Khan's Wacky Xylbot Mafia (Mini 1418) - Game Over

[Zang]

No. I'm not going to vote someone just because you threaten me with your vote.

[MrObvious]

Then my vote stays. Die scum misrepper.

[MrObvious]

MrObvious: sometimes one sibling is mafia, the rest of the time both are town. That's definitely what it means. He was also pretty clearly using "lover" as a way to explain the role.

He could be lying about the sibling part and actually be a lover in the sense of the wiki.

[Shmugen]

I wish we could kill you today, MrObvious. Don't let your immunity today go to your head. Think about stuff.

[Kthxbye]

Yeah, town is fucked. GG scum.

[MrObvious]

I wish you had already killed me, Schmugen.

[MrObvious]

AJ soft claimed an investigative role. I'm not lynching him. If it's AJ vs Zang, my choice is Zang. I'd rather lynch VoidedMafia or TML, in that order.

[Zang]

What the fuck? Can you read? It's imposible for him to be anything but a Xylbot role, that's the while point of this game, Xylbot Mafia. He can not be a lover and there can not be two mafia siblings.

[MrObvious]

Ok, let's use your reasoning. If TML is telling the truth, we should lynch him because there is a high likelihood that he or his sibling is scum.

So, vote TML and I'll gladly follow.

[Aj The Epic]

-MrO, I'm NOT softclaiming. I was planning on using hard logic.
-Zang is definitely scum.

If I had to guess right now, you're dealing with scumZang, scumVoid, and PossibleScumObv, though the last shouldn't be lynched without being sure. I've been thinking on Kthx to see what motivation it has to claim poisoner (a role I always associate as a mafia support role over vig). I can MAYBE see a sk claim poisoner, but the issue is, the SK would be fairly fucked at this point. So, in a way, after reviewing, Kthx is probably town for claiming that.

I still want to say Leaf is town. I also think that you're looking in the wrong place with katsuki. TML isn't a safe lynch without conclusive evidence and a full day. You're dealing with a time bomb and just because he doesn't die won't mean that he's scum, it actually may point to a scum being at the other end. The issue is, you still can't afford to risk killing him at this point.

Someone needs to check (since I don't know how to do the command) if you'd know that Reck's role had bit dust and then come back. Remember, if you don't know he's died, you're in a shitton of trouble if he comes back scum.

Shos is town
Scooby's AtE needs to cool, because that kind of ballistics in later days will make you the leader of every wagon scum supports. He is most likely town, though.
Wind-up needs to post more. When I can't think of a stance you have, you're probably coasting.

Someone needs to vote count.

[MrObvious]

The issue is, you still can't afford to risk killing him at this point.

It's safer killing him now than later.

-----

Ok, I'll take your word that you didn't soft claim. That puts you back in the lynchable category.

I'd revote you now, but Zang sure is squirming.

[MrObvious]

Oh, FTR, the word xylbot didn't mean shit to me until this last page.

[Aj The Epic]

It's safer killing him now than later.

That's looking at the lynch solely from a numbers perspective. With more information comes a better informed lynch.

[Kthxbye]

WTF...seriously AJ???? NOW you decide to post like a townie with brains????

This day needs to fucking end cuz I fucking hate D1. Only good thing about it is it sets up a D2...

[MrObvious]

Here's the possibilities that I see.

1) If a townie sibling doesn't come forth, it's because they are scum. Lynch TML, even trade. I'll take it every time.
2) If a townie sibling does come forth, it's because TML is scum. Lynch TML, even trade. I'll take it every time.
3) TML is lying scum and there is no sibling to come forth.
4) TML is telling the truth and is town and his sibling is town. This is the least likely possibility in my mind.

From the wiki, which the xylbot list is surely inspired by...

"Lovers can have a number of unannounced additions to the above definition, such as the ability to talk to each other or confirmation of each others' alignment (but usually only if they are both Town)."

If TML doesn't know who his sibling is, I'd be willing to be it is because his sibling is of different alignment.

[Aj The Epic]

WTF...seriously AJ???? NOW you decide to post like a townie with brains????

I'd hope your opinion isn't changing just because I'm not calling you scum.

[Voidedmafia]

If I had to guess right now, you're dealing with scumZang, scumVoid, and PossibleScumObv, though the last shouldn't be lynched without being sure.

Someone needs to check (since I don't know how to do the command) if you'd know that Reck's role had bit dust and then come back. Remember, if you don't know he's died, you're in a shitton of trouble if he comes back.

I'd like to know where you got me as scum. And I'm still not understanding how Zang is scummy at all. Hell, his refusal to submit to Obv with his vote threat looks pretty town to me.

Also,

!mafia help Reincarnator
!vote Scooby

I'll look over Aj tonight (or try to), but could someone reiterate in a couple points/ lines on why he's scum? I've seen snippets as I skimmed over the last four pages, but a more centered case would be helpful. As for any other wagons, I already said I wouldn't vote TML so until I see that concise Aj case(or look at him) my vore's gonna stay here.

[Kthxbye]

no, it's not changing. You're still today's lynch. p759 just isn't the brainless crap you've been posting the last few pages and gives me pause...not too much pause though as I still think you're scum and need to die.

[Voidedmafia]

Oh, and if you can't tell, I think Zang is town, so I'm not voting him either.

[Kublai Khan]

<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || VOTE COUNT (7 to lynch) |||

<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || Kthxbye - 2 (The_Mini-Librarian Katsuki) |||
<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || The_Mini-Librarian - 1 (wind-up) |||
<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || scooby - 3 (serrapaladin Shmugen Voidedmafia) |||
<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || Katsuki - 1 (shos) |||
<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || Aj_The_Epic - 4 (Kthxbye scooby Zang Leafsnail) |||
<XylBot> ||| MAFIABOT || Zang - 2 (Aj_The_Epic MrObvious) |||

!mafia help Reincarnator

||| MAFIABOT || Reincarnator (town; rare; 3+ players): If you die, you will return to life and get a new role and possibly a new team.

Deadline: (expired on 2013-02-21 01:56:51)

Deadline moved back a few hours to accommodate my work schedule.

wind-up being prodded.

[wind-up]

Whoa, nelly.

Reading.

[wind-up]

VOTE: Aj_The_Epic

Seems like the best shot, I've been wavering on my The_Mini-Librarian read but Aj's reasons for voting Zang are very shallow. One of them's likely scum.

[wind-up]

Here when you say "besides, defending yourself is not scumhunting" you seem to be saying to Katsuki that he shouldn't be defending himself; he should be scumhunting instead. So it's scummy that you later say "I believe that it is completely unreasonable to attack somebody and not give them the chance to defend themselves."

That's not at all what I meant. Katsuki said that people think she is scum for scumhunting, when I ask her why, she says that she gets called scum for defending. Here, I was trying to point out that her explanation did not answer my original question.

What original question?

[wind-up]

I haven't gone into depth on too many other players yet because I like to think that on the off chance I'm getting things right I might as well not say much in an effort to stick around. ^__^

That said, I'm not particularly averse to any of the other current wagons except Kthxbye's. And scooby's, I guess, but to a much lesser degree.

[Voidedmafia]

Thougu, i suppose that command doesn't actually say if we'll know when Reck/Serra would come back, but I think its safe to assume that would be true.