NY 159: RUST game over

[AngryPidgeon]

Prohawk, you thought that Cheery's claim was fake because he only had 1 shot and there are 2 millers. Does that logic also imply that Malp could be scum, fake claiming. (Thus 1 miller = 1 GS shot instead of 2 millers = 2 GS shots).

Do you still think that Malp is likely fake claiming Miller based on your logic with GS/miller balancing?

[AngryPidgeon]

Also, why is DGB so obvtown to you? I don't see any super analysis of her in your recent posts.

[Rob14]

Actually PH could be scum, that could be how ckd knows he didn't act.

Hmmmmm..

Don't even think about CKD's final post or his claimed actions. It's likely all lies. He clearly likes the WIFOM based on how he played at end of day after being lynched. Don't let it distract you.

[AngryPidgeon]

Rob, notice that PH lists DGB as a good scum NK. Skim his ISO. He really doesn't provide any hard thoughts on her yesterday. Why is he automatically assuming shes so obvtown that shes a good NK?

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: Darthe

With AngryPidgeon's permission?

[AngryPidgeon]

>.>

I won't rage too hard at a Darthe lynch. Hes pretty much #2 on my list. PP I would rage about.

But DGB, I'll ask you too. Do YOU find it odd that PH never mentioned you until I asked him about NK spec and hes not saying you are so obvtown (even on par with conftown me/rob) that you were a good NK?

[AngryPidgeon]

now* not not

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't know. I might actually have to

read

the game, instead of doing it the cowboy way. Shoot first, ask questions later.

[AngryPidgeon]

Not really, you'd only have to read from when you replaced in.

[Rob14]

AP, you need to re-read PH's post. He doesn't say DGB is obv-town. She says me and you are obv-town and DGB/rofl are potentially the best kill targets because they're definitely not on the "to-lynch" list but also don't advantage scum by staying alive in some other way. Only me and you were on the obv-town short list that he provided.

I find PH's analysis of the vote interesting. The way he wrote it almost sounds like he's defending the choice. I'm not sure how to consider that moving forward.

[AngryPidgeon]

DGB/rofl are potentially the best kill targets because they're definitely not on the "to-lynch

So, hes basing his DGB read purely on other people's opinions of her?

[ProHawk]

Come-on AP, lets see your vote.

[Darthe]

I would actually disagree with PH. If the mafia wanted to see a speed lynch today they would have killed Rob. That would have probably gotten me speed lynched. If my death is imminent then that is acceptable, however I still intend to try and find the real mafia until that time.

[AngryPidgeon]

@PH: Sigh. Your responses are not doing anything to make me think differently. And calling for a vote on you from a conf-town is ? Are you trying to ruffle my feathers to make me ragey? I just don't understand.

[malpascp]

I don't want to be a bitch by asking this every day, but is anyone conf-town by now? Or something close to it?

[AngryPidgeon]

Me/Rob.

[malpascp]

How exactlly? By your words if you don't mind.

[AngryPidgeon]

CD flipped 1x GS and claimed to use it on me.

Rob is pretty much conftown since he Vigged Peregrine.

[Rob14]

DGB/rofl are potentially the best kill targets because they're definitely not on the "to-lynch

So, hes basing his DGB read purely on other people's opinions of her?

Come on, AP. He never gave a read of DGB. He was only explaining the rational behind the kill-target as you requested.

[Rob14]

I don't want to be a bitch by asking this every day, but is anyone conf-town by now? Or something close to it?

What is your preoccupation with this and why can't you read yourself to figure the answer out?

[AngryPidgeon]

: |

:/

:\

Can I lynch him anyways : (

The point is he clearly thinks DGB is town because he thinks she is a good NK. The fact that he never mentioned her before weirds me out. IMO you/me/rofl were the only targets that made ANY sense.

I think Malp is town. Darthe lynch ok, I guess. But one of us is dying tonight.

[ProHawk]

Allow me to spoon feed you AP.

@Rob - Your logic on Lyman scum is spot on so long as there are only 4 scum.

My read on the DGB slot ^

[Rob14]

I think Malp is town.

I'm starting to reach that conclusion more and more.

[Paid Pyro]

VOTE: Prohawk

Two reasons.
1. Msotly gut
2. Can't have the rev say saying I'm not on a scum wagon anymore

Actual rev you're such a *removes vulgarity*. Day one I wasn't here to vote. Zab NKed. The CKD was lynched prior to my thread Re-read, since I was way behind. Also, if im scummy why didn't you vote me? How about you soft push me some more.

Prohawk, why haven't you voted DGB, if you think she's scum?

[ProHawk]

I don't vote for townies - I don't think she is scum.