Mini 1504 - Antihero Mafia REBOOT [GAME OVER]

[Paschendale]

Did I misread, or did Beli try to call out Reaper as a cop in his initial big post? Is there rolefishing going on there?

[Antihero]

Splintered Cell needs to get back inhere.

Splinter Cell = Video game series
Splintered Shadow = player in this game

[The Grim Reaper]

Hmm, seems I messed that up straight from the beginning. Think I got it right only twice during this game. Thank you for the heads up.

GG

[JKLM]

Lynch me please if it means you will listen to me.

There's a lot of cross accusing going on, so much so that at some point everybody thinks everyone is scum and everyone is town. There is no clear scum here from people's arguments, so the third scum was tricky. Although I can narrow it down:

BUCKWILD: this would be lurk scum as well. Participate more. Just look at his ISO. Nothing good here. Prob scum.

SPLINTERED: I would say you're scum based on the lying cat votes alone but If it wast the fact that you really are LVA I would have def put you in the scum pile due to inactivity. However, it looks believable honestly and in past games I have tried barreling hard at someone with my first vote to see what happens. You're still #2 on my scum list.

VARSOON: I don't want to touch this because of all the emotion. While it seems to clear up, if life has ya down, subbing for your own sake may be good. I've done it before, mafia can be violent a frustrating at times. If it's all an act than it's just blatant ATE and should be voted as scum, but I'm willing to give him time to work that all out.

Mafiassk: well that's scummy. Kind of. The only thing that kept him from the top spots was the fact that he's simply forgot to announce he's VLA till the 13th. Although give he's posted once yesterday and the day before, I could find it believable. But don't keep him out of your mind.

Everyone else is town.

So buckwild is the third scum. Please vote him as well after me. Although I'd start with Belsarius than DARTHE first.

Lynch me because at this point I'm a liability to town. I can't have all this cornered (or blatant) suspiscion on me for this all to wrk.

[The Grim Reaper]

Mafiassk = Belisarius

[The Grim Reaper]

Lynch me please

if it means you will listen to me.

Probably not. Your reads don't seem extremely thought-out, so even if you are town they'll end up being ignored.
Please do better if you really care. You sound like you do, but I'm not convinced yet.

GG

[Splintered Shadow]

Still here. I will get back into this game tonight.

-Stup

[JKLM]

Hey grim you could Atleast read the rest of my post as to why you should lynch me anyway and not make me look like a whiny brat. Thanks.

[The Grim Reaper]

JKLM if you are pulling the slayers gambit then playing anti town now will not work. Your reads need to be better.

how have you decided buck is scum lurking for example?
~G

[The Grim Reaper]

Also regarding the Varsoon read how is blatant AtE scummy? I find it is a null read

[The Grim Reaper]

JKLM

You should play according to your win-condition and you might have a better chance of not appearing as one.

Asking for your own lynch is never good. If you flip town, we'll know you've been sincere, but it doesn't tell us anything about how correct you are. And given the apparent ammount of thought you've given to your reads, most of which revolve around inactivity, their chance of being correct are roughly the same as the results of a sequence of coin flips.

GG

[Belisarius]

Did I misread, or did Beli try to call out Reaper as a cop in his initial big post? Is there rolefishing going on there?

You misread, badly. I was using cops as in the RCMP, FBI, FSB, Interpol, Scotland Yard, etc., not cops as in the Mafia role.

[Belisarius]

This man does not play Mafia.

[JKLM]

Before this, my whole case on me was on inactivity (and an RVS vote)

Inactivity is important this game because everyone is accusing each other so much (as I've said at some point everyone is seriously being considered as serious scum) that all scum have to do is back away and let the town destroy itself.)
It's too easy for scum to lurk so they will do so under current site meta.

If we're not gonna lycnh me, can we PLEASE lynch Bel? While the other scum reads are connected based I know he's scum and he shows it so obviously he needs to die

If there is one person I know in right about it's definitely Bel. Also please, can hydra stop slipping so much? We hae a lot of hydra so when nearly all of you slip, it's confusing to do ISOs. Sorry about that, I know it's hard.

[Majiffy]

So, nobody's going to answer my question about AP's contraction baseline?

Don'tknowdon'tcare

[JKLM]

Bel I know you think my vote has no weight on you so you can just ignor it but when you do so it just shows your scum colors more:
Scum don't have to rebut every point against then if they don't think it will change anything, so they won't. That's how scum behave. That's how you're behaving.

Scum. Scum. I'm telling you this man is blatant scum.

[Belisarius]

Bel I know you think my vote has no weight on you so you can just ignor it but when you do so it just shows your scum colors more

Bring it.

[The Grim Reaper]

If there is one person I know in right about it's definitely Bel.

If you know he is scum why was he absent from your previous read list (I know you had SSK on there but you didn't have SSK so high...)
~G

[JKLM]

That read list was to try and find the third scum, Belsarius was literally the first guy I talked about.

That wasn't a master read list it was simply me trying to figure scum.

Ssk being on my list was mistake from him scum slipping

[Antihero]

It's only after we've lost everything that we're free to do anything.

-Fight Club

Vote Count 1.6

Belisarius - 5 (Buckwild, Darthe, Fear and Loading, JKLM, flying beauties)
Buckwild - 2 (Paschendale, Splintered Shadow)
Grim Reaper, The - 1 (Varsoon)
JKLM - 4 (AngryPidgeon, Majiffy, The Grim Reaper, Belisarius)
Paschendale - 1 (Lying Cat)

Not Voting: No one

7 to lynch; deadline is in (expired on 2013-10-22 18:32:12).

[Fear and Loading]

I still have to look into splintered. I've been lazy on that front.

I think JKLM's gambit is garbage. Considering his join date I'm inclined to think that it's coming from town, since I don't think that he'd risk blowing a scum game with that play.

I thought that Grim still appeared townish, but I really dislike their "maybe Darthe is up to something" comment.

Beli talk to me about contractions. Have you caught scum with that before? It seems to me like a bizarre thing to comment on.

[Fear and Loading]

-Zd.

[Splintered Shadow]

And I'm back. Things are still busy, so don't expect any long posts after this, but I think AP is scum and here's why:

So the first thing that caught my attention was his constant defense of Buckwild. A few comments is understandable but this just seems like an over-the-top defense. Here is what I'm talking about-

Pasch, what do you make of the last Buck post. I actually feel pretty strongly one way about it.

Ya Buckwild is not getting lynched today. The pride hes showing in his recent posts is more often than not from town.

Mollie can we compromise somewhere?

Somewhere that is not Buckwild or Majiffy?

If Buck gets lynched and flips town today you will never hear the end of it from me. Heads up.

--------

How do you feel about AP,

Ok, so Varsoon isn't reading the thread.

Then there's his scummy attempt to derail any legitimate questioning about himself.

Best information lynch: Paschendale.

Best scum lynch: JKLM

Best policy lynch: Varsoon

Not to be lynched today: Beauties, Majiffy, Buck, Darthe, FnL

Ugh. This post. It feels

really

strange that he categorized the lynches this way. It just doesn't seem like a town mindset. Plus, it gives him a post he can reference if he gets a chance to lynch one of these three (Pasch is very town by the way so back off).

Mollie might need to be policy lynched.

omg majiffy you wouldn't post that if you were town this game

this is so opportunistic

Not really. Your calling it opportunistic is much more opportunistic.

Huh, Darthe might actually be a jklm buddy.

Throwing weak suspicion that could serve if he needs to vote Darthe. How about you explain your reasoning here, AP? And I thought he was in your "not to be lynched today" pile?


To summarize, he has made a lot of fluff posts that I feel have only been to make him appear active. The extreme Buck defense, the bad deflection, and other quotes above should be sufficient to prove that AP is the best lynch for today. Who's in?


VOTE: AP

-Stup

[Splintered Shadow]

As for everyone else, here are my current thoughts:

Varsoon- leaning town
Paschendale- town
Fear and Loading (Quilford + Zdenek)- leaning town
Belisarius- unsure
JKLM- leaning scum
flying beauties (pirate mollie + ArcAngel9)- town
Darthe- unsure
Buckwild- Cerbs thinks he's scum. I think he's more null.
Lying Cat (sthar8 + Jingle)- null
The Grim Reaper (Grimgroove + Guyett)- This looks like the town-Grim that I've seen before.
AngryPidgeon- scum
Majiffy- The attitude looks town to me.

So, like I said above, AP is the best lynch. JKLM might be a good option, but I'll have to ISO him first. If you want any of these explained feel free to ask.

-Stup

[Varsoon]

Not sold on Beli being scum.

I'm with Splintered on AP = scum.

I'm also all for a Grim lynch, but no one's supporting that.

Guess I'll have to get in here and do some work soon.