HunterxHunterxMafia: Yorknew City: Endgame

[implosion]

sigh

:\.

[Magua]

hopefully i won't get lynched over the logic of "experienced player nails scum so all their reads are accurate", at least apply some critical thinking about the likelihood of my posts coming from town or scum. Likewise, hoping my arguments aren't devalued because i was wrong about gamma.

I'm lynching you because MattP's been close to non-existent in posting in your hydra, whereas he's been plenty active elsewhere on site, and disinterested MattP is the same thing I saw in Gay Mafia II.

[AngstyMatters]

actually matt's comp broke, i believe he has posted that elsewhere onsite
(and he was active at the start of the game)

[Magua]

He managed 67 posts in Fortnight Mafia over the last five days.

[AngstyMatters]

think about it. He has limited access and is obligate to keep up in multiple games where he only one in the slot, whereas in this game he is hydraing and I can take over. And that is what I told him when he said his comp broke, that he didn't need to worry about keeping up in this game if he needed to focus on other stuff.

[thenewearth]

What happens if he's screaming in the dead chat right now though? And is like NO I investigated ____ you STUPID !&#*s?
I hate this btw, I wasted quite some time meta researching him. Was going to make up bullshit to pressure him today and then see if he got upset. Now I wasted my time.

I think Syrana is also a good candidate.

@TNE:
post 289
post 183

I said it twice in that cult game.

People I suspect right now:
Syrana
TNE

Pedit: VOTE: Angstymatters

Suspect syryana and me --> Votes angsty

What the what?

[Magua]

think about it. He has limited access and is obligate to keep up in multiple games where he only one in the slot, whereas in this game he is hydraing and I can take over. And that is what I told him when he said his comp broke, that he didn't need to worry about keeping up in this game if he needed to focus on other stuff.

Spoiler: Response

[Amethyst Kitty]

...

VOTE: Remembrance

can we go after this one please?

and nacho, tell me why this scumfuck is town.

[AngstyMatters]

blehh this day is going be frustrating

newearth, having trouble reading you, can i get your strongest town and scum reads?

[thenewearth]

Crap I keep forgetting to place a vote...

VOTE: Remembrance

2 of my scumreads died. (Gamma and Oversoul)
My strongest scum read would be remembrance. And Nibelung

Town reads are Nacho, Vi,

[thenewearth]

And V/LA 2 days (again)

[Nibelung]

Three flips to analyse. I took my time during the night phase to reread Gamma posts, and I will take some time tomorrow to reread the whole topic knowing that Over/squared are 100% town. Thus far, my mind are on the following:

I still RS is probably scum

I think Oversoul left this message

after

we reached the lynch threshold exactly for the case he dies, we know who he was going to target. In this case, I think Remilia is another confirmed town too.

I also believe Vi is probably town for being the first one to place a vote on Gamma and keep the pressure until the end.

And until I reread the topic, thus far my scumreads are the same as I ended the last day: Metal Sonic (jumped on top for relucting first, but hammering anyway), TNE, Maxous, Magua, and Toasty. In order.

I'm lynching you because MattP's been close to non-existent in posting in your hydra, whereas he's been plenty active elsewhere on site, and disinterested MattP is the same thing I saw in Gay Mafia II.

And now I have to read this mafia as well.

[Remembrance]

Can you stop using me as an excuse not to do anything Kitten? You're making everyone else do the leg work for you.

While you're asking stuff of TNE, can you I ask you stuff? Like what you think about the RS stuff, and who your other suspects are? MS is kind of weird, but he also says stuff that I'm only used to town saying (such as his frequent "laziness" coupled with his constant mentioning of isoing players. Plus his annoyance with Syrana, accusing him of being scum again.

I find quite a few players sound more certain than they really are. For example, you thought it was scummy and that MS "knew" what he would flip, but what about Nacho? He said he was sure Gamma was scum but he couldn't know that unless he was scum, could he? But we also know that Nacho postures and that we're never as sure as we sound, but that surety tends to spur us on to action, which is a good thing for town.

Still, his "Gamma is a dumb newbie" portrayal is awful, I agree.

[Remembrance]

^ I read slipped that I'm reading Nacho as town. Though for somewhat different reasons. Mostly his read progressions, not his system per se, but rather what he says and does outside of the system and how he reacts to other player's actions.

TNE is gone, so I can't ask him why he went from:

Nacho's point system is really flawed, tbh.

No offense.

But my town read on you is pretty much dwindling because of how I see a flawed system which can and will hurt town.

to:

Crap I keep forgetting to place a vote...

VOTE: Remembrance

2 of my scumreads died. (Gamma and Oversoul)
My strongest scum read would be remembrance. And Nibelung

Town reads are

Nacho

, Vi,

Other than probably the results of the flip.

[thenewearth]

I'm still here for a bit.

IIRC I already said that nacho's system is flawed. But I still had a town read on him

[Remembrance]

Are you going to explain how the system hurts town anymore than giving your reads does? Or how that makes him scummy?

[Kalimar]

I really don't see how RS is confirmed town at all. We don't know Oversoul definitely targeted RS (I admit it is highly likely), and isn't it the case that only one of the four scum members needs to submit kill actions?

@ToastyToast - In #362 Gamma states that he finds you to be town as you act similarly to the 'squillion' of games you two have played together. Could you please elaborate on your meta-experience with Gamma and how many games you two have played together?

@Rem: Why do you suspect Syryana?

[Remembrance]

His reads mostly and the way he decided to set up shop. He is back from V/LA but he left as a null-scum for me and that has been reaffirmed with the flip.

If you meta people Kalimar, you might want to meta him. If that's your bag. It will give you an idea of what to expect from him.

[Amethyst Kitty]

haha~~

no, I was waffley on Gamma and decided to take a leap of faith on Vi who turned out to be right. I'm getting a strong town-vibe from Nacho in this game but I really, really hate that he's town reading you.

How am I using you as an excuse to not do anything? It wasn't until late into yesterday that we started to focus in on you and we have done other things that didn't have anything to do with you at all

I'm also not asking TNE anything...

MS's hammer was strange, though doing it for town-cred seems unlikely IMO

I'm not really seeing what Vi see's in the Angsty Hydra. they are null to me

~Mara

[Amethyst Kitty]

Kalimar might be scum

~Mara

[Kalimar]

His reads mostly and the way he decided to set up shop. He is back from V/LA but he left as a null-scum for me and that has been reaffirmed with the flip.

If you meta people Kalimar, you might want to meta him. If that's your bag. It will give you an idea of what to expect from him.

Only found two games in which they've played together based on their wiki links. Trying to find out if there are any more because two games doesn't seem like a 'squillion' to me. Trying to work something out.

[Remembrance]

haha~~

no, I was waffley on Gamma and decided to take a leap of faith on Vi who turned out to be right.

I'm getting a strong town-vibe from Nacho in this game but I really, really hate that he's town reading you.

How am I using you as an excuse to not do anything? It wasn't until late into yesterday that we started to focus in on you and we have done other things that didn't have anything to do with you at all

~Mara

I wasn't asking you Kitten, I was asking Angst, but I'm glad you answered.

[thenewearth]

Are you going to explain how the system hurts town anymore than giving your reads does? Or how that makes him scummy?

Uh... I don't think I follow you.

I said he's pretty much town. So... How does it make him scummy?

P-edit: nvm

[Remembrance]

@895: ? Can you reword that?

[Kalimar]

@895: ? Can you reword that?

It'll be easier if TT just replies, I think. You'll see where I'm going with this soon enough.