NY 171: An Education in Telling Jokes (Game Over!)

[Porochaz]

This game makes me want to cry. Part of me wants to vote for whoever decided on this stupid plan.

Seriously how was that ever going to work.

OK cabd counterclaim... Useful. I am not sure double vigs is normal. Not sure why gooner didn't immediately counter. Anyway a vote for zek is incoming. Once I get to read out with a meet

[Ythan]

UNVOTE:

Actually should have read the day though...

I'm having paranoid thoughts about despy putting in double 1-shot vigs. From what I've seen zek's level of shitness doesn't actually correlate to his alignment, so I'm not convinced by yesterday.

serious post

[Ythan]

Mollie's just reading along with the counterclaim and is still

self voting

iirc. I said that's weird and she got defensive.

Was that hard?

that isn't what happened you lying prick I was kidding with you cos I think the question was incredibly dumb

Realize I'm not sitting next to you. Your posting is weird.

[Yates]

I'm having paranoid thoughts about despy putting in double 1-shot vigs. From what I've seen zek's level of shitness doesn't actually correlate to his alignment, so I'm not convinced by yesterday.

What?? Is this really a thing??

Look, at this point Zek is pretty much one of three things:
1. fake claiming scum
2. an SK
3. the worst vig ever - all but guaranteed to target Town EVERY NIGHT ALIVE

Which of those three do you want to keep alive right now? If he flips 1 or 2 we're good. If he flips 3, we lynch fake claiming Cabd and nail scum tomorrow.

Optimal play is obvious:
VOTE: Zek

@Mod - I'll be V/LA until Tuesday. Hopefully knee deep in powder!

[Malakittens]

Hey cabbers your wrong on me. Talk to me so I can reach out to you?

[Zekrom25]

Oi oi back the fuck up.

Cabd is CONFIRMED FUCKING SCUM right here boys and girls.

VOTE: Cabd

I'm the actual fucking one shot scum vig. I shot the Doc last night.

Votes not for me are scumclaims past this line:


------------------------------------------

[pisskop]

:lulz:

We need one for moments like this.

[Zekrom25]

ok

why am i'm a policy lynch for my chosen target ?

[Zekrom25]

Cabd wants votes for Cabd

[Zekrom25]

@Yates

<-------- 3. the best vig ever

[PeregrineV]

Was going to finish reading but there is so much juicy stuff.

well lookie lookie

two terrible votes by two of my day 1 scumreads

I am SO DOWN for a Marquis lynch

vote Marquis

Yes, it's true.

Vote: Marquis

So how many nights does Zekrom get to not confirm his claim?

VOTE: Zekrom25

Given your experience level and game knowledge, and the flip of a town roleblocker, Why would you think that the shot (if true), would not have been blocked?

[PeregrineV]

VOTE: Mollie

Serious vote.

You remind me of Shos when he discredited every single one of my crumbs in OGM. Shos was scum;therefore you are scum by default.

Also;

I think I'm down for a Zek lynch, but not voting because not many people have posted and I don't want a quick lynch to end this day off, tbh.

I feel good about this vote also. ++ to Mala

[PeregrineV]

idk if as a vig my 1 shot was wasted

You could ask the mod how many shots you have remaining.

Do that and get back to us.

[PeregrineV]

Aaaaanyways.

Here's my starting point from my initial skim:

Confirmed Scum:

Zekrom

Probably Scum:

Malakittens
PeregrineV

Lean Scum:

Elyse
Tman

To be sorted:

Deathnote
serrapaladin
pisskop
Yates (formerly Matias)
Untrod Tripod
Nikanor
Porochaz
Pacman
Green Crayons

Lean Town:

Mollie
Ythan
Radiant Cowbells
Marquis

Confirmed Town:

Cabd

I'll rearrange this:

Highly Likely to Be Scum after last 6 pages:

Zekrom

Probably Scum:

Marquis
Mollie

Lean Scum:

Green Crayons

To be sorted:

serrapaladin
pisskop
Yates (formerly Matias)
Pacman
Tman
Ythan

Lean Town:

Malakittens
Radiant Cowbells
Deathnote
Untrod Tripod
Nikanor
Porochaz
Elyse

Confirmed Town:

PeregrineV

[PeregrineV]

Gooner-Cabd can go into "to-be-sorted".

[evilpacman18]

Well this has sorted itself out nicely, like I figured. I'll be voting zekrom whenever people are ready.
It's kind of hard to figure out alignments when people are just voting confirmed scum.
Actually yeah that makes me kind of want to end today, idk what talking can be done now that can't be done more effectively once we have lynched scum and a night kill or two.
I wouldn't think for a second that there's two one shot vigs

vote: zekrom

[Desperado]

Disclaimer: The jokes in this video have absolutely nothing to do with this game of mafia and are meant solely to amuse.

Vote Count 2.1

zekrom25 (9) - Ythan, Untrod Tripod, RadiantCowbells, DeathNote, zekrom25, Malakittens, Green Crayons, Yates, evilpacman18

<---L-1!

Yates (1) - Nikanor
pirate mollie (1) - pirate mollie
Marquis (1) - PeregrineV

Not Voting (8) - Cabd, pisskop, serrapaladin, Elyse, Marquis, Porochaz, tman2nd

The deadline for Day 2 is Thursday, March 6th, at 8:00 PM EST. With 19 people alive, it takes 10 to lynch. Deadline in (expired on 2014-03-06 20:00:00).

[Marquis]

1. Zekrom's claim makes me not want to lynch him today. I say we give him a night to prove whether he's a one-shot vig or not. Zekrom, use your vig shot tonight. Good targets for vig shots are lurkers.
2. Fish still worries me. I want to see if he keeps his word and starts being useful when UT answers his questions. For this reason I ask UT to answer his questions, we can see whether Fish will put his money where his mouth is and start being useful.
3. Elyse is also starting to worry me. She seems sort of active lurky, she's blending in a bit I think and I'm starting to consider her as a target.
4. Pacman is still on my lynch list.
5. UT's looking more town to me, I like the fact he pushed his lynch. It suggests town.
6. Deathnote looks ok to me on a re-read, he seems to actually be scumhunting and trying to find scum. His later posts are a bit spammy though.

Yep, I think my vote on Fish is now concrete. That looks like a slip to me. Not sure what it says about Elyse though.

Ok, you didn't. You said it could be tested. To me tested means that you can figure out one way or the other what his alignment is. I'm saying that any test would be inconclusive because there are too many unknown variables out there.

A test has the potential to confirm Zekrom as town. Anything else and we go off our reads of his in-thread play. This is what I'm advocating.

wait

i don't get why gooner didn't even push on zek after the claim

like

wouldn't you even at least try to help push the zek lynch if you knew his claim directly clashed with yours, which was still at that time an entirely possible lynch wagon? i can sort of understand wanting to just kill him at night, but wouldn't it be more profitable to at least

try

to lynch zekrom so you can use your vig shot on someone else you find scummy if the lynch goes through?

adding to that, gooner was trying to lynch the doctor claim instead of the one-shot vig claim??????????????????????????????????? cabd or someone explaaaaain???

i'm really hesitant to bring this up in case cabd is just fakeclaiming to better secure a lynch on zekrom in which case i might have ruined that but i don't even care if that's the case because the fact that people were going to let zekrom continue without ever confirming himself was silly, cabd shouldn't have had to claim today but he did???? and idek

nika why did you say gooner is conf scum or w/e idek but this whole scenario doesn't actually add up with cabd here now. like zekrom's reaction to being wagoned, attempting to replace out like that should practically confirm him as scum but now i'm just paranoid of him not being scum but just a town one-shot douchebag

also maybe possibly slight scumread on poro for being like "that idea sucked and you guys suck" only now when a zekrom lynch is almost guaranteed if not guaranteed already with the hammer

[Marquis]

never mind i take that back about poro he wanted the zekrom lynch 4 for you poro you go poro

[Green Crayons]

I'm having paranoid thoughts about despy putting in double 1-shot vigs. From what I've seen zek's level of shitness doesn't actually correlate to his alignment, so I'm not convinced by yesterday.

This came to mind, but Cabd specifically said that he targeted Zek, and that the kill didn't go through. So one of them has to be lying, unless if there was a scenario in which Zek was protected (why would doc protect a one-night vig when it was

this

one-night vig?) or where Cabd was blocked.

[Green Crayons]

Z-man. Who did you target.

That did almost nothing for me. Liking Marquis less, UT less.

Cabd

Also, just noticed this post. Both claimed one-shot vigs targeted each other? (Note that Zek claimed to target Cabd prior to Cabd's coming out.) If Zek flips town, Cabd is scuuuuuuuuuuuuuum.

[Untrod Tripod]

unvote

no one hammer before Cabd gets done with his in depth analysis plz

[Untrod Tripod]

I absolutely want Zekrom to die, but I want to let Cabd do his thing first. It's useful regardless of his alignment tbqh.

[Marquis]

Oi oi back the fuck up.

Zekrom is CONFIRMED FUCKING SCUM right here boys and girls.

VOTE: zekrom

I'm the actual fucking oneshot vig. I tried to shoot him last night, fucker's probably mafia bulletproof.

Votes not for zekrom or me are scumclaims past this line:


------------------------------------------

zekrom's behavior makes me like 90% sure he's scum especially with the replace out move

but the gooner/cabd action decisions also make me paranoid of cabd??????? like why try to lynch fish > zekrom day 1

[PeregrineV]

Will look into this.

Good job Marquis.


@UT- you can take the hammer when you think he's done.

Vote: Zekrom