Mini 1415: Fairly Oddparents Mafia Game Over

[numberQ]

The kids looked around. Most were in awe, but a few just yawned. Suddenly, a giant, heavily muscled man with white, cropped hair appeared in front of them.

“Welcome, puny humans, to Fairy World!” Jorgen Von Strangle floated above them menacingly. “We are fairies! We are magic! We are all powerful! We…” His lower lip wobbled. “We need your help!” Jorgen began to cry, and the children all exchanged awkward glances.

“Uh, what’s wrong?” one of them asked.

“The Anti-Fairies have all escaped! They are evil creatures, who do evil things! But mostly they’re just really, really annoying. Except this time, they stole our magic! Our Fairy Intelligence Agency thinks that the Anti-Fairies have disguised themselves as human children! And I think that those Anti-Fairies… are amongst you!” Jorgen blinked. “Although I don’t have any proof of that. I just grabbed a bunch of random kids.”

One of the kids raised their hand.

“Yes?” Jorgen said, pointing at them.

“Well, I-”

“NO QUESTIONS! Now, are there any questions? Good! Go find out who the Anti-Fairies are! Oh, and to help you, I will give you our very last reserves of magic… 26 Magic Muffins! 2 for each of you! You can make one wish, with no rules. But you puny Anti-Fairies hiding amongst these children should not try to use the Magic Muffins, because it will not work on you. Now go, save Fairy World!”

Mini 1415
Fairly Oddparents Mafia

Reviewer: Guy_Named_Riggs
Backup Mod: Agent_Ireland

Game Info:

Current Vote Count (3.0)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
MrZepher [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-25 18:25:00)

Player List (

Bold

is confirmed)

-L-

adorkable

Balrog

Benmage

captaineddie

Human Destroyer

kiwieagle

Klick

MrZepher

PeregrineV

Sanjay

Seanald

Vifam

* denotes a prod.

Spoiler: Alive Players (8/13)

-L-
Balrog
captaineddie
Human Destroyer
kiwieagle
MrZepher
Seanald
Vifam

Spoiler: Dead Players (5/13)

PeregrineV -

town aligned Timmy Turner

- zapped by Jorgen Day 1
adorkable -

mafia aligned Anti-Wanda

- shot by Human Destroyer Day 2
Klick -

town aligned Chester McBadbat

- spontaneously combusted Day 2
Benmage -

SK aligned Elmer

- zapped by Jorgen Day 2
Sanjay -

town aligned Obi-Sanjay Kenobi

- zapped Night 3

[numberQ]

Da Rules:

(Reference: Guy_Named_Riggs)

General

1. Be familiar with the sitewide rules and guidelines.
2. Personal attacks will not be tolerated. Use of homophobic, racist, sexist, or any other derogatory slurs -- even if made in a joking manner -- falls under this rule. Keep it civil. You will be given one warning; I particularly dislike this.
3. Unless otherwise specified in your role PM or by me, you may not communicate outside of this thread while the game is running. If someone contacts you outside of the game, please let me know immediately!
   
4. Do not quote any private communication to which you have access. This includes game-related PMs, instant messages, and QuickTopics. Quoting time stamps from any private communication is also forbidden. Paraphrasing is okay.
5. If it is not visible to the naked eye, do not post it. This includes, but is not limited to: invisible text, tiny text, encrypted text, and text hidden within tags. Spoiler text, however, is allowed, as long as it is used within reason. For cases of breadcrumbing where you aren't sure, please PM me beforehand.
6. If you have the ability to edit your posts, don't use it in my game.
7. Purple
   is reserved for the moderator. All other formatting is fair game with the provision that you do not impersonate me. Seriously. Don't do it.

Activity

1. Prods will be issued to players if they have not posted within a 48-hour period; they will have 24 hours to respond in the game thread before I search for a replacement. I will also send reminders on request as long as at least 30 (1 Day, 6 Hours) hours have passed since the player's last post.
2. Players who have been prodded 3 times are subject to replacement without further notice. Player-requested prods do not count toward this total.
3. If you anticipate being away for at least 48 hours, please PM me or post a V/LA notice in the thread with the expected date of your return.

Days and Nights

1. Days have a fixed duration of 3 weeks. Nights have a fixed duration of 3 days. Deadline extensions will be granted only in extreme circumstances.
   
2. Lynches occur through simple majority (50% of living players + 1, rounded down). If no majority is reached at deadline, plurality rules will apply. Once majority is reached, no further votes or unvotes will count.
   
3. Votes and vote revocations must be bolded (e.g.,
   Vote: numberQ
   and
   Unvote
   ). Unvotes are preferred but not necessary when switching votes (e.g.,
   Unvote, Vote: numberQ
   ). Use of the vote tags (e.g., VOTE: numberQ) is optional.
   
   
4. All players, including the lynched player, are allowed to discuss in twilight phase until I post the death scene. Dead players may make one "Bah!" post that contains no game-related content.

Moderator Actions

1. Flavor is for entertainment purposes only and has no significance in the game.
2. For minor questions or vote count errors, please bold your concern in the thread. For all other issues, use PM.
3. Pretending to break the rules or exploiting loopholes in the rules will be considered breaking the rules.
4. Any situation not covered above will be handled on a case-by-case basis.

Game Specific (aka, don't skim over this)

1. Every town player has 2 Wish Muffins with which they can make wishes.
   
2. The Anti-Fairies cannot make wishes. At night, they can make one factional kill. Alternatively, the can backfire 2 wishes, which will reverse the wishes effect.
   
3. Wishes cannot target more than one person (e.g., “Kill the entire mafia team.” or “Investigate everyone in the game.”).
   
4. Wishes cannot have a vague recipient (e.g., “Kill a mafia member.” or “Protect someone who is going to die tonight.”). You must specifically say who you’re targeting.
   
5. Wishes cannot instantly end the game (e.g., “I wish town wins.”). If the wish only has a side effect of ending the game, such as killing the last remaining mafia member, this rule obviously doesn’t apply.
   
6. Wishes cannot permanently give someone an effect (e.g., permanently death-proof, permanently lose your vote). For the most part, if giving someone an effect is involved, I’ll only allow it for one day. For the most part. ADDENDUM: You may change your role or someone else's role permanently, but only to a certain extent. Most modifiers are only allowed to be 1-shot.
   
7. No wishing for more wishes. That’s just plain wrong.
   
8. No wishing for a better tasting muffin.
   
9. You cannot wish to know the intentions of another person's post. I don't have that much faith in my abilities to gauge intentions.
   
10. Wishes must be made at night.
    
11. Wishes cannot affect the mod (e.g., telling me to say something, or restricting my posts in some way).
    
12. Only one wish can be made per night.
    
13. Upon death, Jorgen comes and takes all your remaining Wish Muffins, so you can't make anymore wishes. The Fairies have to conserve their magic somehow, right?
    
14. In the end, I have full discretion over whether or not I’ll use a wish. If I don’t use a wish because of something not included in the rules, I will update the rules accordingly. I’ll also tell you I won’t use the wish and give you a chance to come up with a different one, so don’t be afraid to try.
    
15. All wishes will be resolved simultaneously just before the start of Day. Natural Action Resolution will be used, though in that case of more unorthodox wishes, I'll have to use my best judgment to decide what order they go in.
    
16. Most of all, be creative! Think outside the box. Go wild. Etc.

Please PM me if you need clarification on anything in the rules.

Biggest rule: Mafia is just a game, so play to win, but more importantly, play to have fun!

[numberQ]

Setup:

10 people will receive this:

Role Name

Paragraph of flavor!

[-]

During the day, you may talk and vote.

[-]

You also have 2 Magic Muffins! You may use them to make wishes at night. See the thread for wish limitations.

[-]

You win when the Anti-Fairies are no longer a threat.

Game thread is here. Confirm via PM.

3 people will receive this:

Role Name

Paragraph of flavor!

[-]

You may talk to your partners at night here.

[-]

At night your faction may backfire one person’s wish, which reverses the wish’s effect. Your faction may also kill someone at night.

[-]

You win when the kids are no longer a threat, or nothing can prevent the same.

Game thread is here. Confirm via PM.

[numberQ]

Role PMs will be out soon.

[numberQ]

Took longer than I expected, but role PMs are out! Game will begin once 11/13 players have confirmed.

[numberQ]

New rules added:

[-]

You cannot wish to know the intentions of another person's post. I don't have that much faith in my abilities to gauge intentions.

[-]

Wishes must be made at night.

[-]

Wishes cannot affect the mod (e.g., telling me to say something, or restricting my posts in some way).

[-]

Both wishes can be used on the same night, but if you are targeted to be backfired, both wishes will be backfired.

Also, you may have noticed the pound signs in the title. This is because I don't think I had the right game number earlier. It'll be changed as soon as I hear back from the list mod.

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.0)

-L- [0]
adorkable [0]
Balrog [0]
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [0]
MrZephyr [0]
PeregrineV [0]
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

You may now post.

kiwieagle has 24 hours to post before I look for a replacement.

[numberQ]

While I congratulate Balrog on his clever plan, I'm sorry to say that no mod wants to see their game broken that easily. After careful consideration, I have decided to alter two rules.

First, the rule that allowed both wishes to be used in one night has been revoked. You may now only make one wish at night.

Second, and this is something that I was wrestling with since my initial plans of this setup, I'm going to give the mafia a slight buff. As of now, they can choose to either backfire OR kill each night. However, if they backfire, they can backfire 2 wishes. I feel this is a necessary change that hopefully balances the game a bit more.

PEdit: Human Destroyer, that is not allowed. Wishes cannot control the mod.

[numberQ]

You guys are killing me. In the interest of not having the game end instantly, I'm going back on what I said. Wishes can and will be prevented if I suspect intentional game breaking.

[numberQ]

Because of the clusterfuck that has been the game so far, I'm considering a restart with the modified rules. We'll put it to a vote, and as always, majority rules.

Restart [0]
Don't Restart [0]

[numberQ]

No restart.

Things are fine the way they are.

I guess the best question to ask is

@NumQ- How much coordination are we allowed to have/use?

I never said you couldn't coordinate. It's the game breaking I don't like.

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.1)

-L- [0]
adorkable [1] PeregrineV
Balrog [0]
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [0]
MrZepher [4] Klick, Human Destroyer, Vifam, Sanjay
PeregrineV [2] adorkable, benmage
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [2] Balrog, kiwieagle

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-, captaineddie, MrZepher, Seanald

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

After some consideration, I have decided not to restart the game. I don't think the amount of discussion contributed due to shenanigans at the beginning is enough to warrant a restart, especially considering the nature of this game (a nature that has hopefully been fixed in the last 8 pages).

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.2)

-L- [1] Seanald
adorkable [1] PeregrineV
Balrog [0]
Benmage [1] Sanjay
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [0]

[L-2] MrZepher [5] Klick, Human Destroyer, Vifam, Balrog, captaineddie

PeregrineV [2] adorkable, benmage
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [2] kiwieagle, MrZepher

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

[numberQ]

New rule added:

[-]

Upon death, Jorgen comes and takes all your remaining Wish Muffins, so you can't make anymore wishes. The Fairies have to conserve their magic somehow, right?

The game number has been fixed, as well.

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.3)

-L- [3] Seanald, Balrog, captaineddie
adorkable [0]
Balrog [0]
Benmage [1] Sanjay
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [1] MrZepher
MrZepher [1] Klick
PeregrineV [2] adorkable, benmage
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [2] kiwieagle, PeregrineV

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-, Human Destroyer, Vifam

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

[numberQ]

Changed a rule slightly that I meant to change a while ago, but just now got around to it:

[-]

Wishes cannot permanently give someone an effect (e.g., permanently death-proof, permanently lose your vote). For the most part, if giving someone an effect is involved, I’ll only allow it for one day. For the most part. ADDENDUM: You may change your role or someone else's role permanently, but only to a certain extent. Most modifiers are only allowed to be 1-shot.

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.4)

-L- [3] Seanald, Balrog, captaineddie
adorkable [0]
Balrog [1] -L-
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [1] MrZepher
MrZepher [1] Klick

[L-2] PeregrineV [5] adorkable, benmage, Sanjay, Vifam, Human Destroyer

Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [2] kiwieagle, PeregrineV

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

No one

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.5)

-L- [3] Seanald, Balrog, captaineddie
adorkable [0]
Balrog [2] -L-, kiwieagle
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [1] Klick
Klick [2] MrZepher, Human Destroyer
MrZepher [0]
PeregrineV [3] adorkable, Sanjay, Vifam
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [1] PeregrineV

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Benmage

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-12 16:45:00)

[numberQ]

Vote Count (1.6)

-L- [0]
adorkable [0]
Balrog [1] kiwieagle
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [1] Klick
Human Destroyer [1] Benmage
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [3] Human Destroyer, Seanald, captaineddie
MrZepher [0]

[LYNCH] PeregrineV [7] adorkable, Sanjay, Vifam, Balrog, -L-, MrZepher, PeregrineV

Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [1] PeregrineV

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

No one

Locking the thread, night will begin once I post the lynch scene.[/color]

[numberQ]

Jorgen looked up from his book.

“Are you puny humans finally done deciding?”

His copy of ‘Magic for Dummies (And Jorgen Von Strangle)’ poofed out of existence as he floated menacingly towards the only kid standing alone. The rest pointed accusatory fingers at him, even as he denied every accusation.

Jorgen and the kids closed in on him, shouting, until finally he threw his hat to the ground and shouted. “Alright, you think I stole the magic? Then yeah, it was me, I stole the magic! I, Timmy Turner, stole Fairy World’s magic!”

“Good enough for me!” Jorgen said happily, as he zapped the red shirted boy. Timmy instantly turned into a pile of smoking dust. Jorgen blinked. “Oh. I meant to turn him back into an Anti-Fairy. That was not supposed to happen! You puny children! You have chosen the wrong person, he was just a puny earth child, not a puny Anti-Fairy!”

PeregrineV,

Timmy Turner

, has been zapped by Jorgen Day 1.

Night begins now! Night will end in (expired on 2013-01-31 18:25:00)

[numberQ]

Because my backup mod and I will both be busy when the day is scheduled to start tonight, expect it an hour or too late. Consider the wish deadline still 9 hours from now, though.

[numberQ]

12 children, tired after a night of thinking, wishing, and conniving, snoozed in pink bedrolls. The sun shone it's light gently across their faces, causing some to turn in their blankets, snug and secure. All was peaceful and quiet.

"WAKE UP, PUNY CHILDREN!" shouted Jorgen, ruining it. The kids jumped and, after escaping their now-tangled bedrolls, stood at attention before Jorgen. He did a quick head count. "10, 11, 12... Oh no! Puny children, one of you is missing!" He paused for dramatic effect. "They are probably... dead!"

"Uh, Jorgen, the only person missing

is

dead. It was Timmy. You killed him," explained one of the kids.

"Oh yeah! Well, then what are you waiting for? Do what you did yesterday, but better!" Jorgen floated away a few meters with his arms crossed, then poofed out of their sight. The kids looked at each other and gulped. Time to get to work.

Day 2 begins!

Vote Count (2.0)

-L- [0]
adorkable [0]
Balrog [0]
Benmage [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [0]
MrZephyr [0]
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-21 19:05:00)

[numberQ]

A magical bolt of lightning struck adorkable squarely in the face. Everyone turned to Human Destroyer, the one who fired it, until Jorgen appeared over them.

As Vicky's body fell to the ground, he shouted, "What have you done?! You puny humans killed someone without voting on it?"



Then someone gasped, and pointed at the body. It was surrounded by a purple cloud, as if something poofed at the very spot. The cloud parted, and Jorgen screamed.

"That is not a puny human! It is a puny Anti-Fairy!" He bent down to examine its body. "It is a puny Anti-

Wanda

!"

adorkable,

Anti-Wanda

, has been shot by Human Destroyer Day 2.

[numberQ]

Forgot this:

PEdit: Fast voting is fast.

Vote Count (2.1)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]
Benmage [1] Human Destroyer
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
Klick [0]
MrZephyr [0]
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [1] MrZepher

With 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-, Balrog, Benmage, captaineddie, kiwieagle, Klick, Sanjay, Seanald, Vifam

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-21 19:05:00)

[numberQ]

Suddenly, Chester McBadbat spontaneously combusted!

Klick,

Chester McBadbat

, has spontaneously combusted Day 2.

[numberQ]

Forgot this again...

PEdit: Ninja'd again...

Vote Count (2.2)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]
Benmage [1] Sanjay
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
MrZephyr [0]
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-, Balrog, Benmage, captaineddie, Human Destroyer, kiwieagle, MrZepher, Sanjay, Seanald, Vifam

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-21 19:05:00)

[numberQ]

@Mod: How did you allow a single ability to target two people in one Night? You told me that you could not make such a wish.

I wouldn't consider being put in a QT as being targeted. I suppose it's possible to say that you were targeted because -L- turned you into a neighbor, but it seemed to me more like the former than the latter.

Vote Count (2.3)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]

[LYNCH] Benmage [6] Sanjay, MrZepher, Vifam, Balrog, Seanald, Human Destroyer

captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
MrZephyr [0]
Sanjay [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Not Voting:

-L-, Benmage, captaineddie, kiwieagle

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-21 19:05:00)

Night begins once the death scene is posted.

[numberQ]

Benmage's wish makes me think that this game might be more amazing if the bad guys had wishes too. It's kind of hard for mafia to fake infinite cosmic power.

In other news, I think it is kinda weird that the thread hasn't been shut now. I sent numberQ a PM, he picked it up, and I saw him looking at the thread. I have a small suspicion of shenanigans.

Oh, and these "shenanigans" were just me being at computers throughout the day, but not for enough time to do the lynch. Sorry it took so long everyone.

[numberQ]

Jorgen appear, and looked down at himself. He squealed, before disappearing and reappearing, this time wearing more than just a towel, some suds, and a rubber ducky.

"Now! Have you decided, puny children?" he asked, staring at them menacingly. Almost immediately they pushed one of the kids forward. Elmer, his boil jiggling angrily, stumbled towards Jorgen, who raised his massive wand.

"Then die, puny Anti-Fairy!" Jorgen pointed the pointy bit in Elmer's direction and let loose an arc of magical lightning, disintegrating Elmer to dust. Jorgen blinked once, then bent down to examine the remains. "Aha! This puny Anti-Fairy was actually a puny human, but look!" He raised a butcher's knife into the air. "He had his own puny plans!"

Benmage,

Elmer, Serial Killer

, has been zapped by Jorgen Day 2.

And night begins. The deadline for Day 3 is in (expired on 2013-02-04 18:25:00).

[numberQ]

Another day. Each child woke up, stretching, wondering what did or did not happen at night.

Jorgen poofed into existence next to them. "Puny children! I see you have finally woken up! You will not be happy to hear... that one of you is DEAD!" Everyone gasped. Who died? Was someone missing? They chattered amongst themselves until Jorgen shouted, "QUIET! You're giving me a headache! You should know that the person who died is still here! He is... a GHOST!"

Suddenly, someone materialized behind Jorgen. "He can talk," Jorgen said, "but nothing else!" Sanjay waved at the children, who closed their open mouths. "Now go do what you always do!" Jorgen disappeared into a purple cloud, leaving the children alone once more.

Sanjay,

Obi-Sanjay Kenobi, 2-shot weak neighborizing reflexive tree stump

, has been zapped Night 2.

Day 3 begins!

[/color]

Vote Count (3.0)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
kiwieagle [0]
MrZepher [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-25 18:25:00)

[numberQ]

Once again, a bolt of magical lightning flew out of Human Destroyer and hit someone in the face. This time, it was kiwieagle who fell to the ground.

Jorgen appeared and shouted, "You again? Look what you have done! The puny Veronica is dead!"



Jorgen pointed with his wand at Veronica's body, but it was gone. Instead, in it's place, was...

"Anti-Cosmo?" Jorgen said, scratching his head.

kiwieagle,

Anti-Cosmo

, has been shot by Human Destroyer Day 3.

Vote Count (3.1)

-L- [0]
Balrog [0]
captaineddie [0]
Human Destroyer [0]
MrZepher [0]
Seanald [0]
Vifam [0]

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Not Voting:

Everyone

Deadline:

(expired on 2013-02-25 18:25:00)

[numberQ]

Lightsaber: Seanald

The answer is probably obvious, but I feel like I should ask anyway, for the sake of Da Rules... Is this a vote?

[numberQ]

After a few short minutes, Jorgen reappeared.

"Puny humans! I was about to get a bath! You think you can find the last puny Anti-Fairy that quickly? Don't make me laugh! I-"

"Oh, screw this," captaineddie said. "Seanald is scum, and Vifam should die!" He sent a bolt of magical lightning at Vifam's face. Remy Buxaplenty was suddenly a pile of ashes.

Jorgen was silent for a moment. Then he shrugged, and similarly blasted Seanald in the face. Chad, too, became nothing but dust.





"Wait for it... Keep waiting... Now!" Jorgen said, just as a blue cloud popped into existence around Chad. The dust cleared, and in Chad's place was a very cube-shaped Anti-Fairy.

"Foop!" Jorgen shouted. "You puny-humans managed to get all the Anti-Fairies. Good! Now... forget everything!" Jorgen sent a burst of magic at the remaining living children. The next morning, they woke up in their beds, the memories of their time in Fairy World quickly fading.

Vifam,

Remy Buxaplenty

, was shot by captaineddie Day 3.

Seanald,

Foop

, has been zapped by Jorgen Day 3.

-L-,

Francis

, survived.

Balrog,

Trixie Tang

, survived.

captaineddie,

Tootie

, survived.

Human Destroyer,

General Cow Cow

, survived.

MrZepher,

Tad

, survived.

Town wins!

[numberQ]

WOO that was a doozy. This entire game was a clusterfuck of a disaster from the get go, but despite all that, I had a ton of fun. I'll admit a lot of it came from bad modding; accidentally confirming Balrog as town was a big one, although I'd like to say that I would have responded in that manner to a game breaking strategy no matter the strategist's alignment. That's no excuse though, since I should have had rules like that in from the beginning. I also didn't even think to send out confirmation PMs for role changes on Night 1, which is why Benmage acted oddly. Sorry Benmage.

As for the setup, back when I was a naive young boy (a few weeks ago, before this game started), I actually thought that this setup was essentially balanced. Sure, maybe a little swingy, but that's why I gave scum the backfire ability. Surely then it would be ok! Yeah, I was wrong. However, in the sense that this game was an experiment to see if this kind of mechanic could work, I'd say it was a success! I think that, with a lot of tweaking, it could definitely work, and I'd like to try it out again sometime.

Anyway, you all did great, even the people who kept trying to break the game. I think I learned a lot about modding (rule 1: don't make a retardedly broken setup), and since this is only my second modded game, any experience is good experience. So thanks everyone!

Dead Thread
Scum QT
-L-, Balrog, and Benmage Neighborhood

Give me a sec and I'll post all the night actions.

[numberQ]

Night 1:

-L- wished for a neighborhood with Balrog and Benmage.
Balrog wished for whoever backfired this wish to survive the night.
Benmage wished to be a bulletproof SK. Then, because of mod stupidity, I allowed him to become an investigationproof SK during day 2.
captaineddie wished to know the wish of MrZepher.
Human Destroyer wished to be a 1-shot dayvig.
Klick wished to give himself a truth-only post restriction. I further refined it so he would get a warning the first time he broke it and death the second time.
MrZepher wished to know the name and alignment of anyone who targeted him that night.
Sanjay wished to become Obi-Sanjay Kenobi, a reflexive treestump.
Vifam wished to investigate adorkable.
adorkable backfired MrZepher, and Seanald backfired Vifam.

Night 2:

-L- wished to be a day JOAT with a 1-shot cop and 1-shot vig.
Sanjay wished to add a 1-shot weak neighborizer to his role. Balrog wished to make Sanjay's role better, so I gave Sanjay a 2-shot weak neighborizer instead.
captaineddie wished for a 1-shot dayvig.
Human Destroyer wished to be a 1-shot dayvig, and to change his role to General Cow Cow... ask him, I have no idea.
MrZepher wished to be vengeful for the night phase.
Vifam wished to steal one of Sanjay's abilities, and got the reflexive treestump.
And Seanald killed Sanjay.

[numberQ]

Town have AMAZING abilities that can literally blow scum out of the water.

Benmage decides to become an SK because town isn't good enough for him


What an idiot lmfao

Weren't you the one who didn't want to break the game because you wanted to have fun with your wishes? Benmage thought being an SK would be fun. Personally, I'm glad he did it, it definitely makes things more interesting. Or it would have, but, yknow, whoops. : P

So numberQ, if you were to run this again, what do you think you would change?

It was fun btw ^_^

Well, one thing I was mulling over was giving the mafia wishes. Probably not the same amount town have, because then that's essentially 6 possible nightkills, but maybe 1 each or 2 for the entire faction or something like that.

[numberQ]

I feel that the town-confirming nature of day wishes would be balanced by allowing the mafia to make wishes as well. Of course, that would also have to be balanced but I'd rather allow as many options as possible. Makes it funner imo

[numberQ]

welp, there you go.

rule number one of modding: get your setup reviewed, even if you don't think it needs it.

lesson hopefully learned for next time, at least?

Yeah, lesson 110% learned. No offense, Riggs. : P

[numberQ]

Oh, and to Sanjay: if you were serious about wanting to help, just know that I won't be modding another game like this until AT LEAST after my next modded game, which will be after someone else's game, since we'll be co-modding. We got some hopefully pretty awesome stuff planned out.