NY 170: Georgetown II (Game Over)

[emogirl123]

Well, let's look at your recent posts...

This one is defense of yourself.
Before that was a defense of yourself and mild poke on Aegor about the countdown (a town tell on Aegor from my perspective, frankly) Also a promise to read and post...that was posted over 24 hours ago...hows that read going?
Before that was defense of yourself
Before that was agreeing you were a good policy lynch.
Before that was a self vote.
Before that was a prod dodge.
Before that was a v/la announcement
Before that was a promise of reading...that was posted over four weeks ago...hows that read going?
Before that was a prod dodge.
Before that was a prod dodge
Before that was complaining about ending the day prior to getting info from people (not that you're doing anything with said info)
Before that was asking for an L-1 wagon to halt.
Before that you voted EmoGirl with no case presented.
Before that was asking for abbreviation definitions.
Before that the game hadn't started.

This is a very good representation of what you have been doing this game. So if you were reading after post 15xx something, I really don't see the effort afterwards. Of the limited content you have provided us, there is nothing you have done that can rule out for us the possibility of you being scum together with ABR.

Explain your aegor vote please.

[inHimshallibe]

Good on you, Thor.

vote: Bulbazak

This one dies Today imo.

[inHimshallibe]

ABR's scumflip strongly suggests Bulbascum. I'll go into more detail when I don't have to clean before friends get here for the weekend.

[Sotty7]

Good on you, Thor.

vote: Bulbazak

This one dies Today imo.

Totally down for this.

Vote: Bulb

[emogirl123]

whatever, only two scum left anyways. ABR was awfully transparent.

VOTE: Bulbazak should have died day 1.

[Aegor]

From my notes:

Code: Select all

979 -- inHim ABR defense
983 -- crap ABR vote
992 -- Sotty reluctance to vote ABR
998 -- Bulba switches focus
1575 -- HS steals attention with Bulba vote
1609 -- kab vote on policy
1638 -- Rainbowdash
1656 -- ED deflection
Chevre opposed wagon

inHim calls ABR town in post 979. Zekrom's vote for ABR in post 983 is horribad. Sotty soft-defends ABR in Post 992 and then tries to direct attention toward Zdenek. Post 994 begins Bulba's persistent soft defense/complete indifference to the ABR wagon. No me gusta. HighShroomish comes out of nowhere to vote Bulba in Post 1575, so Bulb and HighShroomish are probably not buddies because derailing a wagon on a buddy in favor of a wagon on another buddy makes little sense. Post 1609 is RB's redirection of the focus onto kab. This coupled with Zekrom's bad vote and RB's lip service to being okay with lurker lynches but never mentioning ABR is just bad, q.v. 1638 as well. Finally, ED deflects attention by voting me and has ABR firmly in the middle of the read list.

Lynch pool today: Bulb, Rainbow, Emerald. Fine with inHim as well.

Also fine with a kab lynch, although given the associations and his being the target of a counterwagon, he is no longer high-priority.

VOTE: Bulb

[emogirl123]

Aegor, thoughts on Chevre?

[emogirl123]

Spoiler: VOTE: Chevre is scum.

Refer to Day 1 around page 12 where ABR starts asking a bunch of fluffy fluff at which point both NS and Chevre also voted for me. This should get Chevre lynched before Bulba.

[emogirl123]

Last scum is Bulba/Rainbow. Also could be a wildcard like kabooooom, but who cares. We out number scum significantly and can win using process of elimination anyways.

[Bulbazak]

bulba, you keep falling back on how I am scum and you have multiple people tell you that I am town. let's solve this first, why am I scum?

Day 1 reasons + multiple slot replacements + Appeal to Majority + commenting on the NK

Good on you, Thor.

vote: Bulbazak

This one dies Today imo.

I also do not like this. His appeal to Thor makes me uncomfortable.

Aegor, I've shown in multiple games that I do not like lynching a slot that is getting replaced, especially when I can lynch a scumread instead. ABR was a policy lynch, and I felt at the time that it was a bad lynch. Given the same circumstances, I'd resist the wagon again. It's disturbing to me that you are looking only at people who opposed the wagon when ABR flaked, and not associations between people when ABR was active.

Vote Emogirl123

[Thor665]

@Mod

@Bulba - can you walk me through your Emogirl thoughts? As far as that slot's relation to ABR goes...I pretty strongly read town right now, so I'm curious what you see that I'm missing.
Also, if INHim's appeal to me (which was pretty blatant) makes you uncomfortable, I'd love to also hear why Emo is scummier than him.

[inHimshallibe]

Credit where credit is due imo. Thor helped me see the light, at least.

[Thor665]

I did? I don't even remember discussing the issue with you. Your non-presence is one of my issues with your slot.

[Chevre]

V-LAish conditions due to a broken laptop. I have other methods of posting but they are particularly slow and finicky.

[Thor665]

Lynch pool today: Bulb, Rainbow, Emerald. Fine with inHim as well.

Emerald is pretty obv. town. How do you see it otherwise?

In other news, I'll also toss High Shroomish into the town pool.

[inHimshallibe]

@Nero
@Zdenek

I just had a pair of games back to back with ABR where I was scum and he was town both times.
He is not AtEing, he is not pulling shoddy gambits, and he is not yelling at anyone about how bad they play.
Let's vote him now.

You're also allowed to do your own research to see if you think my case holds merit.

He kinda did this with Slandaar, unless you mean to imply he'd just keep on keeping on.

He kinda did this with Slandaar, unless you mean to imply he'd just keep on keeping on.

If he "kinda" did it Day 1 and failed to do anything Day 2-3 I'm not sure what you think I'm missing.

Then:

Mod: This game moves too fast for me; replace me please

This may be the most unusual combination of quote and player I've had the privilege of quoting.

And thus I realized there was a change in ABR's play, so credit to you.

[Aegor]

UNVOTE:

VOTE: RainbowDash

Also kab should die if he is still useless by the end of this game day.

[Sotty7]

Rainbow is a good second option at this point, but Bulb pushing on emo again is just ridiculous. Dismissing ABR as policy. Yeah, ick.

[HighShroomish]

Whhhhhhhaaaa. Why is Bulba scum?

[emogirl123]

bulba, you keep falling back on how I am scum and you have multiple people tell you that I am town. let's solve this first, why am I scum?

Day 1 reasons + multiple slot replacements + Appeal to Majority + commenting on the NK

ABR was a policy lynch

Dude, no!

t's disturbing to me that you are looking only at people who opposed the wagon when ABR flaked, and not associations between people when ABR was active.

Okay, let's put aside your shit for every phase so far this game where you default to "my scum read, the emogirl slot, is still alive so this means I can just coast with

emogirl is scum

every phase with zero effort just for everyone to dismiss your claims yet you still default to that point. Let's put aside that. In this post alone you try to justify my lynch without even referencing my interactions with ABR. Then you say that it is disturbing no one is looking at the associations between people when ABR was alive when I was the main aggressor along with yessiree on ABR for Day 1.

[emogirl123]

Bulbazak's latest post is so bad he completely ignored all of Tebow's points. If he has any hint of being a decent player, it earns him a lynch.

I still stand by this. The level of ignorance Bulba displayed this entire game can only justified by him being scum. Nothing else makes sense. Who has a meta read on this guy? I never played a game with him before.

[emogirl123]

Whhhhhhhaaaa. Why is Bulba scum?

The kill is null. If anybody tries to lynch someone off of the fact that Fonz was reading them as scum before he was killed, from this point on I will do everything in my power to lynch you. Same if you try to town-read someone.

And dammit Garmr, I'm just about to start going after Bulbazak in the morning... For now-

VOTE: BULBA

??

[kabooooom]

Well, let's look at your recent posts...

This one is defense of yourself.
Before that was a defense of yourself and mild poke on Aegor about the countdown (a town tell on Aegor from my perspective, frankly) Also a promise to read and post...that was posted over 24 hours ago...hows that read going?
Before that was defense of yourself
Before that was agreeing you were a good policy lynch.
Before that was a self vote.
Before that was a prod dodge.
Before that was a v/la announcement
Before that was a promise of reading...that was posted over four weeks ago...hows that read going?
Before that was a prod dodge.
Before that was a prod dodge
Before that was complaining about ending the day prior to getting info from people (not that you're doing anything with said info)
Before that was asking for an L-1 wagon to halt.
Before that you voted EmoGirl with no case presented.
Before that was asking for abbreviation definitions.
Before that the game hadn't started.

This is a very good representation of what you have been doing this game. So if you were reading after post 15xx something, I really don't see the effort afterwards. Of the limited content you have provided us, there is nothing you have done that can rule out for us the possibility of you being scum together with ABR.

Explain your aegor vote please.

he said he is comfortable with my or ABR lynch, but when ABR has more votes he wants me to get lynched first and ABR later..i dont see town doing that. looked to me like he wanted me lynched and then next day he would try to divert attention to some other player.

[kabooooom]

Lynch pool today: Bulb, Rainbow, Emerald. Fine with inHim as well.

Emerald is pretty obv. town. How do you see it otherwise?

In other news, I'll also toss High Shroomish into the town pool.

what do you think of scotty and why?

[kabooooom]

unvote

also how is bulb scum?