HunterxHunterxMafia: Yorknew City: Endgame

[Metal Sonic]

He seems like a new player because of forgivable flawed logic and weak reads that can be attributed to a new player who just joined mafia. Since he is not a new player, as testified by you guys, then there should not be cases like this happening.

He is not a new player. Can you explain in a bit more detail why you feel gamma is town if he is a new player?

Additionally, what part of gamma's play did you think was bad in order for you to attribute "town-aligned-badplayer" to him?

[Metal Sonic]

My last minute reads, I could care less about his.
And yeah, it was bad regardless of the flip >.>

i got really lazy until i had my coffee, sry

[Amethyst Kitty]

If looks could kill...

Explain town Rem. I want him dead.

[Amethyst Kitty]

~Mara

[Vi]

Not really a point to end the thread that early in the day. A short day 1.

[vs.]

Curious as to the flip of Gamma.

This sounds like a contradiction.

TBH, at the very least the game went somewhere, which it wasn't before.

[Remilia Scarlet]

Explain town Rem.

Fluffy, constant "I'm town", the posts that sometimes are hard to comprehend.

[AngstyMatters]

wish you didn't so feel so bitter about being burned by lurkerhunting in a previous game.
This kind of logic makes it tough to pressure lurking scum, let alone lynching lurking scum.

It's called a vigilante

No one will give a fuck if a lurker gets shot unless it is a lurker that has an obvious meta and proven themselves to be town already

that's a silly notion
no way to guarantee a vig is in the setup
or that a vig will shoot correctly
and if a lurker has a powerful role you end up giving them a free night to use it

but this is more theorytalk and metal sonic hammered gamma so whatevs

[AngstyMatters]

Explain town Rem. I want him dead.

have already explained why Remembrance is town, seems you disagree with or didn't place any value in my assessment?

[thenewearth]

Oh yeah. That thing, I always do as town. Right.

Plus that self-meta WIFOM.

I don't remember you being bothered by Rem's "I'm town" stuff in the cult game we played in (where you were town). Why getting bothered now?

-G

I'm pretty sure he didn't say the "I do this as town" part in the cult game, IIRC

[thenewearth]

Nacho's point system is really flawed, tbh.

No offense.

But my town read on you is pretty much dwindling because of how I see a flawed system which can and will hurt town.

[Oversoul]

I still RS is probably scum

[Oversoul]

Think*

I've played in a game, still going on, with Metal. I'll have to check if his play is similar but my gut lies with RS

[Dry-fit]

Nacho's point system is really flawed, tbh.

No offense.

But my town read on you is pretty much dwindling because of how I see a flawed system which can and will hurt town.

I don't know why people are saying Nacho is town or scum because of his system. I imagine it's something he was planning to do coming into the game regardless of alignment.

[hitogoroshi]

VC 25 (Day 1, VC 25)

(12)

Gammagooey:

Vi, Nachomamma8, Sajin, ², Nibelung, Oversoul, CarbonFiber, thenewearth, implosion, hp [leaves], Amethyst Kitty, Metal Sonic [Lynch!]

(5)

thenewearth:

Dry-Fit, Remembrance, Kalimar, Gammagooey, Remilia Scarlet
(2)

Metal Sonic:

AngstyMatters, ToastyToast
(2)

Sajin:

CF Riot, Magua
(1)

Remilia Scarlet:

Maxous
(1)

Nachomamma8:

Syryana
(0)

Remembrance:

(Amethyst Kitty)

(0)

Nibelung:

(Metal Sonic)

(0)

Not Voting:

No one

With 23 votes in play, it takes 12 to lynch. Deadline is Saturday, May 25th at 11 PM CST.

End of Day 1

(expired on 2013-05-25 23:00:00)

A lynch has been achieved!

[hitogoroshi]

It's strange how desperate times can have human beings killing other human beings.

Which is not to say everyone assemebled was a stranger to killing. But usually the roles are more well-defined. Someone is shooting at you; you need to fire back. Not this...democratic murder. This is new.

The first target is chosen. Executed without mercy. He fought back - overwhelmed easily by the others, but he fought back. That was the first clue he was the right man. The torture tools concealed in his pockets were a much bigger indicator.

Gammagooey - Feitan,

Phantom Troupe

aligned Interrogator - Lynched Day One!

An Interrogator rolecops and jailkeeps their target.

Night ends at 12pm CST, Saturday May 18th.

Night One Ends

(expired on 2013-05-18 12:00:00)

[hitogoroshi]

Two dead bodies.

The first, a strange man, crawling with some sort of parasite. The second, an apparent member of the Kurta clan, his eyes frozen into that scarlet hue that's considered one of the seven loveliest colors in the world.

Well - you couldn't have supposed it would be only Troupe members dying. Still, it hammers home the importance of your enterprise. If this is what happens when you get it

right

...

Kills are presented in random order.

² - Leech,

Hunter Association

aligned Vanilla Townie - Killed Night One!

Oversoul - Kurapika,

Hunter Association

aligned Clan Avenger - Killed Night One!

A Clan Avenger roleblocks Troupe members and makes all protections on them fail. A Clan Avenger dies without blocking if they target a Hunter Association aligned player.

The Second Day has begun.

With 20 votes in play, it takes 11 to lynch. Deadline is Saturday, June 1st at 2 PM CST.

Day Two Deadline

(expired on 2013-06-01 14:00:00)

[Dry-fit]

For now I'm willing to say RS is town. RS was Oversoul's main suspect and it stands to reason that's who he would have targeted.

The main possible bussers on the Gamma wagon I think are Nibelung or Metal Sonic. thenewearth is also possible.

I had bad gut feelings about Maxous all day yesterday. The way he ignored the gamma wagon altogether is suspicious.

Vote: Maxous.

[Vi]

Next.

Vote: AngstyMatters

(L-10)

[Remembrance]

What happens if he's screaming in the dead chat right now though? And is like NO I investigated ____ you STUPID !&#*s?
I hate this btw, I wasted quite some time meta researching him. Was going to make up bullshit to pressure him today and then see if he got upset. Now I wasted my time.

I think Syrana is also a good candidate.

@TNE:
post 289
post 183

I said it twice in that cult game.

People I suspect right now:
Syrana
TNE

Pedit: VOTE: Angstymatters

[Sajin]

I dislike AngtsyMatters voting record and just general post content. I feel like he was trying to actively take away from the gamma wagon too.

Vote AngstyMatters

[Magua]

Happy to

sheep Vi

give my strong and well-reasoned opinion.

VOTE: AngstyMatters

[Magua]

Also total agreement with Dry-fit that Oversoul investigated Remilia.

[AngstyMatters]

Happy to

sheep Vi

hopefully i won't get lynched over the logic of "experienced player nails scum so all their reads are accurate", at least apply some critical thinking about the likelihood of my posts coming from town or scum. Likewise, hoping my arguments aren't devalued because i was wrong about gamma.

I dislike AngtsyMatters voting record and just general post content. I feel like he was trying to actively take away from the gamma wagon too.

cause calling attention to myself by defending gamma when he was a popular lynch is something scum like to do?

Spoiler: pretty bad sequence of events imo

My opinion on gammagooey is that he seems like a noob vanilla town to me. I have doubts that he is scum and believe that he is most probably a town-aligned-badplayer.

VOTE: GammagooeyHis iso looks to be that of a new player/villager. Since this is not the case, I will therefore doubt his alignment

metal sonic, gammagooey isn't a noob.

Can someone else confirm this?

If so, I will declare intent to hammer

how is that a quicklynch? I declared intent 1 page ago



He seems like a new player because of forgivable flawed logic and weak reads that can be attributed to a new player who just joined mafia. Since he is not a new player, as testified by you guys, then there should not be cases like this happening.


So i expect a Villager or a scum flip. That is all.

If its a pr flip i will be surprised

-5, #832 (Metal Sonic)

Don't judge till you see the flip !

yes that was a scummy post, but flips are always very fun and exciting, and I hope you agree

especially since this happened at the very end and sonic had not interactions or mentioned gamma earlier. Mainly how he doubts gamma is scum to "Don't judge til you see the flip" like he is certain gamma is scum.

vote: Metal Sonic

[implosion]

Hooray for thematically interesting power roles~

VOTE: AngstyMatters

I've gotten bad vibes for a while, and the one thing that holds me back from voting (the townslip comment) really isn't that big of a deal. I can make that more concrete if necessary but Vi is also voting angstymatters so, in the words of the wise, "¯\_(ツ)_/¯"

[AngstyMatters]

sigh