Mewbie 1472 ~ Game Ovah~

[Pharphis]

I'm feeling the urge to hammer right about now.

Do you have an opinion on any player other than me?
Town vibes? Scum vibes?

[XLAV]

I will

Unvote

for now.

[XLAV]

Unvote: Pharphis

[Hopkirk]

Since i last posted:
Cheese now looks worse.
Xlav looks towner.
Karlos still looks scummy.

[Guyett]

I'm feeling the urge to hammer right about now.

Any comments on the game instead of just trying to end the day?

[Guyett]

UNVOTE: karlos

VOTE: pharphis

Guys I'm done pressuring karlos, I think karlos is fine for now, my vote goes back to pharph now

What did you learn and why are you moving your vote to pharph again?

[Karlos4]

What is scummy about it?
We have no information and it was specifically to get reads from people.
Whether that was successful or not I don't know yet, but if it helps you believe it was intentional and not a slip I have been playing forum mafia for ~1.5 years now on another forum and hosted my own games (I am right now!)

How should that actually help getting reads from other players??
Stating that your nonsense is nonsense, doesn´t really have much influence on the game.

To see
1) in which ways people would contradict me,
2) who would vote first and who would follow,
3) who was could contradict their own words by either voting for or against me and saying otherwise
..

The list of potential things goes on and on. I had no way to predict how players would react but i'm beginning to think that your actions are most suspect.
stubborn tends to = mafia imo. It's easy to get away with voting and lynching a townie if you're stubborn about it.

And yeah you still haven't really explained what was scummy about my actions.

VOTE: Karlos

AND if my "nonsense" doesn't really have much influence on the game I don't know how it could be a scummy thing to do

Last sentence: I didnt say that I think the action was scummy in that kind of way, my accusation was that you accidentaly sliped. And then tried to excuse yourself with: Its all just a joke.

Pharphis another mistake that you did, was voting on me for no reason whatsoever than: If you vote me I vote you back. -.-
State your reasons.

[cheesetovey]

The reason I am done pressuring Karlos is because Karlos was talking now and he did not post anything particularly scummy, so I put my vote where it was before.
He is talking now anyways, If he talks without my vote there then we are all good

[Pharphis]

@karlos
If I was going to vote people for no other reason than OMGUS (oh my god you suck) I would have done it 2 days ago. If you truly believe someone who has been playing for ~1.5 years made a slip of that magnitude then there isn't really anything I can tell you to convince you otherwise.
My reason for voting for you is in the post you just quoted (stubborn voting)
Tell me about some other reads you've had, so that if we lynch you we can find your scum buddy

@cheese
What happened to being confused? Why is the vote back on me rather than on kenny for example, if you are satisfied with karlos talking and your vote was there to get him talking?

[Pharphis]

Also @cheese

I've asked you several questions you haven't addressed. Go back and read my posts and answer them, please.
You're second on my scum list, and by avoiding questions while answering other players is the easiest way to get to the top!

[Hopkirk]

"Pharphis another mistake that you did, was voting on me for no reason whatsoever than: If you vote me I vote you back.": What do you mean here? You weren't voting for pharp when he voted you.

[Karlos4]

What is scummy about it?
We have no information and it was specifically to get reads from people.
Whether that was successful or not I don't know yet, but if it helps you believe it was intentional and not a slip I have been playing forum mafia for ~1.5 years now on another forum and hosted my own games (I am right now!)

How should that actually help getting reads from other players??
Stating that your nonsense is nonsense, doesn´t really have much influence on the game.

To see
1) in which ways people would contradict me,
2) who would vote first and who would follow,
3) who was could contradict their own words by either voting for or against me and saying otherwise
..

The list of potential things goes on and on. I had no way to predict how players would react but i'm beginning to think that your actions are most suspect.
stubborn tends to = mafia imo. It's easy to get away with voting and lynching a townie if you're stubborn about it.

And yeah you still haven't really explained what was scummy about my actions.

VOTE: Karlos

AND if my "nonsense" doesn't really have much influence on the game I don't know how it could be a scummy thing to do

I voted him in the beginnen. As a response to that be votes me without stating ANY reasons.

[Malakittens]

Finding a replacement for FSnake.

[Pharphis]

karlos you're quoting the post where I provide reasons for voting you. You appear to playing ignorant and stubborn but you can't keep it up forever

[Malakittens]

Alexcellent replaces FSnake.

[Alexcellent]

Hi all! Haven't played mafia in a fair long while. Going to get caught up with the thread and make a post after work. Or possibly whilst at work, I'm not a very good employee.

[Pharphis]

You'll always be an alexcellent employee in my mind

[Guyett]

Hello Axellent, long time no see

[King Kenny]

This game doesn't seem to moving at all. I may look back and see if I can use my scum hunting skills to good affect.

[Pharphis]

This game doesn't seem to moving at all. I may look back and see if I can use my scum hunting skills to good affect.

that would be nice since you haven't done anything

[penguin_alien]

1.03

With Nine Players alive.. It takes five to lynch

Voting:

King Kenny - Guyett [1]
XLAV -
Karlos4 - Hopkirk, Pharphis [2]
cheesetovey -
BipolarChemist -
Pharphis - Karlos4, cheesetovey [2]
Alexcellent -
Hopkirk -
Guyett -

Not Voting:

King Kenny, Alexcellent, BipolarChemist, XLAV [4]

Countdowns

(expired on 2014-02-04 18:31:00)

[King Kenny]

This game doesn't seem to moving at all. I may look back and see if I can use my scum hunting skills to good affect.

that would be nice since you haven't done anything

To be fair there isn't much to go off. I could go around and say who's fluffing and posting garbage but that doesn't always explain their alignment.

[Alexcellent]

Okay, work's over, I opted to be a good employee for a change.

Pharphis reeks of towniness to me. His "town goon" play is out there to get discussion going and reaction test. The only reason I could see scum doing that is to either throw a load of wifom in the game early, or it's the worst scum slip ever. Although I don't really like his "lurker" vote, but subsequent posts come across as town to me.
Getting super town vibe from Hopkirk as well.

Unvote: Pharphis

Why the unvote? What do you think of Pharphis?

Lets pressure karlos then. He seems scummiest.

Why am I getting voted on? I briefly skimmed the posts, due to me having a lack of time.

I voted on Pharphis as his "was just a joke" seemed like a lame excuse and his actions suspicious.

Bipolar chemist also has put himself on my suspicious list, as he backs up Pharphis defense. What a coincidence that you two guys played with eachother before...!? Guys wake up and smell the coffee. BC and Pharphis explain Pharphis weird behaviour by using some material - not accessable to us - to explain it. This seems very scummy, on top of that, you two guys have happened to play with eachother. Something smells foul and is not right about the situation.

My vote will definitely stay with Pharphis. That doesnt meen BC is off the hook though!

I definitively think that bpc and pharphis is a possibility, although I feel I would need more evidence to be fully convinced of the mafia duo

What's making you see a BPC/Pharphis team? Probably best not to get into associative scumhunting at the moment, but is there any particular post that BPC has said that makes you think he's scum?

Also, @Guyett, your RVS vote is still happening. Do you think King Kenny is still the best place for your vote right now?

Speaking of voting for King Kenny though.

VOTE: KingKenny, because post #122 says to me that you are scum.

[Hopkirk]

"Not Voting: King Kenny, BipolarChemist, XLAV [3]"
Generally in mafia you should be voting someone. Not using your vote allows scum to hide easily.
If you aren’t voting please vote a scumread of yours.

Kenny is giving off a scummy feel. He wants a hammer on someone… but still hasn’t said anything about them or voted them now para is off l-1. This suggests he doesn’t actually think para is scum but he just wants to lynch anyone. You could say that him not hammering discounts this theory but idk if anyone would hammer in their first post without saying anything- no way he’d get away with it.

143 and 146 support the view he’s lurking+doesn’t care about scumhunting. Doesn’t think game’s moving, complains it’s not (trying to make himself pro-town for wanting the game to move) despite he’s got the least content and posts of anyone.

@Kenny: Nothing to go on? What about para and that wagon that reacher L-1 very quickly? Do you still think para is scum? If not why did you feel like hammering? If so why aren’t you voting him? Who on the wagon do you think is scum- bussing or leading it.

[XLAV]

I agree with Alex, King Kenny is probably the scummiest right now.

Vote: King Kenny