Mini 1490 - Chef Mafia (Game Over!)

[Pyrotechnics]

Do you believe there is a scum among the post restrictions?

Why are you trying to continue this line of questioning?

Or more importantly, what do you think this line of questioning will tell you about thenewearth's alignment?

(That whispering in the wind says noooooooooooottttttttttttttthing this is fake content. woo wooo woo)

[Pyrotechnics]

Quickhammers are pretty frowned upon here. Quickhammer img on purpose will usually get you lynched the next day.

yes because this totally happened when scum!Reck quick hammered twice in Red wedding. Oh no silly me he won in lylo.

[Pyrotechnics]

I disagree. Very rarely do I see purposeful quickhammers.

You can start doing some actual scumhunting any time now.

[Pyrotechnics]

why more people need to vote d3x

I've got a comfortable town read on D3X and I don't think a hail mary meta-read from an L-1 slot is enough to convince me to switch votes, but I will back you off from L-1 just so we can continue the discussion. I do so ONLY because we have so much time left before we need to make a decision. Still completely good with hanging you today.

UNVOTE:

*twitch*

[Pyrotechnics]

If kthx flips scum, rank for buddy?

A macho VT PR claim I do not buy at all, and d3x is totally right that kthx's language assumes d3x town, which is in contrast to his reads.

Lynch this, please.

you can stop sucking up to d3x anytime now.

[Pyrotechnics]

Toon

Jake
Amrun
Poro
Tabby
Maestro
-----
Slovak
Kyubey
Rank
-----
PT
PB
-----
tne
Kthx

Scoom

these reads are not close to ours, that makes me feel sad.

But perhaps you could explain your town read on: Amrun, Porochaz, and your leaning town on Kyubey. That would be awesome.

I think the only town reads we agree with you on are Jake, Tabby and Slovak. This is disappointing.

[Pyrotechnics]

Man, d3x is so town. That's the exact reason I originally voted kthx.

He put down an RVS vote on d3x, then said PeaceBringer was scummy and didn't vote PeaceBringer, and this went on forever. It made no sense.

This is the post that reeks fake as molasses.

[Pyrotechnics]

Lynch me today guys, go ahead. I already lost my vote and it will prove my alignment and then y'all can finally listen to me about d3x.

this feels fake.

[Pyrotechnics]

Okay hear ye...hear ye...members of the town block as discussed this evening are the ffery hydra and the mara hydra which syry vouches for as town with no doubt.

So, TT and SP here's what we think:

d3x is town. you guys are town (duh town block). jake is town. (I have town read on peacebringer don't know about spry)

we think that scum is in (kthnxbye, amrum, porochaz, kybuby (I have a scum read on thenewearth, he says hellifiknow.

don't know about maestro or rank but meh.

what have you guys got for us.

d3x - i hear you on kthnx and i will look into more of his games. I'm kind of unnerverd that he hasn't responded to that meta read of mine. I would expect someone who was town to respond to that, so i'm all eh. But I'll look into things later...or ffery will cuz she's a better meta diver than I am.

[Jake from State Farm]

willing to consider that Jake... any thoughts on new earth?

tbh I haven't even noticed him, will need to read his posts first. Will do that later

No one wanted to see the naked banana. I guess it just lacked appeal!

[PeaceBringer]

Yeah,

playing without explaining reasoning does not sit well with me. Im one of these annoying players who needs reasoning.

If you don't give it then what we are basically doing is playing a guessing game. Which I guess is what we are doing but I believe that we should be able to logically work out who is scum, by actually posting properly, making posts that are just "X is probably Y" removes that element and it becomes a crapshoot. This, unless they are terrible or unlucky, benefits scum.

It depends on how far this "town block" goes. It worries me that its still being mentioned after RVS.

And yet you didn't make any noise about Jake's reason-free vote?

missed that, essentially me and prozac are not likely to get along then.

[Kthxbye]

I can agree with scum being in amrum and porochaz from p408 and think y'all (seeing as I lost my vote) should lynch one of them today. I'm still not convinced of d3x though but that can wait I suppose.

[Alton Brown]

Elyse replaces Maestro.

[Elyse]

Hi everyone! I'll read up today and hopefully get my thoughts down. I am finishing up season six of LOST though and I don't know how far I'll get.

[Alton Brown]

Votecount 1.7

Kthxbye (4) - d3x, Amrun, Elyse, Porochaz
PeaceBringer (2) - Rank, thenewearth
thenewearth (2) - Pyrotechnics, PeaceBringer
Elyse (2) - Jake from State Farm, The Slovak Prince
The Slovak Prince (1) - Kyubey
d3x (0) -
Kyubey (0) -
Jake from State Farm (0) -
Rank (0) -
Amrun (0) -
Porochaz (0) -
trebuchet tabby
Pyrotechnics

Not Voting (2): trebuchet tabby,

Kthxbye

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-08-31 19:03:38).

kthxbye is no longer able to vote for this day phase.

Searching for a replacement for Maestro.

[Jake from State Farm]

confirm vote: elyse

This is some pretty good tapioca. That's one way of pudding it.

[Porochaz]

Yeah,

playing without explaining reasoning does not sit well with me. Im one of these annoying players who needs reasoning.

If you don't give it then what we are basically doing is playing a guessing game. Which I guess is what we are doing but I believe that we should be able to logically work out who is scum, by actually posting properly, making posts that are just "X is probably Y" removes that element and it becomes a crapshoot. This, unless they are terrible or unlucky, benefits scum.

It depends on how far this "town block" goes. It worries me that its still being mentioned after RVS.

And yet you didn't make any noise about Jake's reason-free vote?

Where is his reason free vote?

[Porochaz]

That is a ridiculous no of posts in a row, some of which say essentially nothing. Please stop it.

[PeaceBringer]

That is a ridiculous no of posts in a row, some of which say essentially nothing. Please stop it.

you will hate me for sure...

[Jake from State Farm]

Oh peace, you asked me about new earth? I have him as mildly scummy. He made comments about me and when I asked him to clarify what he meant, he instead called me town and moved on. I don't see why he would ignore it, especially when it was what he was using to call me scummy. I'm ok with votes on him but this chk/maestro slot is confirmed scum at this point.

Old skiers never die, they just go downhill

[PeaceBringer]

Oh peace, you asked me about new earth? I have him as mildly scummy. He made comments about me and when I asked him to clarify what he meant, he instead called me town and moved on. I don't see why he would ignore it, especially when it was what he was using to call me scummy. I'm ok with votes on him but this chk/maestro slot is confirmed scum at this point.

Old skiers never die, they just go downhill

fair enough, NE can be dealt with another point...

vote chkflp/maestro/elyse

[Elyse]

Oh hell. Four hydras?

I like kthnxbye's early RVS pressure on PeaceBringer but I don't think PeaceBringer is scum from it.

If d3x has to post like that all game...

I like trebuchet and Amrun's responses to d3x's posts better than Jake and kthxbye's.

d3x going from a townread to a scumread from one post for kthx is scummy. He only pointed out what you did, which was vote to PL someone you think is 99.9% town.

Pyro's posts have a scumvibe to them. It's mostly gut though. And I don't like when people clog up the thread with four posts in a row.

Kthx's switch onto Jake seems very forced. I don't like it.

and yes we are hated so theres no excuwe to hqmmer us accidentally

and yes, we are Hated.

Is 'Hated' a TV chef or something? I have NO idea whether this is referring to something from TV or something from other games you've played.

I thought this was a weird thing to pick up on.

I like 193 by Poro and I have a townread on him. PB was like "Oh I hate early claims" and then tells kthx to claim.

kthx's switch back to d3x is silly. I don't get his whole "he should know I'm town argument" because if d3x is scum, he does know you are town. As you said before, why wouldn't he call you town and NK you? It's a perfect chance to buddy you.

I really like Jake's 201, especially the bit about Macho being a modifier.

why more people need to vote d3x

I've got a comfortable town read on D3X and I don't think a hail mary meta-read from an L-1 slot is enough to convince me to switch votes, but I will back you off from L-1 just so we can continue the discussion. I do so ONLY because we have so much time left before we need to make a decision. Still completely good with hanging you today.

UNVOTE:

I don't like this. It feels over explained and it gives you an easy way to hop back on the wagon.

@PB
You said that you hat early claims, but then go on to say you like to get at least 2 claims in. Which is it?

@ rank - you don't have to 100% think a person is scum to vote them, there are plenty of other reasons to vote a person

Couldn't agree more. He didn't even voice a suspicion in that post, though. THAT is what I found scummy. The other concerns I had re: PB still stand.

it is what I do... go check my meta

Self-meta doesn't work. Stop using it.

Alright I'm on page 10 now and taking a break.

[PeaceBringer]

else- early claim is a claim before claiming point.
generally it is get a run up and a claim, get another one and sort it out.

[Jake from State Farm]

technically we have 5 hydras, I am hyrdra'ing with myself

Visualize whirled peas!

[Elyse]

If kthx flips scum, rank for buddy?

A macho VT PR claim I do not buy at all, and d3x is totally right that kthx's language assumes d3x town, which is in contrast to his reads.

Lynch this, please.

I can get behind this. Townpoints to Amrun.

259 by tne seems too easy.

Alright what is with everyone posting five times in a row? It makes it harder and more tedious to read. Stop.

so right now am reading kthxbye town and believe his claim...

What did you think his claim was at this point?

btw mara, did you realize your other half already claimed hated. So we have a hated townie, I guess macho could fit but really don't make sense but really sucky scum claim. Sticking with my thoughts there...

vote new earth

, that is a direction I prefer

This is actually a good point.

I'm so confused with all this neighbor talk but I don't want to get into it and get more role claims.

VOTE: thenewearth

This game is really weird and confusing. I'll explain my vote later. Have to go.