Mafiastuck (GAME OVER TOWN WINS!)

[ActionDan]

I'd be willing to make a deal for Nachomamma + cohorts. If we lynch Cheery Dog today and if Malsp survives the night, we lynch him the next day?

Is that acceptable?

[Alduskkel]

I must say that lynching someone other than malp in the hopes that he'll be NK'd is interesting.

In my vast experience, this sort of plan NEVER works out. If we think he's scum, we lynch him. We do not count on the creatures of the night.

Hey. Give me one example why.

And why did you immediately vote malp upon replacing in, hmm?

[Alduskkel]

Well, more accurately, link me one example.

[Robocopter87]

Wait who are you shooting Por?

doesn't matter

Right

Carry on then

[Nachomamma8]

I must say that lynching someone other than malp in the hopes that he'll be NK'd is interesting.

In my vast experience, this sort of plan NEVER works out. If we think he's scum, we lynch him. We do not count on the creatures of the night.

not even depending on the creatures of the night
we're going to count on the inevitable role interactions that are bound to occur
he has to give us a result every night
which means that if he's scum, he's a dead man walking
if he's town, he might actually do something useful for once
although i grow tired of defending his useless ass

I'd be willing to make a deal for Nachomamma + cohorts. If we lynch Cheery Dog today and if Malsp survives the night, we lynch him the next day?

Is that acceptable?

scum won't shoot him in this case
although if mehdi is shooting him then that's fine

also

V/LA for four days

hopefully will be able to get a post in here and there

[Porfervor]

And for anyone thinking I'll be roleblocked, assuming malpa is green scum then black would have no desire to stop me, green is doubtful to have two roles that can block roles (and follows I don't think green would have two redirection type roles), and town shouldn't be stopping me.

This doesn't solve anything. You get evidently roleblocked in the process and above all you're implying that scum isn't claiming their real role right now, just in a form of a safe-claim.

[Robocopter87]

Well, more accurately, link me one example.

I hate it when people do this, its such a jerk move.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'd be willing to make a deal for Nachomamma + cohorts. If we lynch Cheery Dog today and if Malsp survives the night, we lynch him the next day?

Is that acceptable?

NO

[Nachomamma8]

I'd be willing to make a deal for Nachomamma + cohorts. If we lynch Cheery Dog today and if Malsp survives the night, we lynch him the next day?

Is that acceptable?

NO

can you vote cheery dog pls

[Alduskkel]

Well, more accurately, link me one example.

I hate it when people do this, its such a jerk move.

DGB claimed that in her "vast experience" that relying on scum to NK someone doesn't work. I'm just asking for one example of that.

Hell, I'll just settle for some reasoning. Either is fine.

[Robocopter87]

Reasoning being:

Yeah lets just trust the people whos sole purpose in this game is to deceive us. No no I'm sure they'll do the right thing that benefits us and not them.

In laymans terms:

They gonna trick us

[DrippingGoofball]

Well, more accurately, link me one example.

I hate it when people do this, its such a jerk move.

DGB claimed that in her "vast experience" that relying on scum to NK someone doesn't work. I'm just asking for one example of that.

Hell, I'll just settle for some reasoning. Either is fine.

I've been burned too many times with these night plans. They just never turn out as planned. And then the tendency is to forget about lynching the scumbag because people get distracted, and bored trying to whip up a 14-person lynch of the same guy yet another frikkin day.

[Vifam]

Do you guys actually think scum will bother with killing Malp in the first place?

[Vifam]

That was a question to all the people who thinks Malp will "draw" the kill if he really is town

[Vifam]

The way I see it, the way Malp outted as a town jailer pretty much condemns him. Town do not string along their role especially when they're a PR. The lack of information when you're on the verge of a lynch with most of the town wanting your neck is ridiculous. Where is the town thought process in that? There isn't one at all.

Okay

VOTE: Pasch

Lets just do it, with the rate this is going people are gonna lose interest and the mod will have to pick up replacements.

My name is Tazaro, not Pasch

Oh my bad son

VOTE: Tazaro

This reads fake (since Taz has been in the game for some while now and I don't think Vifam is that inattentive).

Plus here:

Urgh that just might be second guessing the lynch in general now that Malp is close to a hammer

Doesn't add up with the fact that he just decided to hammer Taz right away

The reason for the hammer on Pasch was because

1. His last few posts before he was lynched were extremely bad and just reeked of scum apathy

2.At the time we needed 4 replacements, Noir was threatening to replace (Even though he flipped scum, whatever), and the activity in town grinded to a halt. If it wasn't for that hammer we probably would have lost a few more. It gave the mod time to get his stuff together. And ended a day that basically became "So when are we gonna lynch Tazaro" a little shorter so the replacements didn't have to sit through 10 more pages of repetitive agreement from half the town.

[Vifam]

Zdenek is still scum as fuck no matter WHAT HE FLIPS

AND IF DGB IS STILL ALIVE IN THREE FUCKIN DAYS AND IM DEAD YOU DONT LET HER SWEETTALK HER WAY TO NO GODDAMN VICTORY

Someone shoot Fate

[Cheery Dog]

How do people not vote this -_-

because they are smart and have worked out that I am town, unlike the people on my wagon. (except nacho who is scum and therefore has reason to want to lynch me)

[Phillammon]

How do people not vote this -_-

because they are smart and have worked out that I am town, unlike the people on my wagon. (except nacho who is scum and therefore has reason to want to lynch me)

The tone of this post interests me. I'm going to do an ISO of Cheerydog, then pass judgment. I probably should have done this a while back...

[Vifam]

What was wrong with it? The bravado? The whole "Nacho is scum thing"?

[Phillammon]

What was wrong with it? The bravado? The whole "Nacho is scum thing"?

I don't know, truth be told. The actual content is roughly the same as what's been said recently, so that's not it. It's half gut, half phrasing. (So all gut).

Also, partially because, as I said, I should do a check over him anyway.

That said, malpa, fate and titan are getting a similar treatment soon.

[buldermar]

I'd be willing to make a deal for Nachomamma + cohorts. If we lynch Cheery Dog today and if Malsp survives the night, we lynch him the next day?

Is that acceptable?

That works for me.

[buldermar]

The way I see it, the way Malp outted as a town jailer pretty much condemns him. Town do not string along their role especially when they're a PR. The lack of information when you're on the verge of a lynch with most of the town wanting your neck is ridiculous. Where is the town thought process in that? There isn't one at all.

He may simply not have thought at first that it was a big deal.

[buldermar]

How do people not vote this -_-

because they are smart and have worked out that I am town, unlike the people on my wagon. (except nacho who is scum and therefore has reason to want to lynch me)

Appeal to superiority will not work, so shut up.

[Mehdi2277]

Robo who are you voting? Since saying the problem with the plan is scum won't follow it would mean you think I'm mafia. Vifam I'm also curious where would mafia bother shooting him come in. The idea is for me to shoot him.

Anyways claim wise I'm going with either a. he's mafia and that's not his role (two stunners on one team of likely 4-5 feels strange) or b. he's town and that is his role so it should be easy for him to stun me. This plan basically says if he's alive tomorrow we aren't lynching him for a while since it'd confirm I got blocked or something similar.

Remind me why cE is ignored again? We've cleared up he's a weak general scum read and that he's lurked a ton, but that's not enough somehow.

[buldermar]

Remind me why cE is ignored again? We've cleared up he's a weak general scum read and that he's lurked a ton, but that's not enough somehow

He's not lurking, he asked to get replaced and the mod is looking for a replacement.