote which put Jal at L-2 was scummy...

Also She hasn't been on since you asked the question if she thought that so saying that is misinterpreting her words until she responds.

So you're being just a teensy bit hypocritical and definitely scummy because of it.

[Arugula]

I didn't think that your vote was scummy because it put someone at L-2. And my vote on you was to get out of RVS.