Mini 1414: Mafia and Werewolves - Game Over

[JacobSavage]

Edit why don't people have up to date wikis!

[rapidcanyon]

VOTE COUNT 1.4

Revenus

- 4/7 (evilpacman18, Hiraki, Josh Lyman, JacobSavage)

Golden Mean

- 2/7 (WT Snacks, the director)

Hiraki

- 2/7 (JasonWazza, Xegarus)

Josh Lyman

- 1/7 (Revenus)

WT Snacks

- 1/7 (Navarre)

evilpacman18

- 1/7 (Hume)

Not Voting (2)

: YOLO, Golden Mean

Deadline

: February 6th, 10PM, PST.

Day 1 ends in (expired on 2013-02-06 22:00:00)

[evilpacman18]

Dear evilpacman

Why do you think Hume is town when he's posting stuff like this about you

I dislike this post because it isn't even true. Take a look at Newbie 1156 in ISO. This is exactly how Revenus plays as town. I don't like it. I think it's poor play for town. But that doesn't change the fact that's how Revenus plays as town.

Because, regardless of whether I think he's right or not, it looks like he's legitimately scumhunting and believes what he's saying.

[YOLO]

On a "serious" note, Xergus why the sheeping Jason, I agree he's town (his play here matches how I've seen him play in other games as town, See Mini 1397 (he replaced out Day 1/2 but anyway) and Micro 104 to give you some idea of what I mean.)

Did you also find games where he was mafia and played noticeably different? Because otherwise 'Jason plays like Jason' tells us absolutely nothing about his alignment.

I really dislike votes without reasoning btw (post 112 and 113). Not explaining your behaviour is something scum wants to do. In fact, this game becomes nearly impossible to win for town if people don't explain what they're doing and go full force ego-mode thinking they found some kind of brilliant method that's going to find them mafioso on Day 1.

[JasonWazza]

On a "serious" note, Xergus why the sheeping Jason, I agree he's town (his play here matches how I've seen him play in other games as town, See Mini 1397 (he replaced out Day 1/2 but anyway) and Micro 104 to give you some idea of what I mean.)

Did you also find games where he was mafia and played noticeably different? Because otherwise 'Jason plays like Jason' tells us absolutely nothing about his alignment.

I swear i (and a few others) just finished saying this about Revenus, are you actually reading the game?

UNVOTE: Hiraki
VOTE: YOLO

UNVOTE: Revenus
VOTE: Hiraki

What are you doing

Playing to my wincon and getting reads, you? (btw there was a logical thought coming up to this vote i just didn't vote at the time)

[Hiraki]

YOLO is by far the towniest person in the game, thanks.

[the director]

YOLO is by far the towniest person in the game, thanks.

He makes three posts and is the towniest person in the game? Please tell me this is sarcasm.

[Hiraki]

Oh--must've been thinking about the wrong guy in hindsight.

[evilpacman18]

Oh--must've been thinking about the wrong guy in hindsight.

How could you even confuse me and him?

[evilpacman18]

Jason don't be such a prostitute with your vote, it's annoying.

[JasonWazza]

Jason don't be such a prostitute with your vote, it's annoying.

You saying i shouldn't scumhunt?

[evilpacman18]

I'm saying it's more effective to scumhunt without throwing your vote around every time you have the slightest suspicion. Voting so often is antitown.

[Hiraki]

I didn't confuse him with you.

Can't remember who I did though. Oh well.

[JasonWazza]

I'm saying it's more effective to scumhunt without throwing your vote around every time you have the slightest suspicion.

Voting so often is antitown.

Bullshit, this is how i play and it isn't anti-town i'm not gonna change just because you don't like it.

[evilpacman18]

Oh you're one of those 'votes create pressure' people. Ok nvm, not even gonna go there. I think you're town anyway. As long as your vote comes back to Revenus at some point.

[Josh Lyman]

Voting so often is antitown.

I'd love to hear your rationale for this.

I didn't confuse him with you.

Can't remember who I did though. Oh well.

I do not like this at all.

Not at all.

unvote

Vote: Hiraki

[Revenus]

I didn't confuse him with you.

Can't remember who I did though. Oh well.

Wait, you can't remember who you think the towniest person in the game is? What? This is the SECOND time you've done something like this.

Oh you're one of those 'votes create pressure' people. Ok nvm, not even gonna go there. I think you're town anyway. As long as your vote comes back to Revenus at some point.

Um, are you saying votes don't create pressure? What are you talking about?


and

I'm saying it's more effective to scumhunt without throwing your vote around every time you have the slightest suspicion. Voting so often is antitown.

Looking at your content so far, the only person you've attacked so far is me, so don't lecture other people on scumhunting.

[Revenus]

Also, gonna go back and address this

His "any reaction would make me scummy" point reads under this interpretation as annoyance that his gambit failed.

You do realize JL said this:

I was not looking for any specific reaction, I was just looking for any reaction. And I got one. And I'm voting you, because you're scum.

Additionally, your entire case is that I HAD to have been faking a reaction, which you base off an assumption that I've seen someone seriously fakeclaiming a dayvig, again, I haven't seen it in any of my finished games, so your case is built on a mountain of bull. You don't even address any other players in the game; your only content of note is 4 posts of fluff, and one post attacking me.

Your case is stupid, and in conjunction with

Because at least Jacob has given out some reads and is honest.

When your only content was post 56 and post 64 seriously makes me suspect both of you as a likely scumteam.

Vote:JacobSavage

[Revenus]

If anyone is unclear, post #142 is addressed to JacobSavage

[Navarre]

Evilpacman, you comment on everyone's ability to scumhunt yet you post no reads yourself and have not done any scumhunting yourself and to me this makes you lean scum.

Xegarus, We still need a reason for your sheeping vote.

UNVOTE: Hiraki
VOTE: Xegarus

Jason are you voting YOLO just because he doesn't understand points that have been made? Because to me YOLO seems more towny then a lot of other players in this game.

[JasonWazza]

Jason are you voting YOLO just because he doesn't understand points that have been made? Because to me YOLO seems more towny then a lot of other players in this game.

Because anyone reading the game and actually scum-hunting would have seen the same argument like 10 posts before and not just repeated it.

Not to mention he hasn't actually talked about much, how can you get a town read on someone with 3 posts that actually has next to no scum-hunting or content on any posts?

[JasonWazza]

As long as your vote comes back to Revenus at some point.

Least he is one of the ones that is scum hunting and not just hiding at the back atm.

Put it like this, he may be scum, even scum can be useful to the town for now (2 scum teams means that scum have to find the other team at least)

(plus his scum hunting doesn't seem all that contrived atm)

[Xegarus]

Xegarus, We still need a reason for your sheeping vote.

UNVOTE: Hiraki
VOTE: Xegarus

one of those 'votes create pressure' people.

He hasn't commented on the vote at all, so don't exactly know what he's doing.
I'm pretty sure voting someone without posting a reason would tick said person off, atleast enough to say something about.

[Hiraki]

I do not like this at all.

Not at all.

Navarre still needs to die nowish.

[JasonWazza]

I do not like this at all.

Not at all.

Navarre still needs to die nowish.

Navarre has done more then a few people, why is he the only one that needs to die?