WhatIn post 1724, Bulbazak wrote:Still waiting on those explanations...In post 1712, DrippingGoofball wrote: Bulbazak, Titan and Syryana - all three are scum. I'm 100% on Bulbazak, 90% on Titan and 80% on Syryana.
Cool post. That's a whole lot of words.In post 1716, Jennifer wrote:Given the flip, DGB is likely town.
I'm not sure what to make of the fact that both Day 1 rival lynches were on scum. It does make me less suspicious of MM though because I can't see why MMscum would give me a hard time about not voting KBW but being okay with voting TUA, when she'd town cred regardless.
The plurality lynches are also making it hard for me, as I don't feel that regular PoE can be applied because there's not the same need to compromise on a lynch choice, so scum can more easily avoid a wagon by just saying "I just felt X was scummier." I feel like we'd be better off from a reads perspective if we forced ourselves to agree on a lynch rather than doing this plurality stuff.
Although I think regular PoE may be a little off, I do think it's probably safe to say that at least one scum was on either KBW's or TUA's train because they would want to get town cred. (Not counting KBW as that wouldn't read for town cred but for self-preservation)
Underachivers - BBMolla (Robocopter), Klick, Human Destroyer, keybladewielder,
keybladewielder - Titan, syryana (TheLurker), RBD (otterhorse), Zdenek (BT), DCLXVI (RachMarie), Bulbazak
On the second lynch, the two largest trains ended up being DGB and TUA.
DrippingGoofball - Titan, DCLXVI (RachMarie), Underachivers, Jennifer, Bulbazak
Underachivers - DrippingGoofball, Human Destroyer, zdenek, BBmolla, Syryana, Metal Overlord
Unless DGB ends up being scum with TUA, I'd expect at least one scum to be on DGB. And probably still at least one scum on TUA for towncred.
I'm not willing to vote Bulb, because he's literally the most town person in this game to me. He's the only one that seemed to get that there was no legitimate case on me before and actually call people out on that.
Of the rest, I want to look more at Titan and Zdenek (Klick is still suspicious to me too, but you all know by now how I feel about voting people who are gone). And I still think that MO is probscum.
I looked at TUA's ISO, and I think RBD is probtown because of this post where TUA was trying to get the KBW wagon aborted:Admittedly, MO might be probtown then too because ofbut MO still rubs me in a not-town way and it's possible (though WIFOM alert I guess) that he would defend one scum while bussing another, which means one of MO or OH would be scum too.In post 709, TheUnderachivers wrote:This only strengthens it. KBW is town. MO is not. OH is not, either.
Here TUA says:which makes me think that at least one of MO, DGB, or Lurker must be scum (because I'm not and I think TUA would likely try to name one of his buddies to get town cred in case he survived the lynch). As mentioned, DGB seems more probtown to me today which leaves MO or Lurker (syrana)In post 718, TheUnderachivers wrote:And, yeah. Right now, looks like a MO-DGB-Lurker-Jennifer scumteam.
Summary: Titan, Zdenek, MO, Syrana possibly Klick are the pool I think we'll find the remaining scum from.
Yeah, but the chances of him being scum are astronomically low.In post 1725, DrippingGoofball wrote:WhatIn post 1724, Bulbazak wrote:Still waiting on those explanations...In post 1712, DrippingGoofball wrote: Bulbazak, Titan and Syryana - all three are scum. I'm 100% on Bulbazak, 90% on Titan and 80% on Syryana.
I have to convince you that you're scum? You should know.
100% is low? K.In post 1727, Antilles wrote:Yeah, but the chances of him being scum are astronomically low.
I already made a case a against you, you should self-vote.In post 1729, Bulbazak wrote:DGB, a scumread has zero merit if you can't explain it.
Makes DCL reasonably likely to be town.In post 339, TheUnderachivers wrote:keys ISO is mainly fluff posting and active lurking. Why are you so defensive here?In post 333, RachMarie wrote:UA WTF??? What is your reasoning
plea from TUA makes me think that she's town.In post 577, TheUnderachivers wrote:This is why there are some people on this site that don't think you're very good. Your being OMGUSy (on me) and it really blows. Mastin was right that your voting this hydra is selective but it was RVS so I don't think it was any kind of tell. I know you get offended when people wrongly accuse you but you should stop grudging on Mastin for putting a crap vote on you and kill MOscum today.
Is truly terrible, so bad that I don't think he'd say it about a buddy who might have been flipped.In post 1478, Antilles wrote:TheUnderachivers don't really feel like scum to me.
Their point about not wanting to be mislynched early as they were in the other Large Normal they have played, is extremely fair.
Well this is definitely a townie post, given the TUA scumflip.In post 1124, Rainbowdash wrote:D1 camp on TUA while attacking (yet never voting) DGB paired with early passive defense to later ignoring KBW.
This is less town.In post 1375, Rainbowdash wrote:Im still siding with TUA as null to leaning town. KBW is a really really bad player. Like to the point where I am half convinced he is somepony who is competent just trolling. I literally finshed a game where as town after responding to a player about who the NK was KNOWING who it was forgot who got killed within a page or two. I dont think he is the type of player who would actually bus when he has other options (MO). Thats why I actually think MO is somewhat decent for a scumpick still.
There are several posts where RD tunnels on Antilles, and makes pre-flip dominos falls.In post 1571, Rainbowdash wrote:Antilles being scum means that TUA is town. TUA is more likely scum than DGB just comparing the two though (although both are town probably). Antilles-scum also means DGB is probably town. Which is basically what my reads on those two already are.
If you quote the whole thing it's better, since he's encouraging Klick to vote you, over, say, TUA.In post 1124, Rainbowdash wrote:D1 camp on TUA while attacking (yet never voting) DGB paired with early passive defense to later ignoring KBW.In post 1113, Klick wrote:Can I ask how I placed a spot on the death list, aside from not really doing much?
Then how the D1 attacking of DGB really hasnt rolled over to today bugs me too.
No, he's not bussing there. It's just a garbage argument to sway people to lynch someone else, by promising information.In post 1736, DrippingGoofball wrote:There are several posts where RD tunnels on Antilles, and makes pre-flip dominos falls.In post 1571, Rainbowdash wrote:Antilles being scum means that TUA is town. TUA is more likely scum than DGB just comparing the two though (although both are town probably). Antilles-scum also means DGB is probably town. Which is basically what my reads on those two already are.
Suppose that RD is scum. She is pushing for an Antilles lynch quite strongly. If Antilles flips scum... then TUA is town, and I'm town. That would mean that RD is Antille's buddy, and bus'ing Antilles to save TUA?
The mental gymnastics are too exhausting to be scum.
You should have also quoted all of this one, since he also tries to set up Antilles to look scummy after TUA flips.In post 1571, Rainbowdash wrote:BLEH!
I need to think on this.
Antilles being scum means that TUA is town. TUA is more likely scum than DGB just comparing the two though (although both are town probably). Antilles-scum also means DGB is probably town. Which is basically what my reads on those two already are.
Im going to spend the hour or so thinking about this, but if we can quicklynch ANtilles that would be awesome.
Seriously look at his "oh TUA is town guys" post with a few hours to deadline that does absolutely nothing to actually stop TUA from getting lynched. He isnt voting DGB (or even talking about her), just still complaining that nopony is following his non-existant case.
Seriously, we get like two votes from each wagon on Antilles and we can actually lynch scum, right now we are basically guarenteed to hit town.
Then maybe you should refresh my memory and quote it, because all I remember is unfounded accusations and you refusing to explain them when asked.In post 1730, DrippingGoofball wrote:I already made a case a against you, you should self-vote.In post 1729, Bulbazak wrote:DGB, a scumread has zero merit if you can't explain it.
Maybe I'm misunderstanding the post then. What I am getting is thatIn post 1737, Zdenek wrote:If you quote the whole thing it's better, since he's encouraging Klick to vote you, over, say, TUA.In post 1124, Rainbowdash wrote:D1 camp on TUA while attacking (yet never voting) DGB paired with early passive defense to later ignoring KBW.In post 1113, Klick wrote:Can I ask how I placed a spot on the death list, aside from not really doing much?
Then how the D1 attacking of DGB really hasnt rolled over to today bugs me too.
Syry, I want you to respond to this.In post 1720, DCLXVI wrote:Why? were you expecting something other than a calm response?In post 1719, Syryana wrote:That is a remarkably calm response.
I don't like your second sentence because it's a rhetorical question with no purpose. The whole post is filler, but if you'd left it at "what the hell Marangal" I'd probably have overlooked it. However, since you clearly felt the need to embellish I took a closer look.
The second line wasn't filler. It was expanding my point to reference the fact that we apparently have more than one suicidal towny in our midst. Which is unusual. Hardly embillishment,
Scum, you are wasting my time.In post 1740, Bulbazak wrote:Then maybe you should refresh my memory and quote it, because all I remember is unfounded accusations and you refusing to explain them when asked.In post 1730, DrippingGoofball wrote:I already made a case a against you, you should self-vote.In post 1729, Bulbazak wrote:DGB, a scumread has zero merit if you can't explain it.
That I can see.In post 1738, Zdenek wrote:No, he's not bussing there. It's just a garbage argument to sway people to lynch someone else, by promising information.
Just as I thought...In post 1744, DrippingGoofball wrote:Scum, you are wasting my time.In post 1740, Bulbazak wrote:Then maybe you should refresh my memory and quote it, because all I remember is unfounded accusations and you refusing to explain them when asked.In post 1730, DrippingGoofball wrote:I already made a case a against you, you should self-vote.In post 1729, Bulbazak wrote:DGB, a scumread has zero merit if you can't explain it.
Why?In post 1746, Bulbazak wrote:I believe Mastin when he says he doesn't bus.
THEY VOTED KBW.In post 1746, Bulbazak wrote:I noted a complete lack of bussing on TUA's part.