Mafia 59: Hell on Earth - Game over!

[Jack]

That seems about right. If he was really sure about him it makes sense.

Vote:Bogre

[Jalyn]

Looking at all of Fircoal's posts, he said twice that he suspected Borge - but he never voted him. I don't think there is any reason to think that Fircoal got a guilty result on him.

[Jack]

He gave reasons for his suspicions of panzer day one. I don't know why he didn't vote bogre but I think his post is a pretty strong indicator of a guilty result.

[Jalyn]

Why would he have not added a vote to moving bandwagon of someone he had a guilty result for?

[Jack]

Why would he say he strongly suspected someone while talking about how he could only drop hints?

[Jalyn]

Because he didn't want to claim and strongly suspected someone without having investigated them? It makes no sense to me that a cop that knows someone is guilty wouldn't vote them.
I'm not saying the Bogre doesn't look guilty as all heck, but I don't think Fircoal had a guilty result on him.

Besides, Battle Mage hammered livingod directly after several posts of "for god's sake everyone hold off so we can talk" and without even coming close to waiting for a claim.

[Nightfall]

I suspect Borge the most. I don't usually vote until I'm really sure once it gets to part of days like this. I kind of hate the vague hints, but I have to do them.

[/quote]

This does it for me,

Vote : Borge

[Fircoal]

BAH!

[Jack]

Because he didn't want to claim and strongly suspected someone without having investigated them? It makes no sense to me that a cop that knows someone is guilty wouldn't vote them.
I'm not saying the Bogre doesn't look guilty as all heck, but I don't think Fircoal had a guilty result on him.

It certainly a possibility though. Bogre was looking like he might be lynched so I don't think fircoal would have felt the need to claim. The way the livingod wagon sprang up is rather suspicious in retrospect (I was on it, and livingod was really suspicious...but the way it started up at that moment is interesting).

Besides, Battle Mage hammered livingod directly after several posts of "for god's sake everyone hold off so we can talk" and without even coming close to waiting for a claim.

Yeah well there's lots of scum.

[spectrumvoid]

vote: Bogre

purely because of Fircoal.

[Yosarian2]

It's possible Firecol had an investigation on Bogre; he did attack Bogre in his first post of the day, although not with any vote. Not sure, but it's possible. And Bogre still looks somewhat scummy for that bad day 1 hammer. Yeah, he's a reasonable wagon.

fos:bogre

I also don't like the way m4yhem was fishing yesterday.

[Kelly Chen]

Vote count

4 - Bogre (theopor_COD, Jack, Nightfall, spectrumvoid)
1 - Battle Mage (Jalyn)

not voting: milkman, Battle Mage, Yosarian2, ~N9V~, Bogre, M4yhem, TheJiveMachine, Akbar

With 13 alive and 13 present it is 7 to lynch!

Deadline: Tue Apr 24

Friday afternoon I'll prod anyone who hasn't posted this game day.

[TheJiveMachine]

I think Fircoal is scum, assumes Bogre is part of the other group, and wants to be looked at as a cop if Bogre comes up scum, without having to claim, in case Bogre is town.

Vote: Fircoal.

[Jack]

Fircoal is dead...

[theopor_COD]

I think Fircoal is scum, assumes Bogre is part of the other group, and wants to be looked at as a cop if Bogre comes up scum, without having to claim, in case Bogre is town.

Vote: Fircoal.

Woah.

We caught another . . Fircoal is dead.

[TheJiveMachine]

That's what I get for kipping pages on rereads. Nevermind then.

[milkman]

Vote:bm

. He's never helpful and his actions are actually detrimental to the town. I consider his hammer yesterday to be the scummiest thing that's happened the whole game.

We need to start catching scum, and bm is at the top of my list right now.

[Jack]

I think Fircoal is scum, assumes Bogre is part of the other group, and wants to be looked at as a cop if Bogre comes up scum, without having to claim, in case Bogre is town.

Vote: Fircoal.

Woah.

We caught another . . Fircoal is dead.

Well, fircoal is dead, but how does this mean we caught another?

[theopor_COD]

Fact that he blatantly hasn't read the last few pages specifically the lynch scene. Your not telling me a remaining townie would fail to see that Fircoal is no longer alive. Plus he's defending Bogre to the hilt and Bogre is scum.

[Bogre]

VOTE: BM

Still who I think is scum.

Jalyn: Why do you suspect a group missed thier NK?

[Battle Mage]

id just like to say on behalf of myself when i first saw what had happened:

OH SH************T!!!!!!
To be honest, what i did was pretty stupid with hindsight. I honestly wouldnt blame the town for lynching me today, as my actions yesterday were pretty costly. Nonetheless, the fact remains that i am not scum. Lynching me today would be a waste.
However, i WILL say, in my defence, that Livingod had ample opportunity to claim, and yet did not do so. I can assure you that if he had claimed, i would not have hammered, as to be honest i wasnt really sure whether he was scum.
Anyway im sorry. But life goes on. I recall my realy suspicions yesterday:
Bogre and Milkman. It doesnt seem like a coincidence that both seem keen to push a hasty BM lynch today, knowing that i will be a popular target.
I will

Vote: Bogre

but if the town chooses to lynch me instead, when i come up town, look VERY closely at Milkmans comments aswell. He has tried to lie low, but his few appearances have not been complimentary.

We only have 1? town power piece left. The scum still have all their members intact. Dont waste a valuable lynch on me.

BM

[~N9V~]

Jesus, thanks alot guys. God, I was going to put my vote on Bogre, but that would put him at -1 to lynch, and that wouldn't be very good. We need a good day today. So as of now, the main people to lynch will be Battle Mage and Bogre.

Right now, I think whoever has the "Newt' role to come out. It would be betgter for him to tell us who he has looked at, becaus ethats three people we can rule out as town right there. Because as soon as he hits a mafia member, he dies.

[Yosarian2]

Right now, I think whoever has the "Newt' role to come out. It would be betgter for him to tell us who he has looked at, becaus ethats three people we can rule out as town right there. Because as soon as he hits a mafia member, he dies.

Only the newt knows if he has enough information to be worth coming out or not at this point. He might not have any useful information; he might not have targeted anyone, or everyone he's targeted might be dead. And if the newt claims, he's dead, with 2 killing groups and no protective roles.

The newt should claim if needed to prevent a mislynch, as we REALLY need to lynch a scum today, but otherwise, meh.

[~N9V~]

I think Battle Mage would be a better lynch today. Bogre would to, but Battle Mage made the second speed hammer, and that is just unnessacery.

Vote: Battle Mage

[Bogre]

I would like it if those voting on me supply another reason more than:

omg fircoal hinted so.

Easy way for scum to slip in a bandwagon, IMO.