Mini 1414: Mafia and Werewolves - Game Over

[rapidcanyon]

VOTE COUNT 1.3

Revenus

- 4/7 (JasonWazza, evilpacman18, Hiraki, Josh Lyman)

Golden Mean

- 2/7 (WT Snacks, the director)

the director

- 1/7 (Xegarus)

Josh Lyman

- 1/7 (Revenus)

WT Snacks

- 1/7 (Navarre)

evilpacman18

- 1/7 (Hume)

Not Voting (3)

: JacobSavage, YOLO, Golden Mean

Deadline

: February 6th, 10PM, PST.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2013-02-06 22:00:00)

[Revenus]

Because at least Jacob has given out some reads and is honest.

I take back what I said about you being town leaning.

[evilpacman18]

To be fair I also almost confused the names Jacob and Jason

[Josh Lyman]

More votes on Revenus, please.

Just 3 more.

[the director]

morons

[Josh Lyman]

.....who?

[the director]

yes

[Navarre]

After doing a quick skim of the game so far.

The most scummy is of course Revenue and i have noticed that nearly all of his posts have been useless filler posts that have absolutely nothing to do with scumhunting at all. His cynical play style from page 1 also irks me for some reason.

Hiraki's posts at the beginning seem town like and reasonable but lately his posts don't seem to have any support to his opinions. He also tries to vote me for adressing nothing not less then 24 hours after game starts.

VOTE: Navarre

for addressing nothing

To me this isn't a RV, this could be Hiraki's attempt at trying to get votes of revenue/golden mean.

[Revenus]

The most scummy is of course Revenue and i have noticed that nearly all of his posts have been useless filler posts that have absolutely nothing to do with scumhunting at all. His cynical play style from page 1 also irks me for some reason.

Don't misrep me; everything after #68 is clear posting of reads, which is far more than what you've done so far.

[evilpacman18]

After doing a quick skim of the game so far.

The most scummy is of course Revenue and i have noticed that nearly all of his posts have been useless filler posts that have absolutely nothing to do with scumhunting at all. His cynical play style from page 1 also irks me for some reason.

Hiraki's posts at the beginning seem town like and reasonable but lately his posts don't seem to have any support to his opinions. He also tries to vote me for adressing nothing not less then 24 hours after game starts.

VOTE: Navarre

for addressing nothing

To me this isn't a RV, this could be Hiraki's attempt at trying to get votes of revenue/golden mean.

Vote

[Revenus]

Thought I submitted a post earlier; Navarre; I want your reads on everyone else instead of commenting on A. the guy everyone is calling scummy (me), and B. vaguely OMGusing the guy calling you out.

[Revenus]

Because right now it looks like you waited for the situation involving me to blow over so you could safely just come in and only comment on it. Why exactly do you think i'm scummy? Is every single vote on me valid? What are your reads on other people?!??!!?

[JasonWazza]

UNVOTE: Revenus
VOTE: Hiraki

[Xegarus]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Hiraki

[Revenus]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Hiraki

Not that I'm particuarly opposed to a wagon on Hiraki right now, but seriously? Jason can vote Hiraki because unlike you, he gives us a logical progression building up to his vote on the dude, but all I've seen from you is one pretty neutral question towards him.

Reasons why, now.

[Xegarus]

Reasons why, now.

Later

[the director]

For the sake of my sanity, lets wait for the mod to prod those who have yet to post because that would be awesome.

[Hiraki]

this could be Hiraki's attempt at trying to get votes of revenue/golden mean.

No, this is making sure you die.

[YOLO]

Quick RVS. While I don't mind pressure being put on weak RVS votes, I don't see it as a scumtell at all either. From there on I haven't seen any real scummy behaviour from Revenus, so I don't really care atm. I really dislike using meta btw (meta'ing as in: skimming a few games real quick).

Because at least Jacob has given out some reads and is honest.

This post implies you think some other players are not honest. Who?

[JacobSavage]

To be fair I also almost confused the names Jacob and Jason

Everyone does, just call be JS, its shorter to type too x

On a "serious" note, Xergus why the sheeping Jason, I agree he's town (his play here matches how I've seen him play in other games as town, See Mini 1397 (he replaced out Day 1/2 but anyway) and Micro 104 to give you some idea of what I mean.) but his reason seam's to be that he was content with me. In fairness I can see his point, I'm not totally content with my play but I wouldn't say its more scummy that Revenus's reaction to his "day-kill" (On an aside, its getting quite old, I've rarley been in a game where somebody hasn't tried to Day-kill someone D1 and its not like Revenus is new here). Taking that and running with it, I can't see that Revenus has never seen the DayKill-Reaction test before, and I suspect that he may of used it as an attempt to get town points. His reations seam forced and not genuine which kind of backs up my point. His "any reaction would make me scummy" point reads under this interpretation as annoyance that his gambit failed.

tl;dr Revenus faked reaction to Day Vig in order to try and get town points.

Also remind me to:

1. Look at Revenus Meta to see if anyone has used a Day Vig in his games
   
2. Re-do this post to try and make it make more sense
   
3. Do my washing

VOTE: Revenus

[Hiraki]

This post implies you think some other players are not honest. Who?

Revenus, to start.

Not sure if EPM believes everything he says (say with Hume) but I don't find that to be a major scumtell.

[evilpacman18]

UNVOTE: Revenus
VOTE: Hiraki

What are you doing

[Revenus]

Dear evilpacman

Why do you think Hume is town when he's posting stuff like this about you

I dislike this post because it isn't even true. Take a look at Newbie 1156 in ISO. This is exactly how Revenus plays as town. I don't like it. I think it's poor play for town. But that doesn't change the fact that's how Revenus plays as town.

[Revenus]

Oh yeah: JS, why don't you actually find out if I've seen a guy who legit faked dayvig who targeted me in a game.


Otherwise, fuck off, I'm doubting you're gonna actually go through my meta; your vote is fucking weak.

[JacobSavage]

It's a note to go through it at some point. And its not just forgetting you, using it in a game.