Mini 1400(!): Bubble Tape Mafia - It's Over!

[d3x]

I've been off the site for a few years... explain to me how that Hammer was proTown, plz.

Also, welcome replacements {-1}

[Thor665]

Vote: Zipperflesh

[Thor665]

I've been off the site for a few years... explain to me how that Hammer was proTown, plz.

Explain how it was pro-scum?

[AngryPidgeon]

proTown

Well it wasn't, and I know I was calling for the hammer. It was a town-tell though, regardless.

Its unlikely that scum-qwints hammers a claimed town cop in his first post of the game. Its just a really bold move. And no offense to qwints, but I dont think hes bold enough to do tht as scum. Unless he had been watching the game and thinking to himself that Dave was obvscum all Day and then replaced in, sw the role PM, and said to himself "eh, I would have voted him as town anyways".

Still, I think the hammer is more likely from town than not.

p-edit: mmm. So presently Im willing to vote Jake/Thor/Kthxbye. I'd like to see Jake pressure.

[d3x]

Stifling D1 conversation, not waiting to hear anything from multiple player slots, Hammering before a consensus has been reached on the claim. These things are all AntiTown. I'm not saying they're scummy just yet, but they're definitely not in the Town's best interest.

[d3x]

More when I'm not on my phone.

[d3x]

@AP- A man could choke on that WIFOM.

[Thor665]

Stifling D1 conversation, not waiting to hear anything from multiple player slots, Hammering before a consensus has been reached on the claim. These things are all AntiTown. I'm not saying they're scummy just yet, but they're definitely not in the Town's best interest.

What are you saying?

[AngryPidgeon]

@AP- A man could choke on that WIFOM.

Pfffff. Lol. Then what isn't WIFOM? Don't answer that, its rhetorical. And if you say vote count analysis then you are mistaken.

Stifling D1 conversation, not waiting to hear anything from multiple player slots, Hammering before a consensus has been reached on the claim. These things are all AntiTown. I'm not saying they're scummy just yet, but they're definitely not in the Town's best interest.

Ok, but anti-town does not mean scummy. Open Space just ended (open 452?) in which Aether got speed lynched for voting someone confirmed town in the previous phase. He flipped town and everyone was surprised. The point is that town players do anti-town things. I would argue that they do them more frequently than scum players.

[AngryPidgeon]

I think hes talking about the qwints slot. But stifling conversation is ridiculous - I think his predecessor just flaked. That not a tell.

[AngryPidgeon]

Oh, Mastin is in this game now lol. Hi Mastin.

@Mastin: Opinion on D3x? (And well, I'd appreciate it if you comment on all of my scumreads: Jake, Thor, Kthx)

[d3x]

What are you saying?

I'm saying...

These things are all AntiTown.

...and I want to know qwints thoughts from qwints. I apreciate the attempt at chanelling him, though AP.

I have a few places my Vote wants to go, but I want to hear from him first. I'm well aware that no one is in danger of a Lynch this early, but I want players' thoughts on paper before I lay it down.

[zipperflesh]

VOTE: jake

him staying off. lynch looks a lot like scum trying .to buy town pants

[zipperflesh]

@AP- A man could choke on that WIFOM.

agreed

at best qwints is a null read until we here his reason for the hammer

[AngryPidgeon]

explain to me how that Hammer was proTown, plz.

Well it wasn't, and I know I was calling for the hammer. It was a town-tell though, regardless.

...and I want to know qwints thoughts from qwints. I apreciate the attempt at chanelling him, though AP.

I thought 475 was directed at me for my comments at the end of D1. I guess it wasnt?

P-edit: Lol, then what isn't WIFOM? What if Jake is town and has a policy for not lynching PR claims? Your jake=scum post is now WIFOM.

[zipperflesh]

i think you are missing. my point

[Kthxbye]

Vote: Zipperflesh

Could you give an explanation? It's not like people aren't going to ask for it, so why just post a vote and nothing else?

---------------------------------------------------------------

As for the qwints hammer post 1 from him....

On one hand, AP makes some good points in defense of a town-qwints. None of it is provable or course, but it would be a very (almost too) bold an act for a scum-qwint's to hammer a claimed PR first post into his part of this game. So bold, it'd be hard to believe that it would be coming from a scum...making people think he must be bold town and just simply really really thought dave was lying....

On the other side...

Stifling D1 conversation, not waiting to hear anything from multiple player slots, Hammering before a consensus has been reached on the claim. These things are all AntiTown. I'm not saying they're scummy just yet, but they're definitely not in the Town's best interest.

^this.

I however disagree with the anti-town not meaning scummy. By definition, anti-town actions are scummy imo.

I'm a firm believer in if it smells like scum, looks like scum, and acts like scum, it must be scum. NOT if it's too scummy to be scum it must be town. Broken down into simple math we have:

town-qwints scum-qwints
too bold a move for scum stopped day 1 very early
stopped day 1 with 2 replacements still being needed
hammered claimed (and now confirmed) PR role

town-qwints in this case is highly unlikely with only a WIFOM bullet to support it.

VOTE: qwints

qwints turns scum, AP probable scum as well.

[Kthxbye]

well, that didn't come out formatted very well....was trying to do side by side....instead I'll do this:

town-qwints

-too bold a move for scum

scum-qwints

-stopped day 1 very early
-stopped day 1 with 2 replacements still being needed
-hammered claimed (and now confirmed) PR role

[AngryPidgeon]

VOTE: kthxbye

K. This is good too.

[zipperflesh]

calling. it

ap qwints and jake

[Kthxbye]

AP: same as Thor, why?

Has not posting explanations and thoughts behind votes become a trend in the past two years or something?

[Kthxbye]

calling. it

ap qwints and jake

sigh....Zipper, what's your connecting factors for these 3 specifically?

[Kthxbye]

guess I should explain my connection for thinking scum-qwints probable scum-AP since I'm asking it of others. It's simply that p478 looks a lot like 'let me answer that for my scum buddy so he doesn't mess it up'. To have little suspicion of qwints after that hammer makes me think they likely already talked about how to spin it into a town-qwints pov during N1.

[Thor665]

Vote: Zipperflesh

Could you give an explanation? It's not like people aren't going to ask for it, so why just post a vote and nothing else?

Zipper knows why - note that he didn't even question it.
You should sheep me.

[zipperflesh]

i can picture their qt convo...

ap: lets be a thorn in Thors side
jake : dave looks an easy target lets tag team
devour: guys i just cant keep up... prb have to be replaced
ap: Dave wagon is a go go
jake: ill keep off the lynch since he claimed cop , but I'll spread some doubt about. his claim
qwints: hey guys... what should. i do
ap and jake: hammer the claimed cop! town will never buy that as a scum. move