In post 430, Wisdom wrote:Because a miller suggests the existence of a cop. The pro-town thing to do was investigate. One of us would get a result.
'Suggests'
We cannot rule out the possibility of the miller being added because of the
future existence
of a cop - knowing what we know about the setup - or a false positive for balancing purposes. Both of these are very plausible realities.
So, whereas a cop investigation is a very specific investigative report that could very well be spent on a dead player, I decided to use an investigative report that casts a wide net - watching - on a highly likely target - a 99% claimed town probability player.
This player is likely to be the target of doc protection, cop investigations, mafia kills, etc.
A watch is
the
most pro-town and logical move to make.
So you're wrong there, lets move on to where else you're wrong;
In post 430, Wisdom wrote:
Jingle trying to submit a kill shows that there are people who thought "maybe I am scum, let's try killing" and submitted a kill. Which supports my logic.
Jingle trying to submit a kill shows that there are idiots who think "Hey you know I've got a good chance at being town but instead of doing anything that could possibly help me if I AM town, I am going to take an anti-town action, to see if I AM an anti-town role, so that my playstyle can thusly be negatively effected in the thread where players are actively looking for other players that know their alignment to be anti-town. This sounds like the most logical and sound action I could possibly take as either alignment!"
So if your logic is supported by this being a logical move, your argument supports my logic that you suck at this game.
In post 430, Wisdom wrote:
I do know if Jingle is town but I don't think that the lying shooter would claim "I tried to shoot Om". And besides, the way he described his thought process looked genuine enough.
That still requires
more
players to take
actively
anti-wincon - not to mention incredibly stupid - actions.
It's a really poor position to take, given that we
know
there is a player who
read
their role PM and could very plausibly be scum.